Was it... you?

[tribey]

On Fox Footy's White Line Fever last night, Tony Shaw and Mark Harvey were reviewing the performance of the clubs so far, including a best and a worst player and a player to keep and a player to trade.

Shaw plumped for Matthew Clarke as our worst player (a tad stiff I would have thought), but this was quickly rebutted by an Adelaide fan off the SMS who stated that our worst player this season has been Ian Perrie.

I was gobsmacked, considering that big Pezza has kicked as many goals as Matthew Pavlich this season (21), has presented well and generally takes the opposition's best defender as a rule.

We know he's not Wayne Carey, but what the hell is this text messaging nuff-nuff thinking? Perrie our worst in season 2005?!

Own up... was it you?

 

[Mad Dog]

not me.......I would have gone young Mick of those who have played......

 

[- PC -]

No No it wasnt me either I was at work


I would have gone about 5 others before Perrie. I actually am happy with his effort this year, I would still get rid of him if a suitable trade came up

 

[macca23]

On Fox Footy's White Line Fever last night, Tony Shaw and Mark Harvey were reviewing the performance of the clubs so far, including a best and a worst player and a player to keep and a player to trade.

Shaw plumped for Matthew Clarke as our worst player (a tad stiff I would have thought), but this was quickly rebutted by an Adelaide fan off the SMS who stated that our worst player this season has been Ian Perrie.

I was gobsmacked, considering that big Pezza has kicked as many goals as Matthew Pavlich this season (21), has presented well and generally takes the opposition's best defender as a rule.

We know he's not Wayne Carey, but what the hell is this text messaging nuff-nuff thinking? Perrie our worst in season 2005?!

Own up... was it you?

I heard that too DT, and had a good chuckle wondering if it was one of the anti-Perrie brigade from this board.

I doubt that we'll ever really know.

I'm with you though - it defies logic to say that Perrie has been our worst. Shaw's nomination of Clarke was equally ridiculous seeing that injury and oppotunity have restricted him to 1 game.

 

[Jars458]

It was probably Chris Connoly trying to reduce Perrie's trade value!

 

[Fergus]

Definitely not me. I'm one of the few in the pro-Perrie and pro-Burton camps.

 

[MaccasNeighbour]

Definitely not me, I just named my new puppy after sarge.

 

[crowie]

Tony Shaw

You can't tell me that people are willing to pay for his opinions.

 

[cro_Magnum]

He may have played one of the worst games this year (against Brisbane I think) when he and Bock were spilling marks everywhere but both have come good since.

Never take the glove off again Ian.

 

[-WWJD-]

On another note, nice to see Shaw named Goody as our best especially since Harvey and Grybas were quick to question where Roo's name was.

 

[st05]

I heard that too, thought it was a bit rough.
'Craig' on the SMS texted it.
I was happy that I struggled to think of our 'worst' player in the ad break before they announced it.
Did you fox viewers catch 'The Gospel' last Friday night?
fair bit of Tredrea bashing........

 

[jmorg1]

*Dr Hibbert giggle* huh huh huh huh huh huh. Well I couldn't possibly solve this mystery. Caaaaaaaaan you?

 

[Alex99]

Well it wasn’t me I wouldn’t waste a phone call on Tony “ god Collingwood are good but sacked me” Shaw and I too was flabbergasted when I herd that.

Ian Perrie has been good this season and Iam very happy with how is value has increased to the Fremantle Dockers and he has contributed to the sides success


Best: Simon Goodwin or Mark Ricciuto
Worst: Mathew Bode or Mathew Clark
Keep: Rhett Biglands
Delist: Michael Doughty

 

[PrideOf]

Own up... was it you?

Nope. It was Warney.

I heard that too, thought it was a bit rough. 'Craig' on the SMS texted it.

Was that Craig as a first name or surname?

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

On Fox Footy's White Line Fever last night, Tony Shaw and Mark Harvey were reviewing the performance of the clubs so far, including a best and a worst player and a player to keep and a player to trade.

Shaw plumped for Matthew Clarke as our worst player (a tad stiff I would have thought), but this was quickly rebutted by an Adelaide fan off the SMS who stated that our worst player this season has been Ian Perrie.

I was gobsmacked, considering that big Pezza has kicked as many goals as Matthew Pavlich this season (21), has presented well and generally takes the opposition's best defender as a rule.

We know he's not Wayne Carey, but what the hell is this text messaging nuff-nuff thinking? Perrie our worst in season 2005?!

Own up... was it you?

I don't have Foxtel, so wasn't me. Wasn't here any way.

I have also been one to rate Perrie when used properly, so much so that my bet with a Port supporter that we would make the finals with Perrie playing in our forward line is looking good.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Well it wasn’t me I wouldn’t waste a phone call on Tony “ god Collingwood are good but sacked me” Shaw and I too was flabbergasted when I herd that.

Ian Perrie has been good this season and Iam very happy with how is value has increased to the Fremantle Dockers and he has contributed to the sides success


Best: Simon Goodwin or Mark Ricciuto
Worst: Mathew Bode or Mathew Clark
Keep: Rhett Biglands
Delist: Michael Doughty

Why delist Dogga when he has been a regular member of the side?

I would have thought there would be plenty of others in the delist category ahead of him.

 

[maccas_no1]

Wasnt me either, Pay TV technology hasnt even reach the land of Tassie yet

TV is that bad here that unless you have a digital set top box, Neighbours is about 3 weeks behind and Amazing Race 7 has only just started

TV is very strange in Tasmania.

 

[Stiffy_18]

Definetly not me but who ever it was should be ashamed of themselves

 

[Crow-mosone]

I did it. from behind the grassy knoll

 

[tribey]

Perrie led back, and to the left...

 

[DaveW]

In order to recieve the magic bullet pass...

 

[- PC -]

In order to recieve the magic bullet pass...

Heard footsteps and dropped it

 

[just maybe]

not me.......I would have gone young Mick of those who have played......

And I hope he smacks you in the face one night.

 

[ignoranus]

Heard footsteps and dropped it

again!

He pounded his fist into the turf in frustration, whilst 40,000 of the crowd sent off SMS messages to Fox Footy declaring Perrie to be the Crows worst player this season.

 

[drakeyv2]

Not me.

I'm no Perrie (or Skipworth) fan & the sooner we replace them with better players the happier I'll be. But I don't have foxtel & even if I did I wouldn't waste a SMS on Tony Shaw.

I'm hard pressed to pick worse players for the year. All have stood up at some stage or another.