Unofficial Preview Changes and pre-match discussion vs Collingwood

[My Left Foote]

PC on 1 leg parked in the F50 would still be better than what Duursma offers up forward

I think your confusing PC with Robbie Nahas.

 

[Roos_03]

Curtis' scan was clear

Where does it say the scan was clear?

 

[The Nostradamus]

Also worth noting this is the last game before the bye

Should be leaving nothing in the tank with a 2 week rest

 

[ohh_v]

Where does it say the scan was clear?

Trust in GR.

 

[grimface_87]

At this point I'm way more scared of the average/bad sides than the good ones. I feel like we could give the Pies a decent crack.

It's mental. If you are playing top teams there isn't the expectation of winning so you play more freely which can help.

Then you have today where we were favourites and expected to win so there is that nervousness of 'what if we mess it up' and as you saw (particularly after we started so well) they went back in their shells and the footy that worked so well in the first quarter dried up.

I'm sure the same thing will happen against West Coast unfortunately, see last year as an example.

Anyway, changes:

Out: Scott, Duursma
In: Fisher, Curtis

Would like to see Corr out but at the moment he is still the best option we have for that position

 

[koshari]

who goes to Hill? That is the one matchup I am terrified about.

Elliott for mine

 

[Hearts to hearts]

For some reason a Pies outfit with Houston, Long, Perryman and Membrey added in seems infinitely scarier to me. I was confident about our chances of pushing them last year. Not this time, but it'll be bloody grouse if we do

They are a much stronger side this year than last year - not just the additions, but the improvement in Pendlebury and Sidebottom - but I had no confidence in us against Brisbane last week either, so you never know.

 

[FlyHigh18]

Scott out.
Wiphi in to tag Daicos again.
Curtis to replace whatever the fk Duursma is doing.
and a bit of shuffle around the mids and HFs.

 

[roos_fanatic08]

In: Phillips & Ford/Fisher
Out: Scott & Duursma.

Hate Duursma as sub. Hate that we don’t have the depth to get rid of Corr.

Phillips to come in to play an extra defensive hand.

Fisher or Fordy sub.

 

[Horizons_00]

No ****ing WAY Bailey gets a game after that. Sure 5 tackles but 5 disposals lol

 

[rubbers0ul]

Move mckercher back onto a wing …. Should too much as an inside midfielder

 

[shintemaster]

No ****ing WAY Bailey gets a game after that. Sure 5 tackles but 5 disposals lol

Forget the numbers. Had a few beyond ordinary moments. Not even remotely to standard at the moment.

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

Forget the numbers. Had a few beyond ordinary moments. Not even remotely to standard at the moment.

The textbook definition of insipid on numerous occasions.

 

[dus]

Out: Scott, Corr, Durz.
In: Phillips, K. Dawson, Curtis.

Daniel sub.

 

[tazaa]

OUT: Scott Corr Maley
IN: Curtis Phillips Ford

B: Daniel Pink McDonald
HB: Hardeman Comben Ford
C: McKercher LDU Stephens
HF: Sheezel Darling Zurhaar
F: Kostanty Larkey Curtis
R: Xerri Wardlaw Parker
I: Jy FOS Powell Phillips
S: Duursma

 

[Poopybum22]

Was Logue decent in the VFL or do we have to keep carrying Corr?

Out: Scott, Corr, Duursma
In: Curtis, Logue, Fisher/Ford/Harvey (sub)

 

[Frank Thring]

Was Logue decent in the VFL or do we have to keep carrying Corr?

Out: Scott, Corr, Duursma
In: Curtis, Logue, Fisher/Ford/Harvey (sub)

You'd rather carry Logue?

 

[FlyHigh18]

You'd rather carry Logue?

Can they carry each other? Or does that equal out to zero?

 

[giantroo]

Trust in GR.

Where does it say the scan was clear.

Sammy Edmund also mentioned it on radio on Friday.

 

[FlyHigh18]

So is Zurhaar out next week bc of his elephant foot?

 

[Possession]

So is Zurhaar out next week bc of his elephant foot?

Who knows, but he said himself that if he played yesterday then he'll be good for next week.

 

[Horizons_00]

Forget the numbers. Had a few beyond ordinary moments. Not even remotely to standard at the moment.

Agree. That missed tackle and fall was surely enough. He got subbed off too.

 

[Caracas]

Move mckercher back onto a wing …. Should too much as an inside midfielder

Joking aside, McKercher’s tackling is much better in congestion. When he’s out in the open, he makes JMac seem like Paul Curtis.

 

[Ardent Roo]

IN: Payne / Harvey, PC, WDawson (appreciate not banging the door down, but let's see what he's got)
OUT: Konstanty (not doing enough), Scott (ditto), Corr.

 

[Works atErrol St]

Maybe Phillips in.