Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

[kirbatron]

Liam Henry yes!!

 

[burger09]

Like when Norf weren’t nearly as s**t and tried this with both Dusty and Kelly and they took less to not play at Norf.

You forgot DeGoey

 

[TylerDurden]

I understand we are still very much in the queue for Gresham.

Front of the queue yeah?

 

[A1fromDay1]

Front of the queue yeah?

Here's hoping we forgot our ID at home and get kicked outta line

 

[Colloquy]

Seeing Ryan is playing do we need Haynes.

 

[Topiary]

There’s a queue for Gresham?

Yes there is.

 

[Colloquy]

Here's hoping we forgot our ID at home and get kicked outta line

Agree Hopefully we around the corner at the back

 

[Steven Tyler]

Front of the queue yeah?

I hope it’s a far queue to Gresham from us

 

[westhawk]

I don’t get the hate for Gresham.

Henry would be good too but won’t be a Brockman straight swap if Peter Bell has anything to do with it.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Would love Henry, apparently has an offer on the table, but not even looking at it. Peter Bell a nightmare to deal with, especially if Henry keeps going as he is, another 24 possessions today on the wing.

 

[ML4Hodgy]

I’m still hoping for a Wiz/Duursma double.
I suspect that means we need to:
1. Help Melb trade up for Harley Reid. Sliding down from 3-4 cheaply would let WC get 3 and have confidence they’d get Curtain.
2. Trade for GCs first. It’s a straight swap for our future first, although we could add their future second for WB and Melb second Rd picks early or on draft night. (We got Melbs in the Harley deal)

Wiz, Duursma and McCabe would be an absolutely amazing haul.

I don’t want Haynes. Would rather play Blanck, and either Scrimshaw, DGB or Serong (Frost in an emergency). They’ll improve more by playing than in the VFL, even if it costs us some matches.

Happy with Riccardi or Georgiades, but also happy to see how Ryan, Kosi and Lewis go together while we wait for B.King to make his choice.

 

[TylerDurden]

I hope it’s a far queue to Gresham from us

He can play.

 

[play2win]

Interest in both Henry and Ryan…….interesting, and probably designed to promote competition for a player coming the other way.

 

[Gut Runner]

Would love Henry, apparently has an offer on the table, but not even looking at it. Peter Bell a nightmare to deal with, especially if Henry keeps going as he is, another 24 possessions today on the wing.

Melbourne seemed to get a good deal!

 

[Hawks91b]

Henry perfect for us - give us the speed that we need, coming into the good part of his career and will fit into the age profile perfectly. Happy to pay to get him.

 

[Steven Tyler]

Would love Henry, apparently has an offer on the table, but not even looking at it. Peter Bell a nightmare to deal with, especially if Henry keeps going as he is, another 24 possessions today on the wing.

Why does he want out?
He was in Freo’s academy wasn’t he?
seems strange

 

[westhawk]

Why does he want out?
He was in Freo’s academy wasn’t he?
seems strange

Was in Freos academy, but was not happy to be out of the team on a regular basis last year. He wanted out then, but Freo wouldn’t deal.

 

[westhawk]

Melbourne seemed to get a good deal!

That’s because they were stupid enough to get caught up in the hype that Jackson wanted to play for them, which over the years not many have wanted to. It is a different story when a wanted player wants to leave.

 

[Hawkspot]

Would love Henry, apparently has an offer on the table, but not even looking at it. Peter Bell a nightmare to deal with, especially if Henry keeps going as he is, another 24 possessions today on the wing.

He’s nowhere near the player Brad Hill was when we gave him to them for a pick after 30, by Freo’s own logic a f3 should do it.

 

[westhawk]

He’s nowhere near the player Brad Hill was when we gave him to them for a pick after 30, by Freo’s own logic a f3 should do it.

They got a bargain didn’t they. They definitely owe us .

 

[Hawk the Talk]

If Tyler decides to go home - straight swap

As much as Peter Bell is a nightmare to deal with it’d be hard for them to argue it’s not a straight swap. Outside the draft position their value should be pretty close on what they’ve done in their careers to date. Even close to identical in where they are rated in the league

 

[NICE1]

Henry would be a great pickup, so much upside.

Our 2nd tied to the dogs won't be enough to satisfy Fremantle though

He is exactly the sort of player that we need...and of course, fits our preferred age profile

 

[westhawk]

He is exactly the sort of player that we need...and of course, fits our preferred age profile

Perfect replacement if Brockman decides to leave, even though he plays more midfield.

 

[Topiary]

He is exactly the sort of player that we need...and of course, fits our preferred age profile

Unfortunately I agree, because of Peter Bell. However, if we involve Brockman and or DGB, who knows. Depends on what happens with Liam Ryan. We are having a go. Got to land them though. Yesterday wont hurt. Got to improve the List. Got to get better. Really better.

 

[Billyc]

Brockman for Henry is about as fair as a direct player for player trade gets. Similar age, similar performances to date and similar upside.

 

[Hawthorn2023]

What kind of pick/s is Wingard worth on the market?

Similar to t.mitchell? 42 & 50

We need these kind of picks for McCabe bid