Competitions 2012 Dream Team and Supercoach questions here

[Jimmy_the_Gent]

I have both Pfieffer and Gray and while I know Gray should be kill, I'm thinking about starting Pfieffer ahead of him just while Gray gets back into it.

Is that a smart move or is sadly foolish?

Thanks.

 

[Schulzenfest]

Gray will be better for the run last week and Pfeiffer is a reasonable chance of being the sub. I'd play it safe if I were you.

 

[ADA23]

Hey all
What are the chances of Redden playing this week?

 

[The Smaller Warrior]

Pretty good, think you will find out tonight/tomorrow aswell due to the SANFL game on Wednesday.

 

[Big Red Machine]

Any chance of Hitchcock playing in the next couple of weeks?

 

[mulz]

gday guys, didnt see the game on saturday, how did darren pfeiffer go? do you think he can hold a permanent role in the side? thinking of trading him in this week. cheers.

 

[The Smaller Warrior]

Pfeiffer was fairly impressive, stays in for now.

Hitchcock, nah wouldn't think so.

Phillips and Rodan ahead.

 

[Check-Raise !]

I have both Pfieffer and Gray and while I know Gray should be kill, I'm thinking about starting Pfieffer ahead of him just while Gray gets back into it.

Is that a smart move or is sadly foolish?

Thanks.

Smartest move you'll make all year unfortunately for 'Gray' .

 

[thomas_m18]

I see Aaron Young is looking like a good thing to debut this week. If he does play, is he a sub risk? I see he's racking it up in the SANFL, so I am wondering whether he's a better option to start in my draft league team this week ahead of Sherman, Harper or Milera, none of whom are terrific scorers. I'm just concerned about his role.

 

[Jonts]

I see Aaron Young is looking like a good thing to debut this week. If he does play, is he a sub risk? I see he's racking it up in the SANFL, so I am wondering whether he's a better option to start in my draft league team this week ahead of Sherman, Harper or Milera, none of whom are terrific scorers. I'm just concerned about his role.

Short answer: Yes he is a sub risk

But then again with Matty P calling the shots who knows

 

[Dwight Schrute]

Hey guys will Redden play this week?

 

[The Smaller Warrior]

Reckon so.

Didnt play in the Anzac Day SANFL game.

 

[IDIG]

Hi fellas, what's Renouf's job security like? What actually is the pecking order for your rucks? Is it Lobbe, Renouf, Redden (and maybe Trengove?).

Sorry don't get to see alot of your games.

 

[Jonts]

Hi fellas, what's Renouf's job security like? What actually is the pecking order for your rucks? Is it Lobbe, Renouf, Redden (and maybe Trengove?).

Sorry don't get to see alot of your games.

Reckon you're on the money, but the gap between them all is all very close

Trengove will do less and less ruck in his career, looks like Port are using the D stewart as the second ruckman when they decide not to play two "pure" ruckman

 

[IDIG]

Reckon you're on the money, but the gap between them all is all very close

Trengove will do less and less ruck in his career, looks like Port are using the D stewart as the second ruckman when they decide not to play two "pure" ruckman

So his JS looks ok while Lobbe is out? I don't imagine you'll play 2 out-n-out rucks with so many mobile talls so once Lobbe is back, Renouf makes way?

 

[Jonts]

So his JS looks ok while Lobbe is out? I don't imagine you'll play 2 out-n-out rucks with so many mobile talls so once Lobbe is back, Renouf makes way?

Yer his JS is fine

Honestly have no idea if Lobbe will force D stewart or Renouf out, would come down to form not force any out

 

[IDIG]

Yer his JS is fine

Honestly have no idea if Lobbe will force D stewart or Renouf out, would come down to form not force any out

Thanks mate

 

[Magpie Since 1986]

Pfeiffer what is his JS like? I wanted him at the start of the year but stayed away because Port supporters said on this board he was unlikely to get many games, has that changed or will he be out of the team soon?

Also any chance of Redden playing again soon? I am holding Sandi/Redden/Steph O and will have to dump one of my rucks if none of those three are names this week

 

[FishingRick04]

Pfieffer will be out this week IMO and unlikely to return, he's too slow and hasn't got it, which is a shame for him.

 

[Dwight Schrute]

Hey guys asked this last week but whats the chances of Redden playing this week, he wasnt even an emergency last week, is Renouf performing too well to keep him out?

 

[The Smaller Warrior]

Renouf will be dropped.

Redden will surely be back in, we all had no idea why he did not come back in this week. Strange.

 

[Dwight Schrute]

Renouf will be dropped.

Redden will surely be back in, we all had no idea why he did not come back in this week. Strange.

Really? Thats surprising, was Renouf a depth trade or was he brought in to be a definite number 1 ruck? eg. Maric, anyway thats nice to hear, any chance both will play?

 

[ize_]

Where's Nathan Blee at? I know he had glandular, is that still ongoing or is he playing in the Magoos?

 

[Powerade 08]

Where's Nathan Blee at? I know he had glandular, is that still ongoing or is he playing in the Magoos?

lol what

He played well on the weekend but he's behind 3 of the best performed key defenders in the league in Trengove Chaplin Carlile. Wouldn't hold onto him...

Nathan Blee (for Roosters v Redlegs)
21 disposals, 3 marks, 2 clearances, 1 inside 50, 3 rebound 50s
Blee played down back for North and once again his offensive stuff was very good with 21 possessions and helping North to rebound the footy. He still needs to work on his defensive stuff but led up to the footy a couple of times and turned the ball over a couple of times. What’s impressing us is his ability to get involved in backline transition and we think that will work for us long term.

 

[Satan]

there will plenty of views on this threat sweating on redden with sandi out again

daniel stewart likely to come in?