Changes vs Melbourne Round 8

[threenewpadlocks]

For me:
Out: Goodes
In: Biggs

 

[JTCWBFC]

Out: goodes, honey (inj), stringer (inj), Hunter

In: Biggs macrae grant hrovat


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[AFDogs]

IN:
Macrae
Webb

OUT:
Hunter
Goodes

Leave the rest for now.

 

[Doggies_13]

Out:
Goodes - not up to it
Hunter- ducked his head multiple times scared
Honey - not sure for bad his shoulder is

In:
Minson - need a number 1 ruck
Macrae - too talented for vfl
Biggs - been consistent time to get a chance

 

[Libba39]

Outs:
Jong - needs a week or two in the vfl to get his groove back
Honey - assuming inj
Hunter - just too flakey for me

Ins:
Biggs
Macrae
Grant

 

[DylanW]

Kinda think we should give Hunter another week. If he continues this rate of improvement he should play well next week. Much better than last week

 

[DylanW]

Out: Honey (inj) Stringer (inj)
In: Hrovat Grant

 

[VitalDread]

Out: Hunter Honey
in: Macrae Webb

 

[VitalDread]

Kinda think we should give Hunter another week. If he continues this rate of improvement he should play well next week. Much better than last week

i want him to play next weekend but i feel like he would be the sub again which is why i voted him out
he isnt sub material

 

[_Mike_]

In : Macrae Webb Biggs, Grant, Minson
Out Goodes , Stringer inj, Honeychurch inj , Cordy

 

[VitalDread]

Melbourne will likely call up Watts, Gawn ans Neal Bullen for our match up

They will stick with Spencer, hes improved a hell of a lot but struggles with running ruckman a bit

 

[hatescaptcha]

OUT:
Goodes
Honeychurch

IN:
Webb
Macrae

 

[Super Hans]

Out: Goodes, Honey
In: Macrae, Biggs

 

[fronkalicious]

Out - honey
In - hrovat

Out - Jong
In - macrae

Out - goodes
In - Biggs

Out - Wallis
In - Webb

Thought Wallis and Jong were spectacularly bad I'm afraid.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Doggstats]

Out: Goodes, Hunter, Cordy

In: Macrae, Grant, Minson

Wouldn't have lost to StK or Freo with this lineup imo.

 

[Brassrazoo]

Out: Cordy, Honeychurch, Goodes

In: Minson, Biggs, MacRae

 

[fargy]

If Honey isn't right, Hrovat comes in.

Goodes out for Macrae.

I am completely mystified with the ruck, at stages Stevens, Bonts, and Crameri rucked, while Goodes spent a fair chunk in the ruck! Maybe Bev will drop Cordy for another small

 

[Struggle]

Out: CORDY
In: Anyone

 

[fred cook]

Out Goodes Goodes Goodes Goodes Goodes Goodes Goodes Goodes
In Anybody as long it is not Goodes

 

[Doggstats]

If Honey isn't right, Hrovat comes in.

Goodes out for Macrae.

I am completely mystified with the ruck, at stages Stevens, Bonts, and Crameri rucked, while Goodes spent a fair chunk in the ruck! Maybe Bev will drop Cordy for another small

As good as Bevo has been, his ruck philosophy is quickly becoming the laughing stock of the AFL. It's only going to get worse each week aswell, Freo obviously came prepared running setplays for Sandi to Fyfe. Same thing as Armatige and Longer last week but alot more efficient. Each week the set plays will become better and better, until we are forced to either bring Will back or run some hard tags in the mid. And by then Will will be rusty as **** because he spent all year in the VFL. We are going to waste half a year of experience with this flawed setup.

 

[TimlinOfficial]

What's the news about Stringer? Was at the game and didn't know he was injured as some are suggesting

OUT: Honey (shoulder), Goodes

IN: Macrae, Biggs

If Stringer is injured, bring in Grant. Give Hunter a full game and see how he goes, I thought he did some good things, the criticism has been very harsh. Cordy also did some good things but was always going to be mauled in the hitouts. I'd be unhappy if he were dropped after his last two games but can see the argument for bringing Minson/Campbell in. If Hunter has another poor game, swap him with Hrovat. Give Webb another week in the VFL before bringing him back, no need to rush, long season for a young kid

 

[TempleKelvington]

Not sure Jacko gets back in based on Saturday's form, but he's a class player so who knows. If String is injured he must be rested, something is not right with him. I'd seriously consider Grant next week, Hrovat is some Chance and big Will did play his best game for a while.

Jong started to get into the game after a very slow, nervous start. He and Wallis will be better for the run. Hunter gave a fair bit when he came on should get a full game next week.

Dale showed a bit, but I leave him out next week.

 

[Zgope1]

Out - honey
In - hrovat

Out - Jong
In - macrae

Out - goodes
In - Biggs

Out - Wallis
In - Webb

Thought Wallis and Jong were spectacularly bad I'm afraid.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

agree but i'm writing it off as first game back syndrome, although Jong will be very lucky to stay.

Out- Goodes, Honey

In- Minson, Webb

If another has to go it'd be Jong for Grant

 

[Zgope1]

Minson plays next week and we're a very hard team to beat. They'd need to share the ruck and we'd need to probably sub one of them but we should be able to make this melbourne side turn it over. we can make everyone else turn it over

 

[Hrovat24]

Out Goodes cordy honeychurch hunter Jong
In hrovat Biggs grant Minson macrae