Universal Love Swans Board Media Poll - Who is worst of the worst?

[The King!]

If you created a shitful commentator/journo bracket suspect eddie v dunstall would be the final. After Kingy loses in the round prior

 

[TheWhiteRhino]

If you created a shitful commentator/journo bracket suspect eddie v dunstall would be the final. After Kingy loses in the round prior

No way.

BT vs Jon Ralph would be a lock.

Eddie and Dermie would be knocked out in the prelim.

 

[The King!]

No way.

BT vs Jon Ralph would be a lock.

Eddie and Dermie would be knocked out in the prelim.

Question is am I bored enough to draft up a bracket for voting

 

[Ticky009]

No way.

BT vs Jon Ralph would be a lock.

Eddie and Dermie would be knocked out in the prelim.

Surely Dwayne has to come in there somewhere? Or is he reigning champ awaiting the winning challenger?

 

[The King!]

Surely Dwayne has to come in there somewhere? Or is he reigning champ awaiting the winning challenger?

Dwayne forgot him massive chance

 

[robbieando]

Question is am I bored enough to draft up a bracket for voting

Do it or I will

 

[The King!]

Do it or I will

Give me a day

 

[robbieando]

Give me a day

Fair enough.

Put 16 names forward in a thread and we'll run a multiple option vote to find the ultimate Swan hater in the AFL media.

 

[Lakeside Swan]

Give me a day

Do it like a tennis tournament commencing at the final round.

 

[The King!]

Proposed Bracket for the 16 worst Journos before i start a thread

here are some seeds (suggest some changes if you want)

1 Eddie McGuire (tournament Fav)
2 Jason Dunstall
3 Dwayne Russell
4 Mark Robinson
5 Damien Barrett
6 David King
7 Jon Ralph
8 Dermott Brereton
9 Sam Landsberger
10 Rebecca Wilson
11 Callum Twoney
12 Bruce McAvaney
13 Kevin Bartlett
14 Brian Taylor
15 Luke Darcy
16 Leigh Matthews

 

[robbieando]

Needs Glenn McFarlane, Michael Warner and Jon Anderson from the Herald Sun to be legit. Plus you have Sam Landsberger twice

 

[momentbymoment]

Proposed Bracket for the 16 worst Journos before i start a thread

here are some seeds (suggest some changes if you want)

1 Eddie McGuire (tournament Fav)
2 Jason Dunstall
3 Dwayne Russell
4 Mark Robinson
5 Damien Barrett
6 David King
7 Jon Ralph
8 Dermott Brereton
9 Sam Landsberger
10 Rebecca Wilson
11 Callum Twoney
12 Bruce McAvaney
13 Kevin Bartlett
14 Brian Taylor
15 Luke Darcy
16 Sam Landsberger

Eddies position is too low.

 

[robbieando]

Also I'll put all 16 names up in the poll and allow everyone 8 multiple votes in the first round, then 4 multiple votes when its narrowed down to 8 names and so on

 

[CD__]

Definitely needs Craig Hutchison and Sam Newman. Matthew Lloyd and Wayne Carey also shouldn't be too far away.

 

[daymee]

Proposed Bracket for the 16 worst Journos before i start a thread

here are some seeds (suggest some changes if you want)

1 Eddie McGuire (tournament Fav)
2 Jason Dunstall
3 Dwayne Russell
4 Mark Robinson
5 Damien Barrett
6 David King
7 Jon Ralph
8 Dermott Brereton
9 Sam Landsberger
10 Rebecca Wilson
11 Callum Twoney
12 Bruce McAvaney
13 Kevin Bartlett
14 Brian Taylor
15 Luke Darcy
16 Sam Landsberger

Needs more Michelangelo Rucci

 

[robbieando]

Any names from Fairfax? Jon Pierik and RoCo could come up for consideration.

Sam McClure is another name for the Mitchell rumours

 

[robbieando]

Needs more Michelangelo Rucci

Not really anti Swans though

 

[sataris]

Roy Masters?

 

[GotTheGoodes]

Needs more Michelangelo Rucci

Eeeeaaahhh *shudders*

 

[GotTheGoodes]

Not really anti Swans though

He can be. He certainly was when the Tippett saga happened.

 

[bedford]

Proposed Bracket for the 16 worst Journos before i start a thread

here are some seeds (suggest some changes if you want)

1 Eddie McGuire (tournament Fav)
2 Jason Dunstall
3 Dwayne Russell
4 Mark Robinson
5 Damien Barrett
6 David King
7 Jon Ralph
8 Dermott Brereton
9 Sam Landsberger
10 Rebecca Wilson
11 Callum Twoney
12 Bruce McAvaney
13 Kevin Bartlett
14 Brian Taylor
15 Luke Darcy
16 Sam Landsberger

 

[robbieando]

Roy Masters?

I'd say no because he isn't an AFL writer

 

[bedford]

Sam Edmund, didn't even give Parker a vote against Carlton

 

[sataris]

I'd say no because he isn't an AFL writer

To be fair, he's not even really a writer.

 

[robbieando]

Sam Edmund, didn't even give Parker a vote against Carlton

Is that a one off or a pattern of behaviour though? Will look into it

Still you would have some good names for anti-Swan journos that we have missed