List Mgmt. 2019 Draft and Trade Hypotheticals Thread - Part II

[Punts]

If you pay a kings ransom for Daniher and his OP / groin issues are bigger than Ben Hur, then what?

It's also important not to fall behind. We stood our ground - props to Kinnear and the gang.

Now we have picks 5, 25, 32 and 44 - I am very optimistic about the next 2-3 seasons.

In a shit draft

We addressed nothing in the last 2 years besides duds

 

[6yearsold]

Then we're in agreement. I think my original response was addressed to the premise that we needed a few years worth of high draft picks in order to win our next premiership. Which I don't think so as I rate our existing core of young players.

I don't think we are ready yet. Our bottom 4 position agrees.

 

[Mister B]

why?
we have traded in guys like mattner. shaw Bolton Richards kennedy etc, all leaders

St Kilda have proven time and again that adding rated players hasn't stopped controversy and players going off the rails.

 

[blood_lust]

Sooo are you suggesting if we got Daniher and lost papley we'd be contention?
Personally I disagree.

based on what we know, cant argue against us standing firm

time will tell, i just think we have in the past traded well to win 2 flags

seems reluctant to do it anymore

just a shame 2020 will be write off now, guess we can watch buddy (hopefully)

On SM-G960F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[The King!]

why chase him and basically offer papley and next year's?

 

[elastic]

Geez Barrett is a freaking moron.

 

[Donza]

Adrian sounds like shit and has some really shit body language

 

[Swansujelly]

just as I thoguht. Papley stays, Daniher next year, Jones goes.

 

[Tesla Tenet]

Our list is stagnant again

True. Our club created it.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

 

[wizcapper]

9 and a future first confirmed offered.


Wow those idiots. did not accept.

Papley is going to kick 8 against them next season. Take it out on the Bombers Tommy!!!

 

[SSwans2011]

The swans have the most promising young list in the comp.

The irony of you calling anyone else a nuff after posting this is hilarious. You do realise the Lions and Bulldogs (for starters) had teams anout as young as us this year and they have much better young depth?

Our list is shit right now.

 

[Dan87]

Oh wow
Barrett getting stuck in

Nonsense land

 

[The King!]

St Kilda have proven time and again that adding rated players hasn't stopped controversy and players going off the rails.

yes but we prove it fixes our side

 

[WillHayward]

We offered two top 10 picks FFS

That is a good deal for an injured bloke who doesnt play.

 

[Opts]

Awesome trade period on the back of last year.

Least we will have a top 4 pick again next year

And pushing for top 4 in 2021 when our youth are more experienced and we have JD.

 

[elastic]

We didnt improve worry i have is another year in Kennedy and Parker probably a similar finish in 2020 awaits.

We have more younger players on the improve than we have older players on the wane.

 

[lollol]

listening to Damo, he is arguing that because Daniher has a famous family name he is worth heaps..

Yeah no worries, We should have trade Nathan Ablett for Chris Judd back in 05

 

[SeanM]

Monumental mistake to not accept 9 for papley...will get less next year

Another year of Papley is worth it.

It increases our chances of doing well next season. And gives us another year to adjust to losing him.

And if the offer was 9 with 25 going back. Then I am happy they did not take it.

 

[The King!]

king is right too, we went for a cheaper deal and said well worse case drive a wedge into essendon

 

[Superstar swan]

This is going to come back to hurt us

 

[Jeffers]

Kingy you ****ing idiot. Apparently Pick 9 and future first is a nothing deal.

 

[WillHayward]

We will do alot better next year than a lot of ppl think. We won our last 2 games by 50 odd. Our kids will develop more, we have kept Paps, added LT plus we get pick 5!

LT is very very ordinary.

We do have some young wingmen (Stoddart, Ling, McInerney) we can try out so losing Jones not that a big a blow.

 

[Banyo Bloods]

What if Papley isn’t that keen to commit and move in with his girlfriend and enjoys the life of living with mates. Requests a trade to satisfy that desire but then is secretly fist pumping that it can’t work that way but it’s the clubs fault.

Ok yes that’s ridiculous sorry

 

[azzzr]

regardless if we offered 5 , he clearly stated they wanted a player so as ridiculous as a first two top ten tops trade is thats not a player

 

[The King!]

Sooo are you suggesting if we got Daniher and lost papley we'd be contention?
Personally I disagree.

On SM-G960F using BigFooty.com mobile app

im saying buddy and daniher are two of the best forwards

and that makes us way better yes