WRFL Div 1 Discussion 2023

[Robos]

Has been playing local footy and in Tassie since being delisted, meant hasn't played in the AFL since 2015.

Pretty sure he has been playing Northern Territory and Geelong league lately

 

[Turbos mail]

Drafted by GWS around 2011, traded to the Bulldogs a few years later, played about 20 AFL games, a lot more AFL Reserves games. Hasn't played AFL since 2015.

Yes was Capt/coach of a GVFL side. Can play!

What’s the salary cap as could PC be in trouble? Oh yeah Deer Park said it’s fine go for it.

 

[Dogs till i die]

Yes was Capt/coach of a GVFL side. Can play!

What’s the salary cap as could PC be in trouble? Oh yeah Deer Park said it’s fine go for it.

The friendship factor could apply here, Darley would have played with Clay Smith and Dahlhaus at the Dogs, maybe his $ not as high as it could have been elsewhere.

Think PC would be coming off a low base with their cap, am guessing though.

I'll say it again, the salary cap is unenforceable at local level, stick with a points system.

 

[Squeeky Clean]

Reckon the sharks up the road that have basically recruited a full side would be paying more. 16-17 point cook juniors running out each week.

 

[BEST OF EDFL]

The friendship factor could apply here, Darley would have played with Clay Smith and Dahlhaus at the Dogs, maybe his $ not as high as it could have been elsewhere.

Think PC would be coming off a low base with their cap, am guessing though.

I'll say it again, the salary cap is unenforceable at local level, stick with a points system.

Agree

Give less points to the clubs who are fortunate geographically to have full book of juniors and more to the clubs that don’t

Also allow more points to clubs promoted a division

 

[ROOS77]

Agree

Give less points to the clubs who are fortunate geographically to have full book of juniors and more to the clubs that don’t

Also allow more points to clubs promoted a division

Which clubs do you think are fortunate enough ?

Promoted clubs do get more points than the top teams now

 

[Hank Heavenly]

How did the league go in all the junior interleague comps? How does the league compare to other leagues at the junior level?

 

[Squeeky Clean]

How did the league go in all the junior interleague comps? How does the league compare to other leagues at the junior level?

Reasonably well

 

[Robos]

Altona by 20
Pc by 6
caro by 50
wb by 20

 

[Betterthedevilyouknow]

Werribee undefeated so you couldn’t possibly tip against them but Spotswoods form had been pretty good of late so in saying that I think every game this weekend is a genuine 50/50.

WD, PC, Caro & Alt all favs but it would not surprise me if any 3 of them get rolled.

 

[ROOS77]

Altona by 20
Pc by 6
caro by 50
wb by 20

Altona by 6
PC by 30
CS by 70
WD by 65

 

[ROOS77]

Werribee undefeated so you couldn’t possibly tip against them but Spotswoods form had been pretty good of late so in saying that I think every game this weekend is a genuine 50/50.

WD, PC, Caro & Alt all favs but it would not surprise me if any 3 of them get rolled.

I think only Yarraville could upset Altona. I’ve looked at the teams and Altona have a lot of players who play twos normally

 

[Dogs till i die]

Altona by 25
PC by 29
CS by 65
WD by 30

 

[flamethrower]

Werribee undefeated so you couldn’t possibly tip against them but Spotswoods form had been pretty good of late so in saying that I think every game this weekend is a genuine 50/50.

WD, PC, Caro & Alt all favs but it would not surprise me if any 3 of them get rolled.

Sharks have key talls missing at the moment - Dogs should have a comfortable afternoon.

 

[Squeeky Clean]

Sharks have key talls missing at the moment - Dogs should have a comfortable afternoon.

Dogs missing about 12 blokes so result not a surprise

 

[bushandburbs]

Dogs missing about 12 blokes so result not a surprise

Every side has players missing this time of year - just got get it right at business end - good for comp not seeing cricket scores in 2023 unlike previous seasons - is it true Sharks fallen short under 6pts in 5 games - give them credit for having a crack each week surely Squeeky


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Squeeky Clean]

Every side has players missing this time of year - just got get it right at business end - good for comp not seeing cricket scores in 2023 unlike previous seasons - is it true Sharks fallen short under 6pts in 5 games - give them credit for having a crack each week surely Squeeky


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

100%

Although their competivness is probably a reason why Hoppers are no good

 

[#thebont4]

Werribee will go through the year undefeated and win the flag.. there isn’t a team that can challenge them this year.. Altona are cooked

 

[Robos]

Every side has players missing this time of year - just got get it right at business end - good for comp not seeing cricket scores in 2023 unlike previous seasons - is it true Sharks fallen short under 6pts in 5 games - give them credit for having a crack each week surely Squeeky


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Sharks are doing well coming up , very competitive and could have beat PC both times and others ! Certainly not the easy beats
Comp has come down except districts!

 

[Squeeky Clean]

Real

Sharks are doing well coming up , very competitive and could have beat PC both times and others ! Certainly not the easy beats
Comp has come down except districts!

Realistically, sharks played at 45/46 points, and PCFC were missing Robinson, Dalhaus, Deery, Darley, Eggmolose-Smith, Schiavello, Lui, Wyatt, Tsapopolis.

I'd argue the Sharks have missed a golden opportunity

 

[Dogs till i die]

Real
Realistically, sharks played at 45/46 points, and PCFC were missing Robinson, Dalhaus, Deery, Darley, Eggmolose-Smith, Schiavello, Lui, Wyatt, Tsapopolis.

I'd argue the Sharks have missed a golden opportunity

Probably did miss an opportunity, but saw PCC the week before lead CS into the last quarter and still maintain they are the best side to come up for a long, long time.

 

[Squeeky Clean]

Probably did miss an opportunity, but saw PCC the week before lead CS into the last quarter and still maintain they are the best side to come up for a long, long time.

Not disputing that.

If they had of played their best footy on Saturday they would have won.

Because if those blokes played, Point Cook are a 10 goal better side than what they put out on Saturday.

 

[Robos]

Probably did miss an opportunity, but saw PCC the week before lead CS into the last quarter and still maintain they are the best side to come up for a long, long time.

Very true , they are very competitive compared to previous teams coming up

 

[Squeeky Clean]

Very true , they are very competitive compared to previous teams coming up

Caro, altona, Hoppers and spotty all probably not as strong as previous years, so it could also be a false economy

 

[Robos]

Caro, altona, Hoppers and spotty all probably not as strong as previous years, so it could also be a false economy

Good for footy , top has dropped off but definite bottom few has picked up !