Unofficial Preview Changes round 14 vs Adelaide

[Testekill]

One forced out in McNeil
No obvious injuries from the VFL and Libba may be available

 

[BEaston]

Now that we're more or less back to full strength, I'd look at resting/managing Treloar and only have him in case of emergency.

 

[bresker]

What to do about Treloar ? I thought some his work around the stoppage was painful to watch. He looked like he was running through treacle , again.

He's still a silky mover with the ball, but he finished with 12 disposals and a weak kick at goal which would have iced the game for us.

Can we continue to carry him along ? He was only on for a bit over half the game. Sadly I don't think he's going to regain full fitness or confidence in his body.

 

[go the dogs]

McNeil for libba and we are set I reckon. Treloar is still smart and be more effective than whoever comes in

 

[Doggies7]

Yeah I said it last week but I would "manage" Treloar. Not moving well or doing a ton defensively unfortunately and doesn't have a spot in the middle, especially with Libba coming back soon. Can give him a week or two off and re-assess.

In - Libba (if ready), Jaques
Out - Treloar, McNeil

 

[Optimistic Dog]

5 day break if anyone plays from the reserves today. Thinking only Libba for McNeill hope Cody and ADZ can back up after 6 day break.

Chance to go 9 wins 5 losses. Think we will win not sure if it will be 1,2,3,4,5 or 6 points likely to be one of those margins.

 

[MaxiBont]

In - Libba , Jaques
Out - Treloar, McNeil

 

[NthBondiDoggies]

Against Adelaide they have sometime exposed our height in defence.

McNeil out for Libba in is easy.

But Bevo might want to get more high in (I doubt it) but if he did then options:

May comes in Lobb goes back.

Buss comes in - Lobb stays as ruck forward.

Hard to know who to drop but probably Bramble or Trelor.

Love Trelor but if Libba comes back we can have him in the guts and if hit there then his limited running ATM..

Bramble was pretty good bringing the ball out with Dale and Buderick but Buss is a good ball mover so may another option.

 

[Mojorisin]

Yeah I said it last week but I would "manage" Treloar. Not moving well or doing a ton defensively unfortunately and doesn't have a spot in the middle, especially with Libba coming back soon. Can give him a week or two off and re-assess.

In - Libba (if ready), Jaques
Out - Treloar, McNeil

I'd do the exact same. (I'd then rest Kennedy against saints in Treloar's place)
Now we're getting everyone back we need to start managing the older guys like the better clubs do well.

I would like to find a way to squeeze Buss in but not sure how.

 

[Martyn_30_]

Treloar's significantly better than half the team when he gets the ball, he only played 58% game time. The other options are liabilities when they get the ball, or aren't tough enough in the contest.

 

[bigbulldog67]

Treloar & Mcneil for Libba & Dolan is pretty easy id think, I really want to get Busslinger into this side too though but not sure how. Can’t drop Coffield & Buku, can we play them all? Maybe. I mean guys like Treloar are playing 50% game time and can’t run, are we really losing ‘run’ by swapping in an extra tall who likes to get on his bike and uses the ball well.

It may free up Buku to be more of an intercepting threat which he’s lost since being tasked with tougher roles. Also Bukus ball use and link up has been great this year so he can focus on that a bit more too, along with Coffield.

 

[DueWest]

Treloar's significantly better than half the team when he gets the ball, he only played 58% game time. The other options are liabilities when they get the ball, or aren't tough enough in the contest.

His game time will build, keep playing him. 6 day break off 58% TOG is ok, into 10 game break with Saints then a bye

Also playing a difficult role off half forward, it’s ok for him to be rusty.