Preview R20: Changes vs. Port Adelaide

[FR0GGY]

Predictable nonsense.

What is?

 

[Cromulant]

What is?

Your opinion around Jones is flawed.

 

[FR0GGY]

Your opinion around Jones is flawed.

How so?
He’s got the career statistics of Murphy who gets absolutely shat on.
If he wasn’t the pick he was he’d have been delisted 2 years ago.

 

[Cromulant]

How so?
He’s got the career statistics of Murphy who gets absolutely shat on.
If he wasn’t the pick he was he’d have been delisted 2 years ago.

Like Murphy has been ??

He played a role yesterday, and played it well.

I think you and others are so fixated on a pick number it absolutely clouds your judgement. His draft pick number is irrelevant

 

[FR0GGY]

Like Murphy has been ??

He played a role yesterday, and played it well.

I think you and others are so fixated on a pick number it absolutely clouds your judgement. His draft pick number is irrelevant

Read above his role was exaggerated by fanboys.
Pick number means nothing to me but as I said he’d have been delisted by now.

 

[FullyBigKPro]

Maybe not this week (fitness depending) but wouldn't mind Mrouch back in our midfield to help Berry, Peatling and Soligo who have been banged up a bit and doing some hard work...

 

[spenze]

Read above his role was exaggerated by fanboys.
Pick number means nothing to me but as I said he’d have been delisted by now.

Don't go bringing facts into a clap fight

 

[spenze]

Maybe not this week (fitness depending) but wouldn't mind Mrouch back in our midfield to help Berry, Peatling and Soligo who have been banged up a bit and doing some hard work...

Eeeeeeew

 

[Cromulant]

Read above his role was exaggerated by fanboys.
Pick number means nothing to me but as I said he’d have been delisted by now.

If it means nothing then why mention it ??

He wasn't as bad as you are making him out to be either, in fact I dont think we haf a "bad" player at all yesterday

 

[Cromulant]

Don't go bringing facts into a clap fight

You struggle with facts it seems

 

[Cromulant]

Maybe not this week (fitness depending) but wouldn't mind Mrouch back in our midfield to help Berry, Peatling and Soligo who have been banged up a bit and doing some hard work...

Nope.

 

[FR0GGY]

If it means nothing then why mention it ??

He wasn't as bad as you are making him out to be either, in fact I dont think we haf a "bad" player at all yesterday

It means nothing to how I’m judging him.
It clearly means something to the club.
As I said compare his career to Murphy and you wouldn’t know whose was whose.

 

[Cromulant]

It means nothing to how I’m judging him.
It clearly means something to the club.
As I said compare his career to Murphy and you wouldn’t know whose was whose.

If you compare a career, or a stats page ??

Thats what you seem to be doing

 

[FR0GGY]

If you compare a career, or a stats page ??

Thats what you seem to be doing

Same same for them, what about Chayces career trumps Murphy.
I’ll wait.

Maybe a best n fairest result?
Malcolm Blight Medal 10 - 2023
1 - Jordan Dawson - 132 votes
2 - Rory Laird - 115
3 - Taylor Walker - 98
Eq.4 - Izak Rankine - 92
Eq.4 - Mitch Hinge - 92
6 - Lachlan Murphy - 91
7 - Brodie Smith - 87
8 - Chayce Jones - 80
9 - Ben Keays - 80
10 - Wayne Milera - 79

 

[GameofSloanes]

SPP. Aliir is on one leg. Rozee under a cloud

Heard rozee in the radio today. Did not fill me with confidence that he'll be playing. Knowing port he'll play anyway and be worse than whoever his replacement would be

 

[FR0GGY]

Heard rozee in the radio today. Did not fill me with confidence that he'll be playing. Knowing port he'll play anyway and be worse than whoever his replacement would be

That would be ideal

 

[Alwaysacrow]

This will probably be an unpopular suggestion but I'm wondering if we can fit Crouch in the side at the expense of Jones? Jones to me has the least upside of our current team lineup. He's been regurgitated many times over his career and usually still seems to come up short.

 

[GameofSloanes]

Taylor still chugging along. Doing just enough to stay in but not enough to command a spot.

He's value for touches (11 disposals for 7 score involvements yesterday) so I'm inclined to keep him in

He's also doing a defensive role on rebounding defenders. Quite well actually

 

[MrBarry]

This will probably be an unpopular suggestion but I'm wondering if we can fit Crouch in the side at the expense of Jones? Jones to me has the least upside of our current team lineup. He's been regurgitated many times over his career and usually still seems to come up short.

Draper should be in ahead of Jones.

 

[jenny61_99]

Like Murphy has been ??

He played a role yesterday, and played it well.

I think you and others are so fixated on a pick number it absolutely clouds your judgement. His draft pick number is irrelevant

I wasn’t overly impressed by jones on watching it live. Will watch the replay again, but I am not hopeful.

 

[GameofSloanes]

It wasn’t wet in Launceston, just bitterly cold and dewy

It was absolutely pouring several times

 

[radiojake]

The Rose is the one a couple streets off Brunswick St ?? Haven't been there in years, but then I havent had much of a reason to go to Melbourne for footy for a lot of that time.

My old man and I use to stay up that end of town when we'd head over to watch games.

The Rose had renovations maybe getting close to 10 years ago now - Lost its charm after that which is a shame - When I lived in Fitzroy it's where I went to watch Crows games - The renovations lined up around the time with me moving out of Fitzroy so haven't been there for ages now - but yeah I just never quite understood why they went for that silver shiny sports bar main room vibe from what they used to have

Didn't realise the owners were Crows fans - but maybe the owners changed with the renovations ?

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

We really should do an honour guard for Ken.

Going to miss that guy

With fake teeth.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Whatever role cook was playing last week is what we want him playing again.

Wing... so it makes sense he plays there again & we move Cumming to HBF to replace Hinge... as not worth risking him.

We shouldn't be playing anyone with significant injuries, so Fog is the other one we need to monitor.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Any significant injuries out of yesterday? I noticed Fog and Dawson getting treatment at various stages.

Fog took a knock early watching the highlights tonight.

Dawson was more about management i think, though he was sore last week after the Gawn clash, so probably more about that.