Preview Round 9 - Brisbane vs Essendon - Saturday 13th May 7:25 PM @ The Gabba

Who will win?

  • Essendon

    Votes: 3 5.7%
  • Brisbane

    Votes: 31 58.5%
  • Joey D will sit on the fence at some point during the game.

    Votes: 19 35.8%

  • Total voters
    53

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

silk

Premium Platinum
Sep 10, 2006
2,756
2,570
Melbourne
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Chicago Bulls
Next Saturday sees Essendon play Brisbane for the first time this season, in what looms, in borrowed terms, a "danger" match for Brisbane. Brisbane has, on paper, one of the best lists in the AFL, and should expect to win comfortably over a spirited, but overall lacklustre Essendon. Brisbane will look to expose Essendon's defence, with another defender and one of our most important players, Jordan Ridley, a guaranteed out. This will be an interesting test Brad Scott with the boys facing consecutive interstate games.



Well, we're plucky, and I get the feeling we are going to get sick of term honourable losses by the end of the season, and yet I can't help be feel ok with how the season has gone so far. I'm far more interested in the overall direction of the list and the team, and yet that loss still stings as once again we are exposed in the last quarter and failed to hold or build on our earlier lead.

golden retriever dog GIF


PORT ADELAIDE 3.4 5.11 9.16 12.20 (92)
ESSENDON 6.1 9.1 11.3 13.9 (87)

GOALS
Port Adelaide:
Byrne-Jones 2, Dixon 2, Rioli 2, McEntee, Marshall, Powell-Pepper, Boak, Finlayson, Rozee
Essendon: Stringer 2, Langford 2, Weideman 2, Perkins 2, Caldwell, McDonald-Tipungwuti, Hobbs, Merrett, Menzie

BEST
Port Adelaide:
Butters, Rozee, Bergman, Boak, Finlayson
Essendon: Merrett, Stringer, Draper, Parish, McGrath

INJURIES
Port Adelaide:
Jonas (chest soreness), Butters (right knee)
Essendon: Ridley (concussion)

SUBSTITUTES
Port Adelaide:
Francis Evans (replaced Tom Jonas in the third quarter)
Essendon: Jye Menzie (replaced Jordan Ridley in the second quarter)


Brisbane on the other hand we able to hand the Blues another loss on the back of another fine performance by Charlie Cameron.

CARLTON 5.1 6.3 6.5 11.8 (74)
BRISBANE 5.3 7.7 12.9 15.10 (100)

GOALS
Carlton:
Motlop 2, Durdin 2, McKay, C.Curnow, E.Curnow, Docherty, Hollands, Cerra, Kennedy
Brisbane: Cameron 4, Bailey 4, Gunston 2, Daniher 2, McCarthy, Sharp, Hipwood

BEST
Carlton:
Cerra, Hewett, Docherty, Acres, Walsh
Brisbane: Dunkley, Payne, Cameron, Andrews, McCluggage, Berry, Bailey, Daniher

INJURIES
Carlton:
McKay (face)
Brisbane: Coleman (hamstring)

SUBSTITUTES
Carlton:
Matt Kennedy (replaced Lewis Young in the third quarter)
Brisbane: Jarryd Lyons (replaced Keidean Coleman in the fourth quarter)

Crowd: 45,848 at Marvel Stadium



The last time we met.

It was glorious! A 10-point victory on the back of a monstrous second half from Peter Wright (God, I miss him!) and a four-goal outing from Langforward - Seriously... get better defenders; stop moving Langford back, saw us beat the paddle pops on their home turf in one of the upsets of the season. Let's hope history repeats itself.


Melting Ice Cream GIF by jasnim



BRISBANE 2.3 4.8 9.9 13.12 (90)
ESSENDON 2.3 7.6 11.9 15.10 (100)


GOALS
Brisbane:
McCarthy 3, McInerney 2, Robinson 2, Cameron, Daniher, Fort, Hipwood, Michael, Rayner
Essendon: Wright 5, Langford 4, Caldwell, Draper, Guelfi, Heppell, Hobbs, Shiel

BEST
Brisbane:
McCluggage, McCarthy, McInerney, Starcevich
Essendon: Merrett, Wright, Langford, Ridley, Caldwell, Shiel

INJURIES
Brisbane:
Nil
Essendon: D'Ambrosio (corked quad)

SUBSTITUTES
Brisbane:
Rhys Mathieson (unused)
Essendon: Brayden Ham (replaced D'Ambrosio in the fourth quarter)

Crowd: 29,101 at the Gabba


The Team

Possible ins:
Durham (Back from Suspension)
Reid (Benched at 1/4 time - To preserve him for Brisbane, or an injury flare-up - It's a mystery)
Baldwin (We might need some more size down back)
Montgomerie (Strong VFL form and a good potential replacement for Rids. We are due for a Debut)
Bryan (Strong again in the VFL.. but still needs to take more marks.)
Snelling (Too good for VFL.)
D'Ambrosio (Could play forward or back, and fill a good spot)
Wanganeen (Give him a go in the AFL, given Davey and Menzie are struggling a bit?)

Possible Outs:
Ridley (Concussion)
Menzies
Hind
Philips
Davey
Hobbs (Not what I want, but I wouldn't be surprised)



Make or break game for us - I think we'll either win by a little or lose by a lot. Essendon by 10 or Brisbane by 40.
 
Last edited:
In:Baldwin, Montgomerie, Durham.
Out: Ridley, Hind, Phillips.
Sub: Reid*


I heard Reid didn't play all of the VFL match. Not sure if managed or injured.

I would think Brisbane win this one and I think relatively comfortably.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

In: Snelling, Baldwin, Durham
Out: Davey, Ridley, Hind

Kelly - Baldwin - McGrath
Redman - Zerk - Heppell
Durham - Setterfield - Martin
Langford - Weideman - Snelling
Tippa - Phillips - Stringer
Draper - Merrett - Parish
Hobbs - Caldwell - Shiel - Perkins
Montgomerie

feel like we're carrying one midfielder too many
 
Baldwin moved forward in the VFL this week.

Reckon he or Voss comes in and plays forward and releases Langford back. Or potentially Stringer to the midfield and Setterfield back, in rotations. Can also go small in the midfield and release both back, and then there’s always the break glass option of Weideman.

Good thing about Joe is he’ll probably sit on the fence or stand around waving so you don’t really have to stop him leading up at the ball carrier. Just don’t be a step stool and you’re fine. Also got Mick Hurley on staff who is pretty familiar with playing on him.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I'm going with this.

Kelly BZT Montgomery
McGrath McBride Redman
Durham settlefield Merrett
Perkins weideman shiel
Snelling Langford tippa
Draper parish caldwell
Hind Hobbs stringer Bryan
Sub.heppell

In. Montgomery McBride Snelling Bryan Durham

Out. Ridley ( assualted) Phillips (managed) Martin (managed) Davey Menzie .

BZT - joedan
McBride - Rafa Nadal
Montgomery - Gunston
Kelly- McCarthy
McGrath - Charlie
Redman- rayner
 
If Ridleys jaw aint broken then he may be fine to play?

Montgomerie may be a better matchup for Hipwood then say a Baldwin who may have to go to Daniher a bit more

Hipwood isnt really a huge aerial threat. Redman could be a bold move but he tends to go to C.Cameron. I wouldnt be against Mcgrath being challenged here J.Kelly also can do it to some degree
 
We have the most points against out of the top 12 teams. And up against Brisbane without Ridley also. This could get ugly.
 
If Ridleys jaw aint broken then he may be fine to play?

Montgomerie may be a better matchup for Hipwood then say a Baldwin who may have to go to Daniher a bit more

Hipwood isnt really a huge aerial threat. Redman could be a bold move but he tends to go to C.Cameron. I wouldnt be against Mcgrath being challenged here J.Kelly also can do it to some degree
He was concussed so must miss a game (10 days technically).

Montgomerie in for mine. Davey will be a good player but will presumably be out given the 1 week on, 1 week off policy he seems to be subject to (which would have him back for Dreamtime!).

Don't like our chances in this one. If get within 5 goals, it will be a pass mark. Hope it rains.
 
I'm going with this.

Kelly BZT Montgomery
McGrath McBride Redman
Durham settlefield Merrett
Perkins weideman shiel
Snelling Langford tippa
Draper parish caldwell
Hind Hobbs stringer Bryan
Sub.heppell

In. Montgomery McBride Snelling Bryan Durham

Out. Ridley ( assualted) Phillips (managed) Martin (managed) Davey Menzie .

BZT - joedan
McBride - Rafa Nadal
Montgomery - Gunston
Kelly- McCarthy
McGrath - Charlie
Redman- rayner

I love this - Out. Ridley (assaulted)..
- not far from the truth!


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
One of Baldwin or Montgomery playing on Daniher or Hipwood doesn’t really appeal as a great match up.

Do you roll the dice and ask Nick Bryan to play in defence? He’s better equipped than the other two and feel
like he played in defence at VFL level quite a bit in his first year or two.
Bryan ran a 2.89sec 20m at draft camp. Not sure about his endurance and if those guys will blow him up but would be interesting to see him have a go down back with his reach and probably our best bet.
 
Out: Ridley, Hind, Phillips, Menzie
In: Baldwin, Montgomerie, Bryan, Durham

McGrath - Zerk-Thatcher - Kelly
Redman - Baldwin - Heppell
Martin - Parish - Durham
Perkins - Weideman - Caldwell
Bryan - Stringer - McDonald-Tipungwuti
Draper - Merrett - Setterfield
Montgomerie - Shiel - Hobbs - Langford
Davey
 
I am expecting the 4th loss in the row this week, no chance of a repeat of last year's upset win. McKenna and Daniher will rip the bombers apart with a bagful of goals. 6-7 thrashing expected.
 
Not sure who plays on Gunston. Zerk goes to Daniher and Baldwin to Hipwood. Kelly needs to do his usual blanket job on Cameron and McGrath on McCarthy. Might have to throw Montie on Gunston

Other end, Starcevich on Stringer, Andrews on Weideman and Payne on the ruck. Lester maybe on Langford? Not sure about small match ups, but hoping McKenna on Walla
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top