Prediction 2019 "Hypothetical Trade, FA, random player you wish we could get" thread..

[Howe Amazing]

Not that I want to trade Smith but if Dees are keen Salem is a player that would fit into our game plan really well, great left foot kick

 

[Slysh]

Not that I want to trade Smith but if Dees are keen Salem is a player that would fit into our game plan really well, great left foot kick

Yeah but they need more god kicks not less, i feel like he would be untouchable for them.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Not that I want to trade Smith but if Dees are keen Salem is a player that would fit into our game plan really well, great left foot kick

Would rather Petracca who is rumored to not be happy.

 

[SodaPop]

Would rather Petracca who is rumored to not be happy.

What’s he worth though? Happy to give a future first?

 

[Howe Amazing]

Would rather Petracca who is rumored to not be happy.

Depends what is happening with Smith, he could easily play another 4-5 years

 

[King Patty]

extended Daniher trade

Efc In: McCartin, H McKay, B McKay, B Crouch
Carl: in: Papley, 4, Jenkins, Betts
Sydney In: Daniher, Hartley,Out: 4, Papley, Zac Jones, Mccartin
North: Zac Jones
Adelaide 8

 

[jenniferHAWKinS]

extended Daniher trade

Efc In: McCartin, H McKay, B McKay, B Crouch
Carl: in: Papley, 4, Jenkins, Betts
Sydney In: Daniher, Hartley,Out: 4, Papley, Zac Jones, Mccartin
North: Zac Jones
Adelaide 8

I think the Hawks come out all square in that trade.

 

[Brant]

I think the Hawks come out all square in that trade.

We'd still find a way to give up our 1st but somehow end up with a star from a Future 4th

 

[Steven Tyler]

extended Daniher trade

Efc In: McCartin, H McKay, B McKay, B Crouch
Carl: in: Papley, 4, Jenkins, Betts
Sydney In: Daniher, Hartley,Out: 4, Papley, Zac Jones, Mccartin
North: Zac Jones
Adelaide 8

 

[lickmerocks]

View attachment 746297

Absolutely mind boggling the Crows haven’t put a contract in front of Brad Crouch, I’d be bitterly disappointed if we weren’t into him 100%.. What would his wage be? 650-700k?

Disagree.

Crows know he wants to remain in Adelaide.

Crows would be crazy to not explore all trade options while they have been a basket case to see what they can get for him.

Decent player that racks up a huge amount of cheapies. No world beater.

 

[Ned Ryerson]

extended Daniher trade

Efc In: McCartin, H McKay, B McKay, B Crouch
Carl: in: Papley, 4, Jenkins, Betts
Sydney In: Daniher, Hartley,Out: 4, Papley, Zac Jones, Mccartin
North: Zac Jones
Adelaide 8

Does TB4 have side effects of mistakenly posting on the wrong forum?

 

[Roughies Boys]

Partington.

 

[Ned Ryerson]

Partington.

Is such sweet sorrowington.

 

[hardway]

Does TB4 have side effects of mistakenly posting on the wrong forum?

At least we now know the user name of Dedoro when he lurks on our page looking for advice on list management

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Depends what is happening with Smith, he could easily play another 4-5 years

He wants an extended contract, he’ll only get 1yr with us at a time.

 

[Milkshaker]

No point. I'd keep both unless we get ripping deals for them.

Imo a team in the window would be nuts if they did not throw a first rounder at either of these two, if it was a need.

 

[BigLittleHawk]

I would give up this year's first and next year's first, for Petracca and this year's 2nd coming back.

 

[Franko Armani]

I can almost guarantee that Cegs doesn’t sign for 3 years unless he is absolutely 100% guaranteed he is number 1 ruckman next year.. that leaves an interesting position with Big boy, something is brewing.

One of 3 scenarios:
1. He enjoys spending half the year at Box Hill and taking unders $$.
2. Big Boy is actually going to play KPD for reals.
3. Big Boy is being traded (if true, hopefully somehow involving pick #1 from GC)

 

[Crankyhawk]

You've been drinking too much Glühwein up in the snow fields my friend.

On SM-G950F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Couldn’t find the gluhwein at Buller (kooroombah has gone all ladidah)

 

[StillAtLarge]

One of 3 scenarios:
1. He enjoys spending half the year at Box Hill and taking unders $$.
2. Big Boy is actually going to play KPD for reals.
3. Big Boy is being traded (if true, hopefully somehow involving pick #1 from GC)

Well we can categorically rule out 2

 

[Howe Amazing]

extended Daniher trade

Efc In: McCartin, H McKay, B McKay, B Crouch
Carl: in: Papley, 4, Jenkins, Betts
Sydney In: Daniher, Hartley,Out: 4, Papley, Zac Jones, Mccartin
North: Zac Jones
Adelaide 8

So Bombers lose Daniher only (Hartley VFL) and gain all those players

 

[Platten44]

He wants an extended contract, he’ll only get 1yr with us at a time.

So what? He is contracted to us for 2020 so he plays for us in 2020. No point giving him away for change like we did Mitchell and Lewis.

 

[Brant]

One of 3 scenarios:
1. He enjoys spending half the year at Box Hill and taking unders $$.
2. Big Boy is actually going to play KPD for reals.
3. Big Boy is being traded (if true, hopefully somehow involving pick #1 from GC)

Well we can categorically rule out 2

Kinda seems like something we'd do, despite it contributing to multiple close & annoying losses, only to stop doing it too late to salvage the season, during which time (our late run home) we'd beat 3 or 4 of the top teams

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

So what? He is contracted to us for 2020 so he plays for us in 2020. No point giving him away for change like we did Mitchell and Lewis.

It’s about what he wants.

 

[Pessimistic]

One of 3 scenarios:
1. He enjoys spending half the year at Box Hill and taking unders $$.
2. Big Boy is actually going to play KPD for reals.
3. Big Boy is being traded (if true, hopefully somehow involving pick #1 from GC)

If it was 3, why not do it all in trade week?