Round 1 Team vs Essendon

[awesome wells]

what do you think?

B: Firrito Gibson Pratt
HB: Urquhart Watt Lower
C: Smith Simpson Wells
HF: Grant Petrie Jones
F: Edwards Thompson McMahon
R: McIntosh Harvey Harris

Int: Hale Swallow Sinclair Hansen

thomas, campbell and harding unlucky to miss

 

[rickety]

Scott Thompson??

 

[NimChief]

You are giving Campbell nothing.

He should, and deserves to start come round one.

Has been playing some excellent football.

 

[awesome wells]

^yeah i was thinking him, but then i thought rd 1 might be too soon

 

[awesome wells]

You are giving Campbell nothing.

He should, and deserves to start come round one.

Has been playing some excellent football.

yeh i know, but i did state he was unlucky to miss

 

[awesome wells]

B: Firrito Gibson Pratt
HB: Urquhart Watt Lower
C: Smith Simpson Wells
HF: Grant Petrie Jones
F: Edwards Thompson McMahon
R: McIntosh Harvey Harris

Int: Hale Swallow Campbell Hansen

OUT: Sinclair
IN: Campbell

 

[giantroo]

Smith won'tbe back by then.

 

[Carnthe]

what i'd like to see:

gibson firrito pratt
hansen petrie thompson
smith harris wells
jones edwards harvey
grant thompson campbell

mcintosh simpson rawlings

hale urquhart swallow mcmahon

 

[Bowski]

My guess at the team for round 1. Bold Equals certain starter while underline equals injured. The rest have question marks about whether they'll be put in or taken out.

People pushing for spots in order of possibility.
Lower
Harding
S Thompson
Adams
Power
Urqhart
Thomas
Brown
Davies


B: Firrito Gibson Pratt
HB: Watt Petrie Sinclair
C: Smith Simpson Rawlings
HF: Grant Jones McMahon
F: Edwards Thompson Harvey
R: McIntosh Wells Harris

Int: Hale Swallow Campbell Hansen

Just having a guess at whats going through JYDs head.

 

[budge11]

what do you think?

B: Firrito Gibson Pratt
HB: Urquhart Watt Lower
C: Smith Simpson Wells
HF: Grant Petrie Jones
F: Edwards Thompson McMahon
R: McIntosh Harvey Harris

Int: Hale Swallow Sinclair Hansen

thomas, campbell and harding unlucky to miss

Smith + Wells not playing I think

Adams IN
Campbell IN
S. Thomo IN

Lower OUT
Smith OUT
Wells OUT

 

[The Other Dean]

OUT: Sinclair
IN: Campbell

That is not something that I would be unhappy to see.

(Does this count as a double negative ? If so, yay.)

 

[NMFC ALWAYS]

Smith + Wells not playing I think

Adams IN
Campbell IN
S. Thomo IN

Lower OUT
Smith OUT
Wells OUT

is Ed injured? coz i think he should be persisted with

 

[budge11]

Don't beleive so, just we havn't seen him this year and I think the others deserve a crack at it. However, i'd be stoked if Lower got a shot at it and did well

 

[NICK_ROOBOY83]

B: Firrito Gibson Pratt
HB: Urquhart Watt Sinclair
C: Grant Simpson Wells
HF: McMahon Petrie Jones
F: Edwards Thompson Campbell
R: McIntosh Harvey Harris

Int: Hale Swallow Hansen Harding


I sorta expect Drewy to go down back if needed. Wellsy will pay.

 

[budge11]

I like that team you just posted... nice balance to it

 

[NICK_ROOBOY83]

I like that team you just posted... nice balance to it

Thanks mate. I would of loved to have Smith in there but his unlikely to be ready by R1. We can only hope he is.

 

[r_boy]

Drew will have to be down back against the dons. Lucas, Lloyd etc.

Anyway, is Wells injury only 1-2 weeks?

 

[Moti]

B: Firrito Gibson Pratt
HB: Urquhart Watt Sinclair
C: Grant Simpson Wells
HF: McMahon Petrie Jones
F: Edwards Thompson Campbell
R: McIntosh Harvey Harris

Int: Hale Swallow Hansen Harding


I sorta expect Drewy to go down back if needed. Wellsy will pay.

Finally someone who is actually thinking!

Grant will play forward, harding back and Mc mahon on the bench would be the only positional changes I would make. Mc Mahon is the one though that might not make it IMO while Petrie will play back as the Dons will start with Hille/Laycock, Lloyd and Lucas forward.

Sinclair will struggle to get a game once Smith returns and one of Urquart / Lower takes a step forward.

 

[NICK_ROOBOY83]

Drew will have to be down back against the dons. Lucas, Lloyd etc.

Anyway, is Wells injury only 1-2 weeks?

From the info thats been distributed by the club, Yes its only a couple of week injury.

 

[Bren]

Interesting that alot of teams left out Rawlings.

At the very least he deserves to be played off the bench.

 

[NICK_ROOBOY83]

Interesting that alot of teams left out Rawlings.

At the very least he deserves to be played off the bench.

Your right. I guess you could replace him with Hansen on the Interchange bench.

 

[ardenroo]

Rawlings is a dead set certainty

 

[Bren]

thats what amazed me with ppl leaving him out, he is still the best tagger in the league, just dont let him kick the ball.

 

[NICK_ROOBOY83]

thats what amazed me with ppl leaving him out, he is still the best tagger in the league, just dont let him kick the ball.

Too many stand out more then Brady, but you know come Round one he will be there.

 

[shinboner magic]

spud gibbo pratt

harding petrie S.thommo

wells harris hansen

jones edwards grant

campbell thommo mcmahon

Hamish boomer simmo

Rawlings swallow hale urquart


If smith is fit to play probably gav will get dumped