Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2025 Draft & Trade Thread - Picks 31, 32, 42, 60 and 71

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

If we give away our next 2 first round picks, where does that leave us with our academy players?
I assume what we give up for Serong will be net neutral after what we get back from Buller.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Buller is worth haggling over to get a lower pick. yes he wouldn't have been given the opportunity without injuries this year. however in the game he has played he has been more than respectable. KPF's are expensive commodities in the AFL and at the age of 22 has the best ahead of him, should only get better without ever being a superstar. Plus with Mihocek leaving the Pies the Swans realise how much the Pies need him. We aren't being difficult just trying to get some value back on a bloke who we took a punt on who wasn't drafted, had most of 2024 off with a back injury
 
Buller is worth haggling over to get a lower pick. yes he wouldn't have been given the opportunity without injuries this year. however in the game he has played he has been more than respectable. KPF's are expensive commodities in the AFL and at the age of 22 has the best ahead of him, should only get better without ever being a superstar. Plus with Mihocek leaving the Pies the Swans realise how much the Pies need him. We aren't being difficult just trying to get some value back on a bloke who we took a punt on who wasn't drafted, had most of 2024 off with a back injury
I agree but he is 24 not 22, but still with another preseason more AFL experience he has more upside and development in him. He's only played 10 AFL Games!
 
If we give away our next 2 first round picks, where does that leave us with our academy players?
I assume what we give up for Serong will be net neutral after what we get back from Buller.
Genuinely not worried unless an Academy player is a top 5 pick. Its too easy to match bids even with the rule changes as long as they aren't top 5.

#8 gets matched with 20 and 21

#15 gets matched with 27 and 30
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I'm talking about a CC to Geelong deal. If they deal #19 to St Kilda for Marshall it ends the pursuit of Charlie IMO, unless they can trade a player, who has some serious value and agrees to going to Carlton, plus the '26 & '27 1sts.

And that might also be why the Swans are making sure they are patient. Wait until Geelong shoots their shot and can't negotiate against a Swans deal. It just makes it a little easier for Sydney.

See, this is where things get interesting. The Cats will have to shift a player.... but, who gets that player? Maybe, we are more interested in that player than Curnow? We give Geelong the capital to close on Curnow and Marshall but we get a player we like and hold some capital. If that player was Connor O'Sullivan I'd be a happy man
 
See, this is where things get interesting. The Cats will have to shift a player.... but, who gets that player? Maybe, we are more interested in that player than Curnow? We give Geelong the capital to close on Curnow and Marshall but we get a player we like and hold some capital. If that player was Connor O'Sullivan I'd be a happy man
I've said it before but I'd be interested in Shannon Neale. I'm not sure why he'd want to play 3rd Banana behind Jezza and Curnow
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top