I don't think its unfair to be somewhat critical of Fyfe's kicking. There's no doubt he's a great player who has top shelf marking ability for a player of his height, great contested ball winning and is quick and has good endurance as well but he still has a weakness and that is his kicking and decision making which is probably only average. To be fair to his kicking he does go fairly high risk so when he pulls it off he looks amazing and at other times it makes him look a bit ordinary. He's still certainly a top 20 mid with plenty of room for improvement to come.
Disposal efficiency the stat isn't useless but it can't be judged in isolation, you need to use it in conjunction with what you've seen of the player both in terms of how they use the ball, where they are getting the ball and their role within the team. There's a reason why team disposal efficiency tends to be quite a good indicator to how good a team is going because over that many players it tends to be far more accurate than when judging an individual player.
Disposal efficiency the stat isn't useless but it can't be judged in isolation, you need to use it in conjunction with what you've seen of the player both in terms of how they use the ball, where they are getting the ball and their role within the team. There's a reason why team disposal efficiency tends to be quite a good indicator to how good a team is going because over that many players it tends to be far more accurate than when judging an individual player.
