Draft Review 2015 - Redo the 2015 AFL Draft

Remove this Banner Ad

Feva said:
I think most lists are right with Oliver at #1 at this stage.

But, i would not swap Curnow for any player out of the 2015 crop.
Click to expand...
Agree 100%

I have Oliver number 1 easily on current output and wouldn't swap him for anyone.

Having said that Curnow probably should end up the best player of the draft and close to the best player in the game down the track
 
Wild Bill said:
Banick was 180cm back pocket. He wasn’t a KPD. 2cm taller than McGrath.
Click to expand...

Ok cheers, my memory was of Banik playing a bit taller than that. Interesting reading people's memories about him, not sure if his career was restricted because of illness or a lack of talent.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Going by a mixture of exposed/projected form. Curious to see where the order lands at the end of the year.
  1. Oliver
  2. Curnow
  3. Weitering
  4. Hipwood
  5. Burton
  6. Mills
  7. Hopper
  8. Gresham
  9. Rioli
  10. Parish
  11. McDonald-Tipungwuti
  12. Menegola
  13. Papley
  14. Adams
  15. Kennedy
  16. Dunkley
  17. Fiorini
  18. Mathieson
 
Tulip said:
Going by a mixture of exposed/projected form. Curious to see where the order lands at the end of the year.
  1. Oliver
  2. Curnow
  3. Weitering
  4. Hipwood
  5. Burton
  6. Mills
  7. Hopper
  8. Gresham
  9. Rioli
  10. Parish
  11. McDonald-Tipungwuti
  12. Menegola
  13. Papley
  14. Adams
  15. Kennedy
  16. Dunkley
  17. Fiorini
  18. Mathieson
Click to expand...

You can't find room for Ryan Clarke there?

Anyway, the KPP's should start coming now.
 
Snake_Baker said:
You can't find room for Ryan Clarke there?

Anyway, the KPP's should start coming now.
Click to expand...

Could be there in place of Fiorini and Mathieson but it’s much of a muchness. Schache, McKay, Durdin and Weideman need to have big seasons
 
Jesslc said:
Yeah, no pressure on Francis or Redman though.
Click to expand...
Francis is going through a lot, so no pressure on him. Redman is a mid who went at 30, so its not as if he's really expected to do much. Neither are talls, and I'm not an Essendon fan - so not sure where you're coming from on this. Schache, Weideman, McKay were all top 10 picks. Durdin slid (as corrected, in 2014) but was still a first round pick that had a big reputation.
 
Tulip said:
Francis is going through a lot, so no pressure on him. Redman is a mid who went at 30, so its not as if he's really expected to do much. Neither are talls, and I'm not an Essendon fan - so not sure where you're coming from on this. Schache, Weideman, McKay were all top 10 picks. Durdin slid (as corrected, in 2014) but was still a first round pick that had a big reputation.
Click to expand...
lol my bad! definitely got the idea from the other comments that you were an essendon supporter being super bias'd and had the red and navy in my perupherals. Durdin's getting there. I'm not worried as a north boy. Watched him the other day at Arden St and he's almost ready to get comfortable at senior level. Mckay's ready for the blues and Weideman's a question mark.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Jesslc said:
lol my bad! definitely got the idea from the other comments that you were an essendon supporter being super bias'd and had the red and navy in my perupherals. Durdin's getting there. I'm not worried as a north boy. Watched him the other day at Arden St and he's almost ready to get comfortable at senior level. Mckay's ready for the blues and Weideman's a question mark.
Click to expand...

"The other comments"... tulips literally doesnt mention anything Essendon at all apart from rating AMT and Parish. Think the you need to hold up the mirror when you talk about bias... classic small club syndrome
 
JDavey said:
"The other comments"... tulips literally doesnt mention anything Essendon at all apart from rating AMT and Parish. Think the you need to hold up the mirror when you talk about bias... classic small club syndrome
Click to expand...
yeah... not interested, champ. Move on.
 
Tulip said:
Going by a mixture of exposed/projected form. Curious to see where the order lands at the end of the year.
  1. Oliver
  2. Curnow
  3. Weitering
  4. Hipwood
  5. Burton
  6. Mills
  7. Hopper
  8. Gresham
  9. Rioli
  10. Parish
  11. McDonald-Tipungwuti
  12. Menegola
  13. Papley
  14. Adams
  15. Kennedy
  16. Dunkley
  17. Fiorini
  18. Mathieson
Click to expand...
Menegola should be nowhere near this list.
 
Tulip said:
Going by a mixture of exposed/projected form. Curious to see where the order lands at the end of the year.
  1. Oliver
  2. Curnow
Click to expand...
I'll give it a crack up to Tippa... no fear (be nice, just my opinion, and a bit of comedy) and the song.
  1. Oliver - Outstanding. Def has the tools to be a 250 game player. Dees have got a gem here. Look, he took a dive, but so what. SONG: Man Overboard Do Re Me

  2. Curnow - Strong hands. Good footy brain. Does the exceptional. Could be anything. SONG: Shooting Star: Bag Raiders

  3. Weitering - Looks 'elite'. Personally, would like to see a bit more 'grunt', but has the full package. SONG: Solid: Ashford and Simpson

  4. Hipwood - Good tall. Could be Great. If he was at Collingwood, would be a Superstar. Underrated and should aim high. SONG: Dreamer: Supertramp.

  5. Burton - Wow. He's an impressive unit. Would walk in to 18 teams. SONG: Xanadu: Olivia Newton-John.

  6. Mills - I must say, I had huge wraps on this kid. He's still got the skills, but others have done better. I hate be proven wrong, so I'm backing him in. SONG: Young Turks: Rod Stewart

  7. Hopper - Not yet, but his day will come. Maybe not at the Giants. Needs serious midfield time, but can't get it at GWS. Change of clubs would be best. SONG: Well Respected Man: The Kinks.

  8. Gresham - Decent stats (according to footywire) for his limited games. Small sample size, but I get a good feeling about him. Could be a decent player. SONG: Electric Feels: MGMT

  9. Rioli - Jury is out. No sh*t fights. The guy has talent, but so does Harley. Hope they both see it through. I guess time will tell. SONG: Time after Time: Cyndi Lauper

  10. Parish - Look, I really like this guy. I had no idea he was only 180cm. Plays taller. I hope he has his time away from footy and gets the help he needs. Footy 'aint everything... but it sure beat's what's second (I can't remember who said that). He would be a 'feel good story' for me. SONG: Up There Cazaly: Mike Brady.
  11. McDonald-Tipungwuti - "Down Among the Dead Men" is my favourite song from Flash in the Pan. SONG: Down Among the Dead Men: Flash in the Pan"
 
2015 draft redone
This is what I’ve come up with who’s shown the most so far, not necessarily where I’d redraft each player. Pretty happy to have Milera, Doedee and Greenwood at the Crows.

1.Oliver
2.Mills
3.Rioli
4.Curnow
5.Burton
6.Papley
7.Hipwood
8.Weitering
9.Tippa
10.Parish
11.Gresham
12.Menengola
13.Greenwood
14.Hartley
15.Kennedy
16.Fiorini
17.Adams
18.Phillips
19.Ah Chee
20.Broad
21.Mathieson
22.Milera
23.Himmelburg
24.Silvangi
25.Bonner
26.Hardwick
27.Dunkley
28.Tucker
29.Doedee
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Ticky009
  • Locked
2023 AFL DRAFT - National Draft completed, PSD & Rookie Draft Wednesday @ 3pm
30 31 32 33 34
Replies
838
Views
45K
Vindicater
Vindicater
adammania9
Draft Review 1999 - Revisit the draft
Replies
2
Views
740
GWS Goose
GWS Goose
S
Rookie draft 2023
Replies
4
Views
1K
Vindicater
Vindicater
S
Draft Review 2022 - Revisit the 2022 AFL Draft
2 3 4
Replies
94
Views
7K
Kane McGoodwin
Kane McGoodwin
BigVic
Grade your team's draft 2023
5 6 7 8 9
Replies
219
Views
17K
ScrappyDo
ScrappyDo
dajesmac
Each Club's Draft Needs 2023
2
Replies
49
Views
4K
Vindicater
Vindicater
Jeremias
  • Sticky
Win Prizes 2023 Official Draft Tipping Competition - Join Now!
Replies
15
Views
2K
Lore
Lore

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top