Game Day 2019 Draft - now with poll!

So how did we do?

  • A+ - nailed it

  • A - really great

  • B - pretty good

  • C - okay

  • D - could have been better

  • E - could have been a lot better

  • F - terrible!


Results are only viewable after voting.

ad victoriam

Norm Smith Medallist
Jan 2, 2016
7,506
6,463
Barossa
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
CDFC
I’d like to see your maths on 300 points and how that equates to those players.

I’m not calling Gollant a poor player, I said he should have been a rookie pick, but I obviously wish he makes it. My poor pick comment was the justification some have used that a pick in the 40s this year is a poor pick.
Dogs finish 6th = 2nd rd = 606 pts, Crows finish around the 8 = 3rd rd = around 300 pts leaves us with around 300pts.
Borliase and Newchurch at this time are looking like late 2nd rd picks.

As for Gollant Hamish team picked him with Pick 45, maybe he heard that GWS were keen, and they had latter picks. and he may not last to the rookie spot,
After all we are talking about a 191cm plus outside player who can play Forward and Back, take a good mark. and Has a Football mindset.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Elite Crow

Premium Platinum
Mar 21, 2008
54,873
75,405
adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
Dogs finish 6th = 2nd rd = 606 pts, Crows finish around the 8 = 3rd rd = around 300 pts leaves us with around 300pts.
Borliase and Newchurch at this time are looking like late 2nd rd picks.

As for Gollant Hamish team picked him with Pick 45, maybe he heard that GWS were keen, and they had latter picks. and he may not last to the rookie spot,
After all we are talking about a 191cm plus outside player who can play Forward and Back, take a good mark. and Has a Football mindset.
What if we finish 12th?

Hamish said last night we picked him because once he played next year his price would have increased, hence we could have rookied him
 

ad victoriam

Norm Smith Medallist
Jan 2, 2016
7,506
6,463
Barossa
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
CDFC
What if we finish 12th?

Hamish said last night we picked him because once he played next year his price would have increased, hence we could have rookied him
What if the Dogs finishes 8th, What if we finish higher lots of what-ifs. you do understand it all speculation
But to answer your question if we finish 12 that 3rd rd is worth 378 pts. base on the dogs finishing 6th that mean we gain an extra 228pts plus whatever discount
End of the day the difference between the picks will be more than 200 pts. with a possibility of being much higher when you add in all the what-ifs. And with 3 possible FA and NGA on the radar, we will need every point available.
As for rookie him then who would you have select for that pick. and what if he was the kid we have been watching all year along with GWS who still had 2 selections. Watch the Kid next year and Judge for self, Don't jump the gun too early.
 

Danger in Texas

DID I STUTTER?
Mar 28, 2011
22,220
13,667
Pluto
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Reds, Lakers, East Side, Knights
Keays and Crocker seem more like Port Power selections
Yeah was going to say, a very un-Crows-like rookie draft, these guys are like the token DFAs Port picks up annually

Not gonna write them off though, both have time on their side at 22yo but are developed enough to make a good impact for our SANFL side
 

hugecannon

Club Legend
Aug 14, 2007
1,170
773
Adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
North Adelaide
Can someone tell me what the trade with Sydney was?

How did we go from having picks right after one another to having 4 picks between our second and third pick.
 

Pea Nut

Brownlow Medallist
Jul 9, 2013
10,412
12,394
AFL Club
Adelaide
Can someone tell me what the trade with Sydney was?

How did we go from having picks right after one another to having 4 picks between our second and third pick.
We only dropped back 2 spots, but Sydney bid on Mead after acquiring our pick. As it happened live some joked that we told them that they had to bid on Mead if we did the trade. Sydney then took Gould with that pick.
 

Golumless

I'm kind of a big deal on the east side
Jul 12, 2013
24,960
28,026
Wherever the ESH clubrooms are
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Newcastle, Colorado Rockies.
Can someone tell me what the trade with Sydney was?

How did we go from having picks right after one another to having 4 picks between our second and third pick.
25 for 27 (pushed to 28 with a Mead bid) + 2020 third-rounder (originally Fremantles).

Pretty nothing trade, but it's a few more points next year.
 

dylan123

Norm Smith Medallist
Jul 3, 2008
7,604
4,604
AFL Club
Adelaide
Keays and Crocker seem more like Port Power selections
Yeah seems a bit odd to not add any speculative young player and add two guys that will be going for a similar position that it feels like we've already got a heap of guys trying to fight for the role. Says a bit about the draft talent this year imo where the draft ended at mid 60s where it typically goes into the 80s and then only 15-20 odd in the rookie draft where it feels like there's usually another 30-40 odd selections. Think our last pick in the draft is what we'd typically do in the rookie draft so at least they've invested in someone that they see being more valuable in the future and getting them cheaper now.

Seems like more teams are open to keeping a spot open to either pick someone up prior to the start of the season like a few teams did last year and/or go into the mid season draft with an opening (although there's every chance you get that from a LTI).

Not that we saw a great deal go in the mid season draft last year but I suppose it's still a handful of names that might have otherwise been drafted in this draft.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

GreyCrow

Hall of Famer
Mar 21, 2016
48,406
71,278
Down South Corvus Tristis
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Sturt, Redskins , White Sox
Hamish gives a good explanation on our last 2 picks.

They felt OConnor has good upside because he was stuck behind 2-3 in the WA midfield. They projected the touches he did get to more midfield time and concluded he would have had greater production.

Gollant they accept is a Smokey but felt if he went round another year would be high end so best get him in now.

Some rationale I guess. Hamish has too many runs on the board to be throwing the toys out at this early stage.
The BK touch

Hamish already flagged people wouldnt like the last pick selection but I am neither here nor there so will follow his progress or lack of
 

Mutineer

Premium Platinum
Aug 9, 2019
3,131
6,400
AFL Club
Adelaide
The BK touch

Hamish already flagged people wouldnt like the last pick selection but I am neither here nor there so will follow his progress or lack of
I've gone back and watched several of Lachlan's NAB League games in their entirity today/tonight and honestly this pick has me completely flummoxed. Other than he looked decent overhead and he most certainly is a long way off growing into his body he doesn't look to have much pace, plays a very outside game and his kicking doesn't look to be anything special. I did note he stuck a couple of decent tackles though.
I'll bow to Hamish and his crew's judgement but all I can say is he must have really shown them something special when playing for PEGS in the AGSV school football program.....
 

GreyCrow

Hall of Famer
Mar 21, 2016
48,406
71,278
Down South Corvus Tristis
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Sturt, Redskins , White Sox
I've gone back and watched several of Lachlan's NAB League games in their entirity today/tonight and honestly this pick has me completely flummoxed. Other than he looked decent overhead and he most certainly is a long way off growing into his body he doesn't look to have much pace, plays a very outside game and his kicking doesn't look to be anything special. I did note he stuck a couple of decent tackles though.
I'll bow to Hamish and his crew's judgement but all I can say is he must have really shown them something special when playing for PEGS in the AGSV school football program.....
Yeah the comment about him costing more next year doesnt stack up for me

Rory Sloane is the recent example and instead of rookie listing him we waited one year and he still went 44

Again it may pay off but we wait and see
 

Jack is Back

Premiership Player
Apr 17, 2013
3,695
8,489
AFL Club
Adelaide
I think our approach to the Rookie Draft has changed in recent years. Rather than picking skinny kids with X-factor who will need 2-3 years to develop we have switched to more mature bodies who have one year to step up or exit stage right.

Crocker and Keays this year, Butts and Strachan last year, Murphy the year before. I thought that we may have have used a spot on the Rookie list for a project ruckman but I wasn’t aware of the Sudanese Basketballers prior to the draft.
 

Golumless

I'm kind of a big deal on the east side
Jul 12, 2013
24,960
28,026
Wherever the ESH clubrooms are
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Newcastle, Colorado Rockies.
Yeah the comment about him costing more next year doesnt stack up for me

Rory Sloane is the recent example and instead of rookie listing him we waited one year and he still went 44

Again it may pay off but we wait and see
I get where they're going with that, and it's more why risk other clubs being interested, especially if you're certain he's special?

That said, we must be incredibly confident he'll grow into that body, and be a dominant inside midfielder. Gollant profile doesn't fit elsewhere.
 

Relaxed

Debutant
Feb 3, 2019
138
217
AFL Club
Adelaide
I would be very interested, from an Crows recruitment interview perspective, if you spoke to 50 Victorian kids who thought they were in the potential 40-rookie draft area about their feelings about moving to Adelaide as a rookie pre-draft, how many would have shown a bit of reluctance.

Now with one SSP spot left open, if you invited any of those undrafted kids to come train in Adelaide for the last rookie spot against Mathews, wonder how many would change their attitude after missing out on their dream.

Also Crows SANFL top up squad had 2, potentially 3 AFL draftees (with Mathews) so even a Crows SANFL top up squad position could look good for kick-starting an AFL career. Will be very interested to see who is invited to train with the squad over summer, and who ends up in the Crows SANFL development squad.

Any kids left around the country with that express pace and line-breaking ability that we want to see?
 

Mr MysteryGuest

Premiership Player
Apr 4, 2015
4,414
4,476
AFL Club
Adelaide
I think our approach to the Rookie Draft has changed in recent years. Rather than picking skinny kids with X-factor who will need 2-3 years to develop we have switched to more mature bodies who have one year to step up or exit stage right.

Crocker and Keays this year, Butts and Strachan last year, Murphy the year before. I thought that we may have have used a spot on the Rookie list for a project ruckman but I wasn’t aware of the Sudanese Basketballers prior to the draft.
Butts and Murphy were closer to skinny kids than mature players like Keays.
 

ams4crows

Brownlow Medallist
Apr 22, 2007
11,107
11,445
Adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
T.Swift Huddersfield Town AUFC
Crocker and Keays this year, Butts and Strachan last year, Murphy the year before. I thought that we may have have used a spot on the Rookie list for a project ruckman but I wasn’t aware of the Sudanese Basketballers prior to the draft.
Umm pretty sure that was a joke mate
 

Elite Crow

Premium Platinum
Mar 21, 2008
54,873
75,405
adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
I get where they're going with that, and it's more why risk other clubs being interested, especially if you're certain he's special?

That said, we must be incredibly confident he'll grow into that body, and be a dominant inside midfielder. Gollant profile doesn't fit elsewhere.
Its interesting, sounds like a rookie selection not a pick 48. On the night the justification was GWS were picking him next and Hamish had to jump in, that’s been dispelled by Hamish himself though. BACCS you called me stubborn for not believing it, seems I might have been wise not to believe. I’ll accept your apology in advance.
 

WaynesWorld19

TheBrownDog
Nov 6, 2003
73,474
71,198
Baghdad
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
West Adelaide, Baghdad Bombers
Yeah was going to say, a very un-Crows-like rookie draft, these guys are like the token DFAs Port picks up annually

Not gonna write them off though, both have time on their side at 22yo but are developed enough to make a good impact for our SANFL side
Nah Depth primarily ...possible upside / future ....but our list depth is young and exposed to injury next season ...we didn't need more youth on the Rookie List
 

Elite Crow

Premium Platinum
Mar 21, 2008
54,873
75,405
adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
Nah Depth primarily ...possible upside / future ....but our list depth is young and exposed to injury next season ...we didn't need more youth on the Rookie List
Port tried something similar a couple of years back, we laughed at them, most didn’t get a game and were delisted.

It’s short sighted and who cares if our depth is tested next year, we aren’t going anywhere but if we’ve missed out on some youth that can have a long term career, that’s more costly than finishing 12th instead of 10th.
 
Last edited:

Huntercrow

Dwat that Wabbit
Feb 7, 2009
7,877
5,466
Hunter Valley
AFL Club
Adelaide
Is anyone else confused with the logic used by GC to give their 2020 mid-first round pick away to Geelong for a 2nd rounder? Makes no sense to me.
Looking from a Crows perspective GC have it too easy. Not hard to be frivolous with first round picks when they are gifted so easily. I hope the AFL ask them WTF were they up to throwing a 1st round selection at Geelong to gain a second round pick.
 

Top Bottom