Gysberts2Bate
Brownlow Medallist
****ing hate those Richmond campaigners
-
AFLW 2025 - AFLW Trade and Draft - All the player moves
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Preview Changes v Richmond - Rd 6, 2021
- Thread starter LeverPuller
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Xhoquelin
Club Legend
- Dec 4, 2016
- 1,099
- 1,120
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Charlotte Hornets
B: Nev May Riv
HB: Salem Tommo Lever
C: Gus Vines Lingers
HF: Milkshakes Weed Spargs
F: Kozzie Boner Fritta
R: Gawn Trac Clarry
Int: Harmes Hunt Hibbo Jacko
Anyone think that's not our best 22 ATM?
HB: Salem Tommo Lever
C: Gus Vines Lingers
HF: Milkshakes Weed Spargs
F: Kozzie Boner Fritta
R: Gawn Trac Clarry
Int: Harmes Hunt Hibbo Jacko
Anyone think that's not our best 22 ATM?
- Oct 18, 2013
- 101,487
- 155,002
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Carolina Panthers
Yes
Anyone who doesn't have TMac in our best 22 clearly haven't watched our games closely enough. He's been fantastic in 3 of our 5 games and only 1 real poor game.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
- Apr 12, 2014
- 34,279
- 62,882
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
Jetta isn’t best 22 anymore and TMac isn’t getting dropped anytime soon.
- Oct 18, 2013
- 101,487
- 155,002
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Carolina Panthers
Agree +
Melksham isn't to me either. At best he's bench depth.
I wouldn't have Harmes in there either, what has he done these past 12 months to even deserve a mention?
GatesOfHell
Club Legend
- Oct 19, 2019
- 1,471
- 1,736
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Banned
- #82
Nev not best 22 anymore. Harmes will have to fight for a spot now, too.
Xhoquelin
Club Legend
- Dec 4, 2016
- 1,099
- 1,120
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Charlotte Hornets
He's a good mark inside F50, better at ground level than Nibbler, what has he ever done in his career to suggest he's not better than Alex Marathon Runner Neal Bullen?
Never understood why we're out on Milkshakes suddenly either. Still a good finisher inside F50, still one of the best kicks inside 50 in our team.
- Oct 18, 2013
- 101,487
- 155,002
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Carolina Panthers
Why isn't Nathan Jones in your best 22 if past performance is an indicator you turn to?
- Oct 18, 2013
- 101,487
- 155,002
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Carolina Panthers
Melksham is a liability defensively now. He provides absolutely nothing. He'll look alright when we are blowing teams away like in the fourth quarter today, I'm not getting sucked in by that tho. He's was nowhere to be seen for the first three quarters, the african kid for hawthorn made him look absolutely useless.
Xhoquelin
Club Legend
- Dec 4, 2016
- 1,099
- 1,120
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Charlotte Hornets
Because Harmes had a drop off playing half back to start the year before being thrown back in the guts, then the wing, then half forward etc. he's not cooked physically like Chunk is, if Chunk still had some legspeed he's probably still a quality player.
Neither is Milkshakes either which is the point.
Xhoquelin
Club Legend
- Dec 4, 2016
- 1,099
- 1,120
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Charlotte Hornets
Is that true or just some analysis you made up off looking at tackles stats. Always been a good runner
- Oct 18, 2013
- 101,487
- 155,002
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Carolina Panthers
Wtf are you talking about? I never look at stats. Judge things off what I see. If you think he was good today defensively youre running off blind faith. He was disgraceful.
I'm still suss on Melksham
Those 2 years of garbage after 2018 really ruined him for me. Especially those games where he waddled around the midfield and did zip. Clearly one of Goody's favourites, for better or for worse.
Baffling he captained the team last year, too.
Those 2 years of garbage after 2018 really ruined him for me. Especially those games where he waddled around the midfield and did zip. Clearly one of Goody's favourites, for better or for worse.
Baffling he captained the team last year, too.
Sir Hugh Percy
BigFooty Aristocrat
Actually thought Chunk was decent in the first 3 rounds, just the last couple he's started to struggle. Hopefully he finds a little more in the tank for his 300th in a big primetime game.
We need BBrown, Weid, May, Fritta and the kitchen sink to throw at these Tigger campaigners. I'd have MBrown, Jordon, Petty and Sparrow out.
We need BBrown, Weid, May, Fritta and the kitchen sink to throw at these Tigger campaigners. I'd have MBrown, Jordon, Petty and Sparrow out.
- Banned
- #91
I'll go Lockhart for Nev
TMAC for Harmes
A mid rotation for Melksham. Cause that 22 is definitely lacking midfield depth.
Gysberts2Bate
Brownlow Medallist
****ing cringe at anyone talking about the 2018 finals series being more important than next week
Goody stated in his post game presser that Jones was definitely playing. The club learnt the hard way about embarrassing/mistreating spiritual leaders.
Topkent
Confirmed ITK Drafting King
Yeah some bad choices in there.
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
May and Slick would be huge returns. Surely May doesn’t get up from that break though. Reckon he’ll miss, bit of fugazi perhaps.
Jones cannot be dropped, in fact this week needs to be one of the biggest in the club's history. He carried us through one of the darkest times in living memory and needs to be celebrated as the club legend he is.
Remember when Norf wouldn't confirm Harvey was going to play his 400th until late in the week? It was poor, left a bad taste in the mouth and ruined a historic occasion. They were trying to look tough and it didn't do them any favours.
Remember when Norf wouldn't confirm Harvey was going to play his 400th until late in the week? It was poor, left a bad taste in the mouth and ruined a historic occasion. They were trying to look tough and it didn't do them any favours.
I haven’t read this entire thread and the Jones discussion, but I’ll leave an outsider/American viewpoint. And I’m prepared for all of your thumbs-down responses.
WhenI first started following the club by rewatching the recently concluded 2018 season, Jones was one of my favorite players. I remember him kicking a massive, captains goal in a desperately needed situation in his 250th game. And his goal and iconic celebration against the cats is my favorite moment in my short time following the team.
And when he stepped down as captain, my respect for him grew only more. I have no idea if he was pressured to do that. But it had the mark of a man putting the best interests of the team ahead of his own. That’s leadership. That’s the mark of a man who loves his team.
But if he plays against Richmond, I will lose a good amount of respect for him. I’ll also lose respect for the system and culture that would allow it. Americans are viewed as selfish assholes, interested only in what’s best for them (rightfully so I may add). And yet, this... this would not be tolerated. You will argue that he’s earned the right. And my question is the right to what? To give his team a worse chance to win? What right is that? A true leader would refuse to hamper his teams chances one bit in such a big game. Especially in a season so rare for this club.
He’s seen a lot of losing, and he’s been a good soldier. Don’t ruin it now by being an anchor to the team. He’ll get his 300th, but what an absolute legend if he took it out of Goodys hands that it wouldn’t be this week.
WhenI first started following the club by rewatching the recently concluded 2018 season, Jones was one of my favorite players. I remember him kicking a massive, captains goal in a desperately needed situation in his 250th game. And his goal and iconic celebration against the cats is my favorite moment in my short time following the team.
And when he stepped down as captain, my respect for him grew only more. I have no idea if he was pressured to do that. But it had the mark of a man putting the best interests of the team ahead of his own. That’s leadership. That’s the mark of a man who loves his team.
But if he plays against Richmond, I will lose a good amount of respect for him. I’ll also lose respect for the system and culture that would allow it. Americans are viewed as selfish assholes, interested only in what’s best for them (rightfully so I may add). And yet, this... this would not be tolerated. You will argue that he’s earned the right. And my question is the right to what? To give his team a worse chance to win? What right is that? A true leader would refuse to hamper his teams chances one bit in such a big game. Especially in a season so rare for this club.
He’s seen a lot of losing, and he’s been a good soldier. Don’t ruin it now by being an anchor to the team. He’ll get his 300th, but what an absolute legend if he took it out of Goodys hands that it wouldn’t be this week.
Topkent
Confirmed ITK Drafting King
You're not wrong, but I'd say the intangible boost it brings the culture and club celebrating this warriors 300 together just outweighs his performance. Normally I'd say it's a complete wank but I honestly believe it will galvanise the football club in ways you can't see.
I don't know if a player will ever earn my respect more than Jonesy from 2012-18 and it's gonna mean alot to alot of people around this club to see him run through that banner.
- Oct 18, 2013
- 101,487
- 155,002
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Carolina Panthers
You're coming round to me and Blitz.
Look , I absolutely reckon he put the club in a no win situation over the offseason and 100% should have pulled the plug himself. I'm not as up for this significant occasion because he's been gifted the past 25 or so games.
But ..
We are here now, what's done is done and despite Jones leaving a sour taste in my mouth he absolutely deserves to have his career celebrated. It honestly doesn't matter to me who it's against. I'd prefer to get it out of the way now so we can move on from it and focus on bigger goals towards the end of the year. (Preferably without Jones cause the need for sympathy games will have passed now the milestone has been reached)
100% agree about losing some sort of respect for him. Never like seeing club champs have to be told to go rather than releasing when the time is right themselves.
Topkent
Confirmed ITK Drafting King
You're coming round to me and Blitz.
Look , I absolutely reckon he put the club in a no win situation over the offseason and 100% should have pulled the plug himself. I'm not as up for this significant occasion because he's been gifted the past 25 or so games.
But ..
We are here now, what's done is done and despite Jones leaving a sour taste in my mouth he absolutely deserves to have his career celebrated. It honestly doesn't matter to me who it's against. I'd prefer to get it out of the way now so we can move on from it and focus on bigger goals towards the end of the year. (Preferably without Jones cause the need for sympathy games will have passed now the milestone has been reached)
100% agree about losing some sort of respect for him. Never like seeing club champs have to be told to go rather than releasing when the time is right themselves.
Just one thing though, it's gotta be easy to walk away when you're a 3x premiership player.
I don't think Jones gives a **** about 300, he's played 2 finals series in his whole career I honestly just think he wants to play in a good team
