Who will win the Best and Fairest at each club?

[Blues_Man]

Would tip Howlett to be runner up.

really ?? He has looked pretty ordinary this Year

 

[Lord Nicholson]

...touche.

 

[eaglespremiers]

Would tip Howlett to be runner up.

Sounds about right:
1. Watson
2. Howlett
3. Dempsey
4. Stanton
5. Crameri
6. Jetta
7. Fletcher
8. Bellchambers
9. Heppell
10. Hooker

What do you think?

 

[eaglespremiers]

From West Coast I think:
1. Selwood
2. Gaff
3. Cox
4. Glass
5. Naitanui
6. Darling
7. Shuey
8. Schofield
9. Hurn
10. Kerr/Priddis

 

[yaco55]

Sounds about right:
1. Watson
2. Howlett
3. Dempsey
4. Stanton
5. Crameri
6. Jetta
7. Fletcher
8. Bellchambers
9. Heppell
10. Hooker

What do you think?

watson
howlett
fletcher
stanton
crameri
dempsey
hooker
heppell
hardingham
davey

 

[yaco55]

From West Coast I think:
1. Selwood
2. Gaff
3. Cox
4. Glass
5. Naitanui
6. Darling
7. Shuey
8. Schofield
9. Hurn
10. Kerr/Priddis

glass
sellwood
cox
hurn
priddis
gaff
natanui
waters
kerr
darling

 

[skittler]

Reckon Swallow would be a certainty to bring it home at North.

 

[Tuck In]

Hawthorn:

Birchall
Mitchell
Sewell

(new club rule, name must end in double l or not eligible)

 

[Schauermann]

Luke McPharlin will win the Freo B&F i would think. Pav has been great no doubt but Luke Mac has been just sensational all year.

Probably, but McPharlin didn't poll well last year. So I expect Pav to win...

Both deserving anyhow...

 

[Lord Nicholson]

Sounds about right:
1. Watson
2. Howlett
3. Dempsey
4. Stanton
5. Crameri
6. Jetta
7. Fletcher
8. Bellchambers
9. Heppell
10. Hooker

What do you think?

Dempsey too high, Fletcher too low, Jetta in the top 10 would be offensive.

Carlisle might get a look-in. Hurley too. Haven't really sat down and figured it out.

Might come fairly close to resembling our board's MVP, but the coaching staff love Howlett a little bit more.

 

[Coaster2012]

I hope Waters wins it for West Coast, all Australian half back surely, think he deserves it, I don't think Priddis has had a good end to the season

 

[Baldur]

Like the other Saints fans here, Dempster for me.

There are a number of other Saints players who have had good years, but most of them have also had injury limit their number of games as well.

Don't really see enough of the other teams but
GWS - Greene
Richmond - Cotchin

Appear to be standouts

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

Adelaide: Thompson
Brisbane: Redden
Carlton: Simpson/McLean
Collingwood: Beams
Essendon: Watson
Fremantle: Pavlich
Geelong: Selwood
Gold Coast: Ablett
GWS: Greene/Ward
Hawthorn: Mitchell
Melbourne: Jones
North Melbourne: Swallow/Thompson
Port Adelaide: Brad Ebert
Richmond: Cotchin
St Kilda: Dempster
Sydney: Jack/Kennedy
West Coast: Cox
Western Bulldogs: Boyd

 

[Roby]

Like the other Saints fans here, Dempster for me.

There are a number of other Saints players who have had good years, but most of them have also had injury limit their number of games as well.

Don't really see enough of the other teams but
GWS - Greene
Richmond - Cotchin

Appear to be standouts

I also think Greene has been better, but they way they have been talking up Ward, I think they will give it to him. Also Ward has done a lot of defensive stuff that coaches like.

 

[Freomaniac]

Mcpharlin will win freo IMO

I agree with that one as Hes been good all season.

Pav Struggled to kick goals in the 1st half playing in the Midfield. Will come close to winning it due to his 2nd half Performances.

 

[Scotland]

1. S Selwood
2. Cox
3. Gaff
4. Glass
5. Hurn
6. Darling
7. Naitanui
8. Shuey
9. Kerr
10. Waters

Masten a big chance to finish top 10. Priddis and Mackenzie outside chances.

Kennedy missed the top 10 last year kicking 59 goals. LeCras also missed, likewise Schofield.

The West Coast Club Champion is heavily weighted towards playing every game. 7 players played 25 games in 2011, all made the top 10. 3 played 24, Lynch was the only one of those to miss out. Naitanui played 23 and was the only player in the top 10 to do so.

 

[pazza]

1. Watson
2. Dempsey
3. Howlett
4. Bellchambers
5. Stanton
--------------------
6. Fletcher
7. Davey
8. Crameri
9. Hurley
10. Carlisle

 

[Wizard]

1. McPharlin
2. Pavlich
3. Hill
4. Mundy
5. Crowley
6. Johnson
7. McPhee
8. Pearce
9. Mayne
10. Ibbotson

DeBoer, Barlow, Ballantyne, Mzungu all a chance for top 10 also.

 

[nicky1995]

For Sydney - J. Kennedy and T. Richards cannot separate them. Either one would be deserving

 

[robstewart23]

Car - Simpson
Coll - Beams
Ess - Watson
WB - Boyd
Geel - Selwood
Haw - Mitchell
Melb - Jones
North - Swallow
Rich - Cotchin
Stk - Hayes
Syd - Kennedy
Ade - Dangerfield/Thompson
PA - Ebert
WCE - Cox/Priddis
Fre - Pavlich
Bris - Rockcliff/Redden
GC - Ablett
GWS - Ward

NM B&F is mid-nov so here is the review of my other selections:​

Hits - Adel, Coll, Ess, GC, GWS, Haw, Melb, Rich, Stk, Syd, WB​

Misses – Bris (Patfull), Car (Scotland), Geel (Hawkins), PA (Cornes), WCE (Selwood), Freo (Crowley)​

Surprises – Crawley, Maine and Johnson finishing ahead of Pavlich at Freo; Breast ahead of Buddy at Hawks; Maxwell in top five at pies; Milne and NicNat AA but not in top 10 at club.​

 

[Natho]

Scooter Selwood surprised me a little winning the eagles bnf. Thought his last handful of games were a little bit down. Very well deserved win no doubt.