List Mgmt. Trade & F/A - 2020

[jefffff34]

I'm not quite sure what others see in Aish as anything other than depth (which he was for the later half of the season and certainly should not have played the prelim before Scharenburg). Is he statistically important to the structure of our backline?

Our defense with him gave up an average of 70 points, with an 8-6 record (57%).
Without him, our defense gave up an average of 67.2 points, with a record of 8-2 (80%).

Our defense with him vs top 8 teams gave up an average of 76.56 points, with a 5-4 record (56%).
Without him vs top 8 sides, our defense gave up an average of 70.75 points, with a 3-1 record (75%).

Statistically, and our general win/loss record, was better without him, in 2019.

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

Can we expect a similar video when Crocker's delisting is announced?

 

[Piestration]

Greenwood out with the ACL and now Aish gone. They were playing in the side together for a while. Now we have 2 small/med defenders to replace.

I guess Quaynor is best 22 now... Langdon back will help. Depth in that position might be a problem...

I'd rather utilise Varcoe down back than Aish.

 

[Rusty Beam]

The one thing I will give Phillips credit for is that he is often the player that most helps us transition the ball up and down the ground with his gut running. Kind of like a non-damaging Sidebottom.

He’s dependable so with him it just comes down to a discussion on his cost vs how much you lose by having a different player replacing him. He is only a one trick pony though, so he’s a winger or bust and we already have a logjam of outside mids being forced to play inside ineffectively.

But we don’t have a logjam of wingers though. Or guys who can do it well.

From my perspective it has gone back to being a really specialist position again.

 

[sr36]

Shame shame on you. Forgetting one of if not the Greatest Collingwood player of all time.View attachment 764194

Could never forget a player that was so good that he had a Chinese Star sign named after him. I just remember his greatness as having been all year round rather than just confined to one month.

P.S. When we didn't play in finals, I have heard rumours that he used to absolutely dominate in September...

 

[Saintly Viewed]

The one thing I will give Phillips credit for is that he is often the player that most helps us transition the ball up and down the ground with his gut running. Kind of like a non-damaging Sidebottom.

He’s dependable so with him it just comes down to a discussion on his cost vs how much you lose by having a different player replacing him. He is only a one trick pony though, so he’s a winger or bust and we already have a logjam of outside mids being forced to play inside ineffectively.

Could you have just hit the perfect Phillips definition?

I think so.

 

[caloschwaby]

Our defense with him gave up an average of 70 points, with an 8-6 record (57%).
Without him, our defense gave up an average of 67.2 points, with a record of 8-2 (80%).

Our defense with him vs top 8 teams gave up an average of 76.56 points, with a 5-4 record (56%).
Without him vs top 8 sides, our defense gave up an average of 70.75 points, with a 3-1 record (75%).

Statistically, and our general win/loss record, was better without him, in 2019.

And it wouldn't be fair to put it all down to him as if he was the sole reason we were statistically worse on defence (plus it's quite a marginal difference), though it shows that having him in the side didn't make our defense anymore superior than without him.

 

[Piestration]

A 3 year deal with Freo


Start the car. Start the Car

 

[Chrispiesssss]

Anyone else think the trade period should just be 48 hours? That’s it.

How the f can we go like 10 days with barely any trading??

What a waste of time.

 

[Tbone McGraw]

Anyone else think the trade period should just be 48 hours? That’s it.

How the f can we go like 10 days with barely any trading??

What a waste of time.

The AFL love it.

They would have it for a month if they could.

 

[Jafo]

Could never forget a player that was so good that he had a Chinese Star sign named after him. I just remember his greatness as having been all year round rather than just confined to one month.

P.S. When we didn't play in finals, I have heard rumours that he used to absolutely dominate in September...

But he stepped it up come finals. Why do you think no other clubs asked about him? His greatness was just too good for other clubs to even consider.

 

[Tbone McGraw]

A 3 year deal with Freo


Start the car. Start the Car

I wish I understood this post....

 

[Jafo]

A 3 year deal with Freo


Start the car. Start the Car

Josh Carr

 

[BEEG]

If we lose Aish and don't have to hear salary cap squeeze again it will be worth it.

 

[sr36]

But he stepped it up come finals. Why do you think no other clubs asked about him? His greatness was just too good for other clubs to even consider.

Actually, h never got the chance to, but we all know he would have torn the Finals to shreds - possibly to use as a roach in his joint.

 

[Chrispiesssss]

The AFL love it.

They would have it for a month if they could.

I’d be happy if it was a month, if we didn’t have trade radio and all these journalists reporting articles 24/7.

The media create the urgency. They make it out like 14 days isn’t enough, yet nothing happens till the last hour.

 

[regpies]

What will we get from Freo? They have pick 22 which is too much for Aish, then 79. Nothing in the 30-45 range.

St Kilda have no picks in the 30-45 range either so not like Freo will get a pick like that from the Hill trade.

Aish + 35 for Griffin Logue and Freo’s 3rd rd next year (would be around 45)

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

LOOKS GOOD FEELS GREAT TINT A CAR.

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

What will we get from Freo? They have pick 22 which is too much for Aish, then 79. Nothing in the 30-45 range.

St Kilda have no picks in the 30-45 range either so not like Freo will get a pick like that from the Hill trade.

Aish + 35 for Griffin Logue and Freo’s 3rd rd next year (would be around 45)

Pick 7. Original value for Aish.

 

[Tbone McGraw]

I’d be happy if it was a month, if we didn’t have trade radio and all these journalists reporting articles 24/7.

The media create the urgency. They make it out like 14 days isn’t enough, yet nothing happens till the last hour.

That is why the afl love it.

 

[Moore of the Same]

If we lose Aish and don't have to hear salary cap squeeze again it will be worth it.

Don't be absurd. We'll be hearing about it for the next 12 months.

 

[Tbone McGraw]

What will we get from Freo? They have pick 22 which is too much for Aish, then 79. Nothing in the 30-45 range.

St Kilda have no picks in the 30-45 range either so not like Freo will get a pick like that from the Hill trade.

Aish + 35 for Griffin Logue and Freo’s 3rd rd next year (would be around 45)

Future 2nd??

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Lube Mobile will come to you. 13 30 32

 

[manicpie]

I don't rate Noble at all, so that doesn't fill me confidence. Anyway, hope to be proven wrong

How can you say that when he has only played 4 games and might I add 4 reasonable games, he can only improve

 

[sr36]

Pick 7. Original value for Aish.

Six years of AFL development put into him, surely he's increased in value?