Ive been in both camps. However Martin seems to have shown to be far more explosive.
List Mgmt. "Gold Pass" Mackay: Put a fork in him
- Thread starter Rory Walkerfield
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Haha I see what you did. Very clever!
Red mist
Reynholm Industries
- Jun 30, 2014
- 29,143
- 34,097
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspur, East Side Hawks
He just doesn't provide enough of what he is there for.
Pressure for spots should see him slide back in the pecking order.
fairfooty
Premiership Player
Sheesh - anyone realise it was his birthday today - he was 27 by my calculations? Can't even 'party' for a birthday!
We dont have anything against him personally just today he looked like a lame duck. His body language is shot and has no confidence.
- Banned
- #33
Not sure about that.
Can't we get him to work off the contract we paid him washing Campos car?
I know we (myself included) are a fickle bunch,
But srsly
Martin is a better footballer than 400kay.
Trade Moo for a late 2nd / early 3rd and go to the draft
But srsly
Martin is a better footballer than 400kay.
Trade Moo for a late 2nd / early 3rd and go to the draft
- Sep 11, 2009
- 5,135
- 3,977
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Must trade. We need a Blight like moment. The club needs to clean out the dead wood.
MacKay - I dont care how Victorian the commentators are, if they still cant say his name right after 8-9 years on a senior list, and 139 AFL games, then it has to be that he is so bad he doesnt get noticed. Have a look at the way players like Heath Shaw, Birchall, Mackie, S Hill, Yarran etc contribute. Then you have MacKay who hasnt had over 14 possessions in about 2 months, or over 60 Fantasy points. What good is speed and an elite leg if you arent running to get the ball, and only 8 kicks a game. Currently has his lowest disposal count average since his debut year
MacKay - I dont care how Victorian the commentators are, if they still cant say his name right after 8-9 years on a senior list, and 139 AFL games, then it has to be that he is so bad he doesnt get noticed. Have a look at the way players like Heath Shaw, Birchall, Mackie, S Hill, Yarran etc contribute. Then you have MacKay who hasnt had over 14 possessions in about 2 months, or over 60 Fantasy points. What good is speed and an elite leg if you arent running to get the ball, and only 8 kicks a game. Currently has his lowest disposal count average since his debut year
Has Wayne's-World talked about DMack lately, like how we know nothing because we haven't watched him with our eye?
- Oct 31, 2014
- 1,726
- 4,014
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Miami Heat
Wright, by a bee's pube. Totally ineffective by both players.
Its a race to the sewer for these two
He's saying we're lemmings because we're judging Mackay on his stats.
STrAng3C1oUdZ
Team Captain
- Aug 31, 2013
- 368
- 344
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Pretty harsh criticism of the guy im not his biggest fan but i think he's been ok! Yeah he might have turned the ball over a bit but he is taking the game on and when a player is doing that they are always going to make mistakes
He player on the wing and had 13 possessions
I thought I saw ww bring up stats to compare two players in another thread today.
Who
Saying yarran gets less possessions than Mackay
- Oct 16, 2011
- 15,360
- 38,192
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
I can't be the only one that questions this but does he really have pace?
I have seen him chase a few opponents this year and lets be fair about this, Wil E Coyote has more chance of catching the Roadrunner. I mean I'm not expecting him to catch people with a 5 metre head start but they all increase the distance on him, he doesn't close it down. Compare that with Mr Cameron and a 5 metre gap probably guarantees you at full pace about 10 metres to get rid of it before he grabs you. Charlie has pace, Mackay is faster than Lyons but not by much.
I have seen him chase a few opponents this year and lets be fair about this, Wil E Coyote has more chance of catching the Roadrunner. I mean I'm not expecting him to catch people with a 5 metre head start but they all increase the distance on him, he doesn't close it down. Compare that with Mr Cameron and a 5 metre gap probably guarantees you at full pace about 10 metres to get rid of it before he grabs you. Charlie has pace, Mackay is faster than Lyons but not by much.
fairfooty
Premiership Player
And we've had 6 odd years of this since his debut in 2008... even I'm saying enough!
Agree. He didnt get a lot of it and never does but he provided some much needed run today. Id prefer we had a more effective winger but he always offers more than wright does.
