Changes for Showdown

[port always]

you would have to say no changes...Karlos wii learn a lot from that game...

 

[Power Pete]

OUT: Lobbe (Rested) - Amon
IN: Harvey - Krakouer

News Update: Ken said Carlile could be out for 2-3 games... hip problems.

 

[Adz2332]

Out Amon
In Krak

 

[Long live PAFC]

No changes.

Back the team in. Yes Amon made some mistakes but give him a chance to atone. They have a good long break and will need it after that emotional and sapping game.

Amon to sub and Ah Chee for a full game.

Give Carlile a chance to recover and recuperate.

The big question is what to do if Lobbe doesn't come up....

 

[Footy Matt]

Hoon in for Amon

Moore in for Stewart

Harvey in for Lobbe

Krak in for Neade

Give Ah Chee a full game and Hoon for sub.

Game, set and match.

 

[ImportExport]

id rest Lobbe, just doesnt seem right, id be happy to go in with Ryder, Westhoff and Trengove sharing the ruck duties,

I think Impey will be looking forward to giving Betts a night to remember

Contest ball is king with the Crows, Maybe young to come in for Lobbe, Ah Chee to start and Amon on the bench, wouldn't say no to Mitchell replacing Amon

Id also start Clurey on Walker and Hombsch on Jenkins. Seems they have been putting Jenkins deep forward with Walker up the ground a bit.

Also Krakouer in for Monfries, something is not right with monfries, Krakouer and Neade in the forward line might be good

Oshea to stand the red head

Jasper on the wing

 

[Wargreymon90]

We will bring in Jonas for Lobbe.

 

[Long live PAFC]

Also Krakouer in for Monfries, something is not right with monfries, Krakouer and Neade in the forward line might be good

Oshea to stand the red head

Jasper on the wing

Monfries was a jet last night! No way he is coming out.

 

[Blaggut]

Out: Amon (he'll get another chance)
In: Krak

Those calling for Clurey, O'Shea, Neade or Broadbent to be dropped need to watch the replay. I was super critical of O'Shea's selection but I couldn't be happier with his match.

 

[El_Scorcho]

I saw I few clangers and a few lost contests. Zero tackles. What did you see?

EDIT: when you say "watching", do you mean on TV? Because that would explain a lot.

Tackles are not the way to measure a KPD. They just don't get them as much as other players. Carlile has had 5 games this year without a tackle.

Clurey stays in until Carlile is fit as far as i'm concerned. You play developing talls when you have your starting talls out to maintain structure.

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

I would keep Amon in for another week. He is still trying to find his feet and it was his first game back. Give him another go next week see how he goes

 

[PAFC66]

Jonas isnt a in untill he absolutely dominates SANFL level.

 

[tribey]

Monfries was a jet last night! No way he is coming out.

I know a few boys who will be devastated.

 

[Hong-Kong Phooey]

I know a few boys who will be devastated.

monfries was better last night. but ot quite ready to enter the best player lists just yet

 

[Hong-Kong Phooey]

out - lobbe.
in - Carlile

if moore has a cracker for the maggies then he can replace someone. not sure who

 

[Portology]

We will bring in Jonas for Lobbe.

I too would rather have a partly mobile midget CHF/HFF than a tall but currently immobile injured ruckman trying to do two jobs.

So Paddy to go up all day vs Jacobs, Jonas as the nominated defensive HFF/midget CHF of the week, and Monfries to run more freely through the midfield per his role last night?

Add "Pittard to the wing" and we might have something weird enough to work.

Krak in for Clurey might also happen, if their number/type of talls don't warrant bringing Bob back yet. Paul Stewart has done enough to hold his spot under normal circumstances but may be unlucky.

I'll go against last night's consensus and say keep Amon in for another week but make him the sub. Show us exactly what you learned from last night, kid. Leave the 'Hoon free for twittercise this week

Full game for Arch pls.

Impey and/or Krak to Betts pls.

Jonas/Lobbe
Krak/Clurey/Bob/Stewart

Sub: Amon

Emg: Hoon


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Hong-Kong Phooey]

one thing thats got to go for the showdown is all this love bewteen the clubs at the moment. While i dont like the idiotic fighting, i do enjoy a bit of banter and especially enjoy seeing them lose. It was nice for a while, but lets get it back to normal. im sure they all agree.

 

[charcolechaddy]

Im gonna be harsh I think... yes we won... but...

Out: Broadbent, Monfries, Schulz, O'Shea

In: Krak, Harvey/Shaw, Carlisle, Sammy C.

Reasons: Broady has been playing rabbit football the last few weeks, constant turnover then lets try and make up for me giving up a goal... enough is enough, have a spell. Monfries, sorry mate, but the under 18 would dominate you atm, the drug crap has to playing on his mind so give him a spell and try and work shit out. Schulz, has played shit all year, maybe injured, maybe not, but hey lets see what our future holds. O'Shea... Bobby is better sorry, and Clurey is the future... sorry.

Kark... why was he dropped? one of the best and consistent all season imo!, Harvey/Shaw... lets see what they have. Carlisle... Welcome back Bobby, Sammy C... if he is the replacement of Kornes... give him for than 2 games, seriously like what the F!

I cant agree with that. Angus was better last night, given it wasn't a night for tall forwards I thought Shultz was good.

What has Shaw done to get a game?

 

[RossFC]

Jonas isnt a in untill he absolutely dominates SANFL level.

Not playing against Norwood this weekend. Cross him off for the Showdown.

If he's in for Clurey or O'Shea anyway, My head will explode.

 

[ab56452001]

Krak for Amen , but who replaces Lobbe ? ,

 

[RossFC]

Krak for Amen , but who replaces Lobbe ? ,

Hopefully Harvey creams Norwood if Lobbe is injured.

 

[BIG MATTY WHITE]

I am willing to give amon the benefit of finding his feet

I will say vest him so he knows that wasnt good enough in terms off effort though

Amon sub
achee man full game

Lobbe out
Kraks in

 

[The Smaller Warrior]

John Butcher

 

[Doctor Feel]

Krak for Amen , but who replaces Lobbe ? ,

Broadband, Yonus and Amen.

**** me.

 

[RossFC]

Broadband, Yonus and Amen.

**** me.

Aaron Moore