Preview Changes v Saints Rd 6

[timtamWB]

What a bloody win.

No injury worries from the looks of it. I think a few guys might need a rest. And has Cordy run his race?

I'm honestly thinking no changes at the moment. Everyone deserves their spot.

 

[Bont2Bruce]

What a bloody win.

No injury worries from the looks of it. I think a few guys might need a rest. And has Cordy run his race?

I'm honestly thinking no changes at the moment. Everyone deserves their spot.

Cordy clearly can't do much as a forward, and he can't do much in the ruck either.

As a decoy, he has broken even from time to time. But we need someone who can give us first use from the ruck more than 1 in 10 times.

 

[Dale4captain]

Out -Cordy.
In - One of Hamling, Campbell or Minson.

Leaning towards Hamling so Rough can spend the entire game in the ruck.

 

[ossie_21]

In - Me for a kick around Etihad because I'm coming to Melbourne

Out - A. Cordy

Replace Ayce with someone who is......




Ace.

YEEAAAHHHHHHHHH

 

[House_of_Dahl]

Roberts played pretty well. Will be interesting to see if Bev gives Roughy a go as first ruck.

 

[Testekill]

Roberts played pretty well. Will be interesting to see if Bev gives Roughy a go as first ruck.

I could see us having Roughy ruck next week and Hamling replacing him as a defender.

 

[fargy]

Cordy has had a go, not up to it and there is no shame in it.

Other than that anyone out would be extremely unlucky! But I wouldn't be adverse to bringing in some fresh legs, can't afford to drop a game to the Saints after a win like that!

 

[footscraybulldog]

OUT: AYCE CORDY

Think this was his last game for the us. When Lin Jong has more hit outs then our own ruckman.....

 

[DognBones]

Out:
Cordy, as always he's just too light for an AFL ruckman and to need a third player jumping over the top (Jong etc) just to nullify the opposition ruckman says it all
Smith: struggled again and needs a longer stint in the VFL to build fitness
In: Minson or Campbell
Hunter

 

[Zephiisdaman]

Out:
Cordy, as always he's just too light for an AFL ruckman and to need a third player jumping over the top (Jong etc) just to nullify the opposition ruckman says it all
Smith: struggled again and needs a longer stint in the VFL to build fitness
In: Minson or Campbell
Hunter

I agree Clay needs a gallop in the Magoos. He is in when fit and conditioned though.
Ayce just has to go. Awful today

 

[fargy]

First game going in as favourites for the year! And we are 4-1!!

 

[Dav1d]

hmm
Hunter & Minson in

 

[Doggstats]

Minson in for Cordy. As much as I love Hrovat 2 weeks in a row he lets himself down with bad decisions/mistakes, gave up 2 goals last week from turnovers and today made more bad decisions. He always seems to be in a rush, needs to take a breath and think his way through things.

 

[threenewpadlocks]

As much as I have defended Cordy:

Out: Cordy, plus whoever pulls up the worst after that physically brutal game
In: Minson, Wallis

 

[VitalDread]

Out: 3rd place
In: 1st place

 

[Struggle]

Minson in for Cordy. As much as I love Hrovat 2 weeks in a row he lets himself down with bad decisions/mistakes, gave up 2 goals last week from turnovers and today made more bad decisions. He always seems to be in a rush, needs to take a breath and think his way through things.

Hrovats last 10 minutes were amazing. Honeychurch in the gun before him

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Out: 3rd place
In: 1st place

We need Fremantle to lose a game, and we don't get that chance until the week after next...

 

[House_of_Dahl]

Hrovats last 10 minutes were amazing. Honeychurch in the gun before him

The rat was good at the end, but don't think honey should be in any trouble either.

 

[TheHoneyBadger]

Both Honeychurch and Hrovat shouldn't be anywhere near the chopping block. They've played a combined 30 games and they're already making significant contributions to winning teams - only AFL game time can benefit them now.

 

[ExpertDog]

Minson should have played today in the wet. Give Ace next week he needs an extended run in the dry to be sure he is not up to it.

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Minson should have played today in the wet. Give Ace next week he needs an extended run in the dry to be sure he is not up to it.

Q1 was perfectly dry.

Pyke was on world record pace for hitouts to advantage at the end of the first quarter. Ayce lost the first 6-7 contests so badly that we didn't get a disposal in the centre square until near the end of Q1.

 

[threenewpadlocks]

Both Honeychurch and Hrovat shouldn't be anywhere near the chopping block. They've played a combined 30 games and they're already making significant contributions to winning teams - only AFL game time can benefit them now.

People are forgetting this quite quickly. These two are doing exceptionally well for their age by AFL standards - but we've been blessed with Bonts, Macrae, Stringer etc. so compared to them it doesn't look so good. But in reality, there's not much more you can ask for a 10/20 gamer in their 2nd/3rd season.

 

[dergert]

Cordy out and redpath in (roughie rucking)

 

[Martyn_30_]

Out- Cordy never to return
In- Anyone tall

 

[Doggies_13]

Out: Cordy Smith
In: Campbell Hunter

Campbell deserves the a crack at number one ruck Cordy hasn't taken his chance
Smith should have thrieved in todays conditions needs a few more VFL games under his belt