Which of these players would get a game in your teams 22

[cartman48]

As if Stokes would get a game ahead of Davis. Or play on the ground ahead of Medhurst.

Stokes showed his true colours in last years GF - passenger is a word for him - I'd pick every player on Melbournes list ahead of Stokes.

 

[DanA]

Birchall Croad Maxwell
Swan 'Campbell Brown' L Hodge
Bateman Mitchell Thomas
Didak Roughead Rioli
Medhurst Franklin Williams
Foll: Campbell Sewell Lewis
Inter: Fraser Ladson Pendlebury Osbourne Dew Young Ellis (Could leave any of them out)

You don't rate H.Shaw?

 

[DanA]

Stokes showed his true colours in last years GF - passenger is a word for him - I'd pick every player on Melbournes list ahead of Stokes.

LOL
Stokes was injured and should never have played.

 

[Juddbemetron]

Try not too use your Collingwood hater blinkers on & be as honest as possible.. I am just curious to see who people would take from this team

Obrien Prestigiamco Maxwell

Goldsack Brown H Shaw

Clarke Pendelbury Thomas

Didak Cloke Davis

Medhurst Rocca Rusling

Foll:Fraser Swan Obree

Inter: Wood lockyer Sidebottom Anthony

them

 

[Collins-Langford-Ayres]

Try not too use your Collingwood hater blinkers on & be as honest as possible.. I am just curious to see who people would take from this team

Obrien Prestigiamco Maxwell

Goldsack Brown H Shaw

Clarke Pendelbury Thomas

Didak Cloke Davis

Medhurst Rocca Rusling

Foll:Fraser Swan Obree

Inter: Wood lockyer Sidebottom Anthony

Not many. Who do you think would get again in Hawthorn's team?

I'd take Maxwell, Brown, Pendles, Thomas, Medhurst and Didak for starters, but doubt all would walk into our 22.

 

[X_box_X]

Stokes is a premiership player. Are Davis or Medhurst?

So is Shannon Byrnes, LOL.

In fact, how's this for a team of premiership players since 2000:

BA: Bevan, Gilham, Dempster
HB: Copeland, Lewis Roberts-Thompson, Mathews
CE: Byrnes, Shattock, Heffernan
HF: Mahoney, Thurstans, R. Jones
FO: Moorcroft, Keating, Armstrong
RU: Renouf, Blumfield, Hadley
INT: B. MacDonald, Wojcinski, Bishop, N. Ablett

 

[WEARECOLLINGWOOD!]

them

lol/// Carlron would take our whole backline & evry forward player we hav except for Rooca..

 

[Pied Avenger]

Stokes is a premiership player. Are Davis or Medhurst?

Great thread for a change.
Nice to see intelligent thought put in across the board rather than pointless trolling.
As to the quote, Stokes played in an awesome side in 2007, I'm not sure he would be the diffference in winning or losing a GF.

 

[MC_9]

Hawks and Pies team i Would have.

C.Brown N.Brown H.Shaw
G.Birchall T.Croad L.Hodge
C.Bateman S.Mitchell S.Pendelbury
A.Didak L.Franklin L.Davis
C.Rioli J.Roughead M.Williams
R.Campbell B.Sewell D.Swan
J.Fraser J.Lewis X.Ellis D.Thomas

14 Hawks 8 Pies

Pretty good team there.

 

[Herne Hill Hammer]

Best team:
FB: Milburn Scarlett Shaw
HB: Enright Brown Harley
C: Corey Ling Swan
HF: S.Johnson Cloke Didak
FF: Stokes Mooney Chapman
R: Ottens Ablett Bartel
Int: Frazer Selwood Medhurst Taylor
Unlucky: Pendlebury, Thomas, Hunt, Wojcinski

It seems a bit harsh but I can only fit 7 into my side with some players I really rate missing out.

Shaw, no.
Fraser for Blake, yes
Cloke for Lonergan, yes.
Medhurst and Didak for Stokes and Varcoe, yes.
Pendlebury, no.
I like Thomas and Swan but who do they push out? Maybe one of them for Wojcinski.
Brown for Taylor? Perhaps.
Davis for S.Johnson or Chapman? No.

4 definates and 2 maybes.

 

[X_box_X]

Hawks and Pies team i Would have.

C.Brown N.Brown H.Shaw
G.Birchall T.Croad L.Hodge
C.Bateman S.Mitchell S.Pendelbury
A.Didak L.Franklin L.Davis
C.Rioli J.Roughead M.Williams
R.Campbell B.Sewell D.Swan
J.Fraser J.Lewis X.Ellis D.Thomas

14 Hawks 8 Pies

Pretty good team there.

Surely two of Thomas, Medhurst or Maxwell will replace two of Birchall, Rioli and Ellis.

 

[cartman48]

You don't rate H.Shaw?

Not really - not over some of our premiership players - won't pick Shaw in the Cats best 22 either.

 

[lemmon]

Stokes is a premiership player. Are Davis or Medhurst?

Mate i could have lined up in the forward pocket against Port and it wouldnt have changed the result. Premiership medals have no bearing on rating a players quality IMO, its about the team around you.

 

[cartman48]

Surely two of Thomas, Medhurst or Maxwell will replace two of Birchall, Rioli and Ellis.

Thomas yes but not the other two - can't believe you left Young out - all our drive forward comes through Young and Bateman.

 

[jonoman89]

Obrien Prestigiamco Maxwell

Goldsack Brown H Shaw

Clarke Pendelbury Thomas

Didak Cloke Davis

Medhurst Rocca Rusling

Foll:Fraser Swan Obree

Inter: Wood lockyer Sidebottom Anthony

 

[blues_gibbzy]

Obrien Prestigiamco Maxwell

Goldsack Brown H Shaw

Clarke Pendelbury Thomas

Didak Cloke Davis

Medhurst Rocca Rusling

Foll:Fraser Swan Obree

Inter: Wood lockyer Sidebottom Anthony

Same for me but did you take Sidebottom for the future?

 

[StringyDog]

Maxwell, Lake, Morris
Shaw, Williams, Gilbee
Cross, Boyd, Griffen
Didak, Cloke, Murphy
Davis, Rocca, Johnson
Hudson, Cooney, Swan
Fraser, Pendlebury, Giansiracusa, Higgins

9/22 Pies.

I might have missed one or two.

You don't rate Akermanis...and you have Hackswell in the team lol

I would put it;

Hargrave, Lake, Morris
Shaw, Williams, Gilbee
Cross, Boyd, Griffen
Didak, Cloke, Murphy
Medhurst, Johnson, Ackermanis
Hudson, Cooney, Swan
Davis, Pendlebury, Giansiracusa, Higgins

7/22 Pies with Thomas (Higgins), N.Brown (Williams) unlucky as about on par

 

[Silvagnis]

My effort

Try not too use your Collingwood hater blinkers on & be as honest as possible.. I am just curious to see who people would take from this team

Obrien Prestigiamco Maxwell

Goldsack Brown Shaw

Clarke Pendelbury Thomas

Didak Cloke Davis

Medhurst Rocca Rusling

Foll:Fraser Swan Obree

Inter: Wood lockyer Sidebottom Anthony

Heath is now the only Shaw on your list.

B: Thornton Jamison Shaw

HB: Bower Waite Grigg

C: Stevens Gibbs Simpson

HF: Didak Cloke Davis

F: Medhurst Fevola Betts

Foll: Kreuzer Judd Murphy

Inter: Yarran Hadley Walker Warnock/Hampson

Toss of the coin between a fully fit Hadley and Swan.

Hadley used the ball better than Swan in our round four win over the Pies.

 

[DanA]

Re: My effort

I'd do a bit more culling at Carlton:

B: Thornton Brown Shaw

HB: Gibbs Waite Grigg

C: Stevens Swan Pendlebury

HF: Didak Cloke Thomas

F: Medhurst Fevola Davis

Foll: Fraser Judd Murphy

Inter: Kreuzer Maxwell Simpson Walker

Toss of the coin between a fully fit Hadley and Swan.[/quote]

 

[DOCKER MAN]

Obrien Prestigiamco Maxwell

Goldsack Brown H Shaw

Clarke Pendelbury Thomas

Didak Cloke Davis

Medhurst Rocca Rusling

Foll:Fraser Swan Obree

Inter: Wood lockyer Sidebottom Anthony

 

[treefingers]

Didak and Pendlebury would fit in very well in the hawks side.

 

[X_box_X]

Rusling's injuries make him useless. Collingwood might as well have Brian Straughn lining up for them instead.

 

[Jeremias]

Brown
Shaw
Pendelbury
Thomas
Didak
Cloke
Davis
Medhurst
Swan

 

[Jeremias]

Re: My effort

I'd do a bit more culling at Carlton:

B: Thornton Brown Shaw

HB: Gibbs Waite Grigg

C: Stevens Swan Pendlebury

HF: Didak Cloke Thomas

F: Medhurst Fevola Davis

Foll: Fraser Judd Murphy

Inter: Kreuzer Maxwell Simpson Walker

Good effort that, but there is no way in hell that Maxwell would get a game in front of Bower or Jamison.

 

[X_box_X]

Re: My effort

Good effort that, but there is no way in hell that Maxwell would get a game in front of Bower or Jamison.

LOL

Maxwell second in the competition in one percenters last year. Also the Collingwood captain... I like the way he goes about his footy.

Bower, LOL...