Opinion Joel Selwood Vs Patrick Dangerfield .Who was the better player?

[The 747]

I vote for the Richmond player

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Main board seems to be learning.

 

[Orange crush]

Richmond

The answer to almost any question

 

[Sky]

Selwood. Don’t like Dangerfield and never have. Always wished we got Boak instead as unlike Ablett Jnr and very much like Selwood, the epitome of loyalty

 

[Elmer_Judd]

Selwood for mine, his finals record and performances were extraordinary, which
something Danger has been somewhat disappointing at.

 

[janty]

Both have been overrated for most of their careers.

In a best vs best scenario I would take Dangerfield who could rip a game open.

 

[James Colorado]

Dangerfield the "better" player, but Selwood the stronger leader. If you want individual brilliance and someone who can put together an amazing season, then you choose Dangerfield. If you want someone who leads from day one and raises those around them, then Selwood. I'd rather leadership over mercurial, so would be picking Selwood.

 

[Power Raid]

Dangerfield, simply for the fact that he didn't have to resort to unsportsmanlike dropping of the knees in order to get his possessions. I know Danger sometimes plays for frees, but Selwood was on a whole other level.

The sad bit is he was a good player who didn’t need to resort to undermining the spirit, health and safety of the game.

But what is done is done

 

[Cursed Cat]

Selwood very comfortably.

 

[Falcon3518]

Selwood very comfortably.

I knew cats supporters overrated Selwood but I didn’t know it was this bad, not even teammates are safe.

 

[PetterdHoisted]

It's Selwood

in spite of his behaviour with FKs