Changes for next week v Melb

[ImperialPurple]

Out: Sandilands (inj)
IN: Longmuir (presuming he comes up)

Otherwise, leave well enough alone.



Unless Macca's fit, then I don't know who you'd drop to bring him in. Maybe Peakey as the last man in, although I thought he did alright today. Crowley got towelled up by Judd... maybe him?? Or does Macca have to earn his spot again?



Crikey - I just remembered Jeffrey.... Medders didn't set the world on fire today - maybe another stint in the magoos for him??


No free rides or gold tickets this year!

 

[ImperialPurple]

Sorry IP, I want Jeffrey in our team no matter what!

Edit - see above... I was just fixing that and you beat me to it.

What a shame Our Jeffrey wasn't able to enjoy a derby win with the rest of the boys...

 

[Kenny_01]

Medders won't get dropped again.

 

[bigtanker5]

Medders won't get dropped again.

I wouldnt be surprised if he was

 

[Goal Square]

-Sandilands to be replaced by Longmuir. If J Lo's not fit then Warren's gotta come in.
-Farmer to come in for Peake or possibly Medhurst...?

 

[voodoo_86]

How many shots on goal did medhurst have, 5 or 6?

He wasn't that bad... just needed to convert a couple. I'm liking his game atm, one of the few players in our team that kicks it in long and quick.

 

[ImperialPurple]

-Sandilands to be replaced by Longmuir. If J Lo's not fit then Warren's gotta come in.
-Farmer to come in for Peake or possibly Medhurst...?

Warren is not up to AFL footy.

 

[Reveler]

Farmer for Peake
JLO for Sandilands

Our backline chemistry was quite good last night.

 

[ImperialPurple]

Farmer for Peake
JLO for Sandilands

Our backline chemistry was quite good last night.

Our backline has been good all year. Robbie is going to have to work hard to get a gig when he's fit, I reckon.

 

[Reveler]

hopefully he will get fit just in time to take over the reigns from parker if/when he retires.

 

[newlander77]

I think Grover has already taken over the reigns from Parker this year!

 

[Vintage]

-Sandilands to be replaced by Longmuir. If J Lo's not fit then Warren's gotta come in.

Disagree. If I was the match commitee (fortunately I'm not), I would be giving some serious thought to the 'no ruckman' side that did so well yesterday and in Tasmania when Sandi was off.

Of course if JLo is fit he should definitely play.

 

[masai]

We were missing a crumber, Jeff in.

After being at the game and having a look on the tv replay, Parker was still a rock. Yes he made a couple of errors, but he made some darn good saves under pressure and allowed Duff and Grover to run off. He set up the Bell goal in the last quarter, I was fortunate to see the instructions Bell gave him (view from the outer). Parker is still useful in his "stabilising" role.

Guess who made the most clangers for us on Saturday ?. Pav, would you have thought that ?.

 

[kanabar]

Medders won't get dropped again.

id say farmer in for medhurst he didnt do that great and i wouldnt mind the run of macca if hes back

 

[kanabar]

We were missing a crumber, Jeff in.

After being at the game and having a look on the tv replay, Parker was still a rock. Yes he made a couple of errors, but he made some darn good saves under pressure and allowed Duff and Grover to run off. He set up the Bell goal in the last quarter, I was fortunate to see the instructions Bell gave him (view from the outer). Parker is still useful in his "stabilising" role.

Guess who made the most clangers for us on Saturday ?. Pav, would you have thought that ?.

i agr3ee we missed our crumbers jeffs needed there big time.

 

[malpaso]

OUT: Sandilands (inj), Peake/Walker (omitted)
IN: Longmuir/Murphy, Farmer

Murphy instead of Longmuir in case of setback for Justin's fitness.

Between Peake and Walker for the other drop.

 

[kanabar]

OUT: Sandilands (inj), Peake/Walker (omitted)
IN: Longmuir/Murphy, Farmer

Murphy instead of Longmuir in case of setback for Justin's fitness.

Between Peake and Walker for the other drop.

i would drop peake and put walker on that demons lighting player...in the midfield dont remeber his name though...

peakes disposal aint terrific walkers is better and we dont want to get punished if we loose the pill due to poor disposal.

 

[dominguez]

OUT: Sandilands (inj), Peake/Walker (omitted)
IN: Longmuir/Murphy, Farmer

Murphy instead of Longmuir in case of setback for Justin's fitness.

Between Peake and Walker for the other drop.

I agree. If Walker is going to play on Davey we drop Peake. If the match committee think Schammer or Duffman can go with Davey we drop Walker. Showers are forecast for Melbourne on Saturday, if they eventuate Cook might come in (B.O.G. again on weekend for Perth).

 

[masai]

Wet MCG = Cook.

 

[kanabar]

interesting then we definately need cookie but walker would be nice to put on davey

 

[malpaso]

Showers are forecast for Melbourne on Saturday, if they eventuate Cook might come in (B.O.G. again on weekend for Perth).

Spot on with Cookie. He'd tear the Melbourne midfield apart with his bumps.

Likewise if it's wet, I doubt Longmuir will play meaning Murphy would come in.

 

[Kenny_01]

OUT: Sandilands (inj), Peake/Walker (omitted)
IN: Longmuir/Murphy, Farmer

Murphy instead of Longmuir in case of setback for Justin's fitness.

Between Peake and Walker for the other drop.

Agree completely.

 

[peterss]

IN - J-Lo, Cook, Farmer
OUT - Sandi, Crowley, Peake

 

[Freo Big Fella]

In - Longmuir, Farmer, Cook (tore it up for Perth on the weekend)
Out - Sandi, Medhurst, Peake

 

[dugrene]

If Jlo has bung knees it is madness to have play footy then get squished up in a plane.
Probably he gets the seat that he stretch his legs, if not dont dont send him. It is a long season make sure he is right for the second half.

As for who to drop my initial thought was Peake but having watched most of the game he did alright especially in the last quarter. Another thing about Peake that I noticed last year and continued on Saturday. ..... The umpires seem like him

Someone has to make room for Farmer though. My guess is Peake. But he will be a regular by seasons end I'd say.