Strategy Changes: Round 16 Fremantle vs. St Kilda

[mattis117]

A huge 10 day break for this one. Back to a Sunday afternoon. First day home game for a while.

Clearly a lot of the depth well below standard.

Out: Draper, Aish, Sharp
In: Pearce, Switta, Darcy.

Fyfe back to sub.

Hoping Switta is only the two week injury, huge out tonight.

 

[Mainy66]

Changes for next week.

Possible ins. Omac, Dudley, Brodie
Possible outs, Draper, Fyfe, Sharp, Amiss.

Be great to have Pearce, Young and Cooper back soon.

 

[ubiquitous226]

We need Pearce back, he makes a big difference.
Fyfe, Ras and Draper had pretty average games, so I'd expect there to be another change.

 

[_007_]

Out: Banfield, Fyfe and Draper.

In: O'Meara, Dudley and Pearce (McDonald)

FB: Ryan Pearce Worner
HB: Clarke Cox Chapman
C: Wagner Serong O'Driscoll
HF: Bolton Treacy Reid
FF: Amiss Voss Dudley

R: Jackson Brayshaw Johnson

I: Frederick Aish Erasmus (lucky) Sharp (lucky)

S: Banfield

 

[Sir Deadly]

Need Pearce back in for Draper

 

[Lach72]

Banfield has to go.

Anyone for Drapes. His lack of physicality is pissing me off. McDonald or Davies

Dudley back in.
Darcyback in.

Fyfe was putrid

 

[south beach]

Banfield has to go.

Anyone for Drapes. His lack of physicality is pissing me off. McDonald or Davies

Dudley back in.
Darcyback in.

Fyfe was putrid

Banfield has to go.

Anyone for Drapes. His lack of physicality is pissing me off. McDonald or Davies

Dudley back in.
Darcyback in.

Fyfe was putrid

 

[fleur]

We want bloodthirsty vengeance

 

[south beach]

First out is sharp just no physicality poor disposal, followed by FYFEY [sorry mate it’s been a great ride) Draper will have his time just not now.

 

[Farrand]

Out: Draper, Sharp, Aish
In: Pearce, Brodie, Dudley

Banners should be out but he never will.

 

[King Huskii]

Banfield was terrible

We need Dudley back in he actually kicks goals

 

[Tbonefreo]

OMac for draper

 

[The Feeder Club]

If ever a Peel game should mean something at the selection table, it's the game this weekend. It is impossible to really be definite about any ins until we see Peel

 

[StingBitten]

O'mac has to be in for Draper until Pearce gets back - but it probably won't happen.

Dudley in for Sharp (woeful).

Darcy in for Fyfe.

 

[Getlegs]

Out three of the following. Banfield, Draper, Fyfe, Sharpe, Aish, Erasmus.

In Pearce Switta Walker

Hopefully Young before the end of the season

 

[freo1]

Out three of the following. Banfield, Draper, Fyfe, Sharpe, Aish, Erasmus.

In Pearce Switta Walker

Hopefully Young before the end of the season

Not sure which game you watched tonight but Banfield played extremely well. Cannot be dropped.

Can’t believe so many ppl thinking Banners should dropped. Played a very serviceable game.

He offers so much flexibility. I find his gap in effort between his best and worst is very small which is precisely what you want for a player.

He may be in the last 4 picked each weekend but he had a very good game tonight

 

[Deathly]

Not sure which game you watched tonight but Banfield played extremely well. Cannot be dropped.

Directly handing the opposition goals in the 4th is playing extremely well? If we played a good side we would have gotten buried after that. What Banfield does extremely well is changing the tide of momentum in the oppositions' favour. This is the only thing he's been consistent at in his career.

Cool, he can play a few roles and can stay a Round 1 - 24 hero, and even play next week - but he should never play in a final for this club again. It is players like him (amongst others) who will ultimately cost us.

 

[StingBitten]

Not sure which game you watched tonight but Banfield played extremely well. Cannot be dropped.

Can’t believe so many ppl thinking Banners should dropped. Played a very serviceable game.

He offers so much flexibility. I find his gap in effort between his best and worst is very small which is precisely what you want for a player.

He may be in the last 4 picked each weekend but he had a very good game tonight

We promise not to talk about your son like that again, Mrs Banfield.

 

[freo1]

Not quite sure why Banfield is the continued whipping boy of fans.

I’m not even a JL fan, but I support his selection of Banfield - he offers flexibility, commitment and consistency.

The other thing is team consistency is very important. Banners was not our worst tonight but keeping a group together is very important when you can

Johnson: love the kid, important we keep giving him games, but he got caught a lot tonight. Still need to keep getting games into him

Erasmus: same as Johnno.

Fyfe: important but just looked clumsy and slow. Didn’t really want to kick it and we didn’t exploit his marking prowess.

Aish: not much good putting him on after 3qtr time

Sharp: untidy tonight but his running ability is important and he offered a good outlet.

Dris: love the kid, untidy and fumbly tonight. Will be better for the run. Did some really good things but also just some poor skill errors ie missed set shot.

Draper: starting to look tired but loved his speed and Caddy is a serious talent

All the above I thought were below Banfield, but I don’t think they should be dropped as they still performed in patches.

Pearce needs to come in so Draper misses out

If swit comes in that’ll be for Aish

Darcy may get a look for Dris but that’s about it.

We now have some selection integrity. Basically you need to have good form.

I’d love duds in but I don’t know who for.

Fyfe back to sub next week.

 

[s_wd6]

Pearce please. Draper was jogging half the time.

 

[fleur]

Need to rip out their hearts

 

[Deathly]

Pearce please. Draper was jogging half the time.

He should have been dropped after trailing behind old man Darling all game last week. Not sure what's happened to him but he's nowhere near it.

 

[King Huskii]

Not sure which game you watched tonight but Banfield played extremely well. Cannot be dropped.

Can’t believe so many ppl thinking Banners should dropped. Played a very serviceable game.

He offers so much flexibility. I find his gap in effort between his best and worst is very small which is precisely what you want for a player.

He may be in the last 4 picked each weekend but he had a very good game tonight

Banners can't hit a target

I was at the game he was putrid

 

[Righteo]

"Banfield played extremely well"

"Banfield was not our worst tonight"

We're like two posts away from "Okay Banfield was awful but he is NOT a Russian asset"

 

[wakojako]

Can we leave the chip-mark and sideways ball movement in this game please. I want to see the aggressive ball movement from our pre-bye games.