Preview Changes R6 vs Crows

[Jeffcrowe]

Guys - how come ibbotson didn't play yesterday ? He will be a great match up for lynch

 

[E Shed]

I tend to think recall some experienced players. Mzungu, DeBoer, Ibbotson.
We saw how Grey, Weller tired in the 2nd half. This game is mission impossible but no need to traumatise the kids with a 20 goal loss.
I don't think Suban deserves to be recalled, hardly set the world alight in the WAFL.

 

[meima]

I tend to think recall some experienced players. Mzungu, DeBoer, Ibbotson.
We saw how Grey, Weller tired in the 2nd half. This game is mission impossible but no need to traumatise the kids with a 20 goal loss.
I don't think Suban deserves to be recalled, hardly set the world alight in the WAFL.

Agree, but suban is such a bad blood that peel player also don't want him to involve. basically he piss people off with his attitude.

 

[Stuart88]

In: My Buddy!

 

[salim malik]

Agree, but suban is such a bad blood that peel player also don't want him to involve. basically he piss people off with his attitude.

Thats rubbish, Suban might not be an A grade senior player but there is nothing wrong with his attitude. Really the 7 Peel boys who played Sat are pissed off with Suban.

 

[meima]

Thats rubbish, Suban might not be an A grade senior player but there is nothing wrong with his attitude. Really the 7 Peel boys who played Sat are pissed off with Suban.

Up to what you said salim malek, I saw it and tell it as it is . defend him as you like player like O'Brien is way better than him week in week out for peel. Calvin as a 65kg kid also got much more development than suban. Suban best value is go back to freo first team never ever to play for peel again . such as list clogged to a team like peel.

 

[332docker]

6 day break for us 8 day for crows so I reckon ring the changes with some fresh legs...

Out:
Fyfe (inj), Balla (inj), Johnson (inj), Mayne (Omit - lost patience watching him try to regain confidence in front of goal - back to Peel to find his radar!), Sutcliffe (Omit - same, too many turnovers first 5 weeks - long term they rate him highly, but not helping us at the moment so give him a run for peel to remind him his place is no longer secure!), Grey (omit)

In:
Mundy, DeBoer, Muzungu, Collins, Langdon, Blakley


Adelaide team last week:
B: Jake Lever, Daniel Talia, Rory Laird
HB: Paul Seedsman, Kyle Hartigan, Luke Brown
C: Richard Douglas, Scott Thompson, Brodie Smith
HF: Charlie Cameron, Tom Lynch, Eddie Betts
F: Josh Jenkins, Taylor Walker, Rory Atkins
Fol: Sam Jacobs, Rory Sloane, Matt Crouch
I/C: David Mackay, Kyle Cheney, Jarryd Lyons, Mitch McGovern

• We need at least 3 tall defenders - I'd say Snos to come in but when he travels he often is a late withdrawal (due sick or otherwise) so save him for a return in a home game, I'd like a look at Collins
• Grey is not a big improvement on someone like DeBoer when he started - fumbly, decision making questionable - hard nut, but we need more class from the new guys coming in. Not sure he'll ever be a permanent fixture. Reckon Langdon shows more class
• Love to give Pav a break but due injuries we need him - glad he went round again, he may not be as dominant but takes a key defender or 2 and is class when ball in hand still...
• Need to move D.Pearce up fwd with Balla out I reckon

B:Sheridan, Dawson, Spurr
HB: A. Pearce, Collins, Tucker
C: Weller, Hill, Mundy
HF: Crozier, Pavlich, Tabener
F: Walters, Z.Clarke, D. Pearce
Fol: Griffin, Barlow, Neale
I/C: DeBoer, Muzungu, Langdon, Blakley

 

[Demons09]

Up to what you said Salim , I saw it and tell it as it is . defend him as you like player like O'Brien is way better than him week in week out for peel. Calvin as a 65kg kids also got much more development than suban.

Hate to break it to you, but Calvin isn't on Freo's list Subab is Peel is there to do Freo's bidding.

 

[meima]

Hate to break it to you, but Calvin isn't on Freo's list Subab is Peel is there to do Freo's bidding.

Yup I am peel supporter , so forget the bidding. Like I said you support Perth I support peel time to create club history I respect your support for Perth so you should respect mine decision too . suban can never help with that.

You should be more happy suban in for freo against adelaide than playing for peel isint it. Don't tell me you think Perth got more chance to win in Mandurah with suban with peel.

 

[Demons09]

Yup I am peel supporter , so forget the bidding. Like I said you support Perth I support peel time to create club history I respect your support for Perth so you should respect mine decision too . suban can never help with that.

I

Well that's too bad mate Freo is aligned with Peel what Freo says goes, I thought you would of known this.

 

[meima]

Well that's too bad mate Freo is aligned with Peel what Freo says goes, I thought you would of known this.

Yah I know that , I want suban to play against crow not Perth isnt this thread for changes vs Adelaide?

Best value now for suban is play for freo against big body team or unuse emergency.

 

[balthazarthedonk]

6 day break for us 8 day for crows so I reckon ring the changes with some fresh legs...

Out:
Fyfe (inj), Balla (inj), Johnson (inj), Mayne (Omit - lost patience watching him try to regain confidence in front of goal - back to Peel to find his radar!), Sutcliffe (Omit - same, too many turnovers first 5 weeks - long term they rate him highly, but not helping us at the moment so give him a run for peel to remind him his place is no longer secure!), Grey (omit)

In:
Mundy, DeBoer, Muzungu, Collins, Langdon, Blakley


We need at least 3 tall defenders - I'd say Snos to come in but when he travels he often is a late withdrawal (due sick or otherwise) so save him for a return in a home game, I'd like a look at Collins

• Grey is not a big improvement on someone like DeBoer when he started - fumbly, decision making questionable - hard nut, but we need more class from the new guys coming in. Not sure he'll ever be a permanent fixture. Reckon Langdon shows more class
• Love to give Pav a break but due injuries we need him - glad he went round again, he may not be as dominant but takes a key defender or 2 and is class when ball in hand still...
• Need to move D.Pearce up fwd with Balla out I reckon

I am always interested in others' selections but I can't understand how you can demote Grey - who had a crack and was involved in the majority of Freo's forward thrusts in the first half - because he is unskilled but replace him with de Boer, Mzungu and Collins. The first two are unskilled and furthermore never have the influence that Grey had. I reckon Brady will come along just fine, he's the type to will himself to get better. He had some poor disposals (not really that many) but also some excellent ones before he tired.
Collins was woeful on the weekend. He was given a bath by Darcy Cameron. There's no way you can reward that performance. Yes to Langdon, Mundy and de Boer (only due to size of injury list). Ibbotson and/or Hughes has to be part of the conversation to allow A Pearce to play on one of the Adelaide big talls and possibly move Sheridan to the midfield. I agree Sutcliffe should be demoted, it's a matter of whether it's too many changes to do so this week. SNOS is simply not tall enough, although I'd take him over Collins ATM.

 

[meima]

I am always interested in others' selections but I can't understand how you can demote Grey - who had a crack and was involved in the majority of Freo's forward thrusts in the first half - because he is unskilled but replace him with de Boer, Mzungu and Collins. The first two are unskilled and furthermore never have the influence that Grey had. I reckon Brady will come along just fine, he's the type to will himself to get better. He had some poor disposals (not really that many) but also some excellent ones before he tired.
Collins was woeful on the weekend. He was given a bath by Darcy Cameron. There's no way you can reward that performance. Yes to Langdon, Mundy and de Boer (only due to size of injury list). Ibbotson and/or Hughes has to be part of the conversation to allow A Pearce to play on one of the Adelaide big talls and possibly move Sheridan to the midfield. I agree Sutcliffe should be demoted, it's a matter of whether it's too many changes to do so this week. SNOS is simply not tall enough, although I'd take him over Collins ATM.

We need strategies with our rebuild now. The recruitment team and assistant coaches should go to peel matches and look around fo r local talent if we serious about our draft this year.

 

[Lach72]

I tend to think recall some experienced players. Mzungu, DeBoer, Ibbotson.
We saw how Grey, Weller tired in the 2nd half. This game is mission impossible but no need to traumatise the kids with a 20 goal loss.
I don't think Suban deserves to be recalled, hardly set the world alight in the WAFL.

Mundy is coming back in.
I'd bring Ibbotson back in and Hughes. Stick them on the half back and release Tommy to the wing.

We need runners to break the lines.

 

[Lach72]

6 day break for us 8 day for crows so I reckon ring the changes with some fresh legs...

Out:
Fyfe (inj), Balla (inj), Johnson (inj), Mayne (Omit - lost patience watching him try to regain confidence in front of goal - back to Peel to find his radar!), Sutcliffe (Omit - same, too many turnovers first 5 weeks - long term they rate him highly, but not helping us at the moment so give him a run for peel to remind him his place is no longer secure!), Grey (omit)

In:
Mundy, DeBoer, Muzungu, Collins, Langdon, Blakley


Adelaide team last week:
B: Jake Lever, Daniel Talia, Rory Laird
HB: Paul Seedsman, Kyle Hartigan, Luke Brown
C: Richard Douglas, Scott Thompson, Brodie Smith
HF: Charlie Cameron, Tom Lynch, Eddie Betts
F: Josh Jenkins, Taylor Walker, Rory Atkins
Fol: Sam Jacobs, Rory Sloane, Matt Crouch
I/C: David Mackay, Kyle Cheney, Jarryd Lyons, Mitch McGovern

• We need at least 3 tall defenders - I'd say Snos to come in but when he travels he often is a late withdrawal (due sick or otherwise) so save him for a return in a home game, I'd like a look at Collins
• Grey is not a big improvement on someone like DeBoer when he started - fumbly, decision making questionable - hard nut, but we need more class from the new guys coming in. Not sure he'll ever be a permanent fixture. Reckon Langdon shows more class
• Love to give Pav a break but due injuries we need him - glad he went round again, he may not be as dominant but takes a key defender or 2 and is class when ball in hand still...
• Need to move D.Pearce up fwd with Balla out I reckon

B:Sheridan, Dawson, Spurr
HB: A. Pearce, Collins, Tucker
C: Weller, Hill, Mundy
HF: Crozier, Pavlich, Tabener
F: Walters, Z.Clarke, D. Pearce
Fol: Griffin, Barlow, Neale
I/C: DeBoer, Muzungu, Langdon, Blakley

Grey omit? Are you ****ing insane?

 

[meima]

Grey omit? Are you ******* insane?

Grey omited Just for Crows match , be back against GWS. Let the footsoldiers do the travelling this week more about strategies than anything.

 

[Lach72]

lol. You guys have no idea

 

[meima]

lol. You guys have no idea

Carlton lost make most of us lost our mind. I could not care less if anyone keep defend about suban,gu,C.Pearce and co just keep playing them until the end of season against strong team . they are not in our rebuilding plan.

 

[Demons09]

Yup I am peel supporter , so forget the bidding. Like I said you support Perth I support peel time to create club history I respect your support for Perth so you should respect mine decision too . suban can never help with that.

You should be more happy suban in for freo against adelaide than playing for peel isint it. Don't tell me you think Perth got more chance to win in Mandurah with suban with peel.

Yah I know that , I want suban to play against crow not Perth isnt this thread for changes vs Adelaide?

Best value now for suban is play for freo against big body team or unuse emergency.

What are you on about I didn't even mention Perth,I was reminding you that Suban is a Freo player and that the development of Calvin is a non issue where Freo is concerned, your post was suggesting that Suban is destabilising Peel and even Salim told you that was rubbish.

The way I read it is your saying that Suban should play for Freo for the betterment of Peel, I never want to see Suban in Freo colours again.

 

[mightymouse75]

Haha. Totally clueless. But I think the coaching panel would be clutching at straws as well

 

[blue shark]

I am always interested in others' selections but I can't understand how you can demote Grey - who had a crack and was involved in the majority of Freo's forward thrusts in the first half - because he is unskilled but replace him with de Boer, Mzungu and Collins. The first two are unskilled and furthermore never have the influence that Grey had. I reckon Brady will come along just fine, he's the type to will himself to get better. He had some poor disposals (not really that many) but also some excellent ones before he tired.
Collins was woeful on the weekend. He was given a bath by Darcy Cameron. There's no way you can reward that performance. Yes to Langdon, Mundy and de Boer (only due to size of injury list). Ibbotson and/or Hughes has to be part of the conversation to allow A Pearce to play on one of the Adelaide big talls and possibly move Sheridan to the midfield. I agree Sutcliffe should be demoted, it's a matter of whether it's too many changes to do so this week. SNOS is simply not tall enough, although I'd take him over Collins ATM.

To be fair to Collins he is conceding 10cms, 10 kgs, to Darcy Cameron, may have had an off day, didnt machup well?
From all the reports on DC, you would wonder why he wasnt looked at by us, especially when Moller was axed.

 

[meima]

Haha. Totally clueless. But I think the coaching panel would be clutching at straws as well

That is the best description on our lost on field yesterday , the coaching panel is clueless to fix the problem.

 

[pavslovechild]

Grey omit? Are you ******* insane?

Grey to betts...bury him early

 

[meima]

mightymouse75 you are such a troll.

 

[DeanS]

Guys - how come ibbotson didn't play yesterday ? He will be a great match up for lynch

No idea, and it seems like no one else knows either.