Changes Round 5 vs Hawks

[Doggy]

I will continue to have some faith a few players don’t make a team

A "few" extremely irreplacable players

 

[RWnBluey]

Well I guess we’re about to learn more about how deep we bat. Next month is the toughest stretch of the year for us so the timing is not ideal.

 

[Angak]

 

[threenewpadlocks]

Well, in 2016 we had an excellent start to the year before being detailed by injuries..

 

[Doggy]

Research suggests up to 3 months..

Yay

 

[WAbulldog]

Thinking this

In Smith/Emmett Hynes
Out English Jones

 

[Doggy]

Be nice to win at Gather Round at some ****ing point

 

[_Cerberus_]

Be nice to win at Gather Round at some ****ing point

We always get drawn the good teams too.

 

[MaxiBont]

In - Emmett, Hynes
Out - English, Jones

McNeil used as the low % ToG player.

Ruck shared between Lobb/Croft/Emmett

Don’t think the game will be won in the ruck. Meek has been hurt by the new ruck rules.

Still feeling like we can get a result

 

[Doggy]

We always get drawn the good teams too.

Meanwhile geelong always draws the trash..

Typical

 

[Doggy]

In - Emmett, Hynes
Out - English, Jones

McNeil used as the low % ToG player.

Ruck shared between Lobb/Croft/Emmett

Don’t think the game will be won in the ruck. Meek has been hurt by the new ruck rules.

Still feeling like we can get a result

Our midfield has no point of difference without Richards... it is slow as hell

 

[Rocketsurgery]

I am surprised people are suggesting Emmett and Croft take over ruck duties going forward with English out. One player is in his first year and hasn't played an afl game yet, the other has a handful of games and hasn't contributed much since the season started. Wouldn't Lobb be a better option to cover English? He's a seasoned veteran who has rucked many times before and performed well. Then bring Busslinger in to defence. I would drop Croft who is contributing very little atm and play Will Lewis who at least has the physicality to make the Hawks defenders accountable and might even create some space for Naughton and Darcy who seem to be getting locked down of late.

 

[Marsy]

Anybody else having flashbacks to when Roughead injured the tendon behind his knee?

 

[threenewpadlocks]

Out: English, Jones, McNeil

In: Emmett, Hynes, Gallagher/Vandermeer

 

[Doggy]

Never anything to gain by playing those pissants last night... only to lose and look what happened

 

[threenewpadlocks]

I am surprised people are suggesting Emmett and Croft take over ruck duties going forward with English out. One player is in his first year and hasn't played an afl game yet, the other has a handful of games and hasn't contributed much since the season started. Wouldn't Lobb be a better option to cover English? He's a seasoned veteran who has rucked many times before and performed well. Then bring Busslinger in to defence. I would drop Croft who is contributing very little atm and play Will Lewis who at least has the physicality to make the Hawks defenders accountable and might even create some space for Naughton and Darcy who seem to be getting locked down of late.

I think the idea that Busslinger/Gardner would not be so much better than Emmett/Croft/one smaller in defence that its worth not having the flexibility that Emmett provides.

Just because we do pick Emmett, doesn't mean Lobb won't ruck.

If we're dropping Croft and playing Lewis (who surely can't be expected to ruck), who plays key defence in your example?

 

[Ash1337]

Emmett probably gets his debut for English. McNeil might get lucky and stay because he was probably gassed from the VFL and couldn't adjust to the game otherwise he comes out for Hynes. Gallagher in for Jones.

 

[bresker]

" Tendon behind the knee" is that PCL? Hmm...I guess we'll find out midweek

 

[Doggies_13]

English our with an MCL best case scenario would be a mild tweak which is 2-3 weeks but any kind of tear is gonna be 3+

Hopefully Richards is minor but the club saying he will “be assessed this week to establish a firmer timeline” sounds a bit ominous.

Croft has been woeful in each game this season so far. He needs to to find some form at Footscray. McNiel not up to it.

Out: English (inj) Jones (inj) Croft McNiel

In: Emmett Hynes Buss Gallagher

Lobb to ruck, Emmett to provide second ruck duties and third tall forward. Hawks play tall with 3 key forwards and 2 rucks so will need a defender to cover Lobb rucking.


B: Buss JOD Budarick
HB: Dale Khamis Jacques
C : Williams Bont Baker
HF: Dolan Naughton Sanders
F: West Darcy Bramble
R: Lobb Kennedy Freijah
Int: Sellwood Emmett Hynes Davidson Gallagher

Very young team but we don’t have a lot of options.

 

[JohnnySteel]

Would love Carmichael & Emmett to get a run. Both are quality.

 

[BigFloppa]

Damn we're screwed

 

[threenewpadlocks]

I thought Croft did a job when required to in the last quarter with English and Lobb off. Nothing with how he played, which was fine and adequate, suggests to me that Lewis, Busslinger or whoever will play a better overall game in whatever role

 

[BrisDog]

Never anything to gain by playing those pissants last night... only to lose and look what happened

Doggy, maybe get all your negativity out in one big, comprehensive post old son!! The sun has come up, we will be alright

 

[Marsy]

" Tendon behind the knee" is that PCL? Hmm...I guess we'll find out midweek

A tendon atttaches muscle to bone, ligaments attach bone to bone.

The hamstring connects behind the knee.

 

[Doggy]

Doggy, maybe get all your negativity out in one big, comprehensive post old son!! The sun has come up, we will be alright

After the next month... maybe