Welcome Welcome to Hawthorn: Ethan Phillips. 2024 SSP.

[thehardway]

How did he go on Saturday? I haven't had a chance to watch.

Baptism of fire for Ethan in his first "major league game". He was up against some of the best Key forwards in the competition and combined with the doggies dominance out of the middle I thought it did a reasonable job. Showed some glimpses that he could play at AFL level. I'd pick him for round 1.

 

[VandoHawk]

How did he go on Saturday? I haven't had a chance to watch.

Thought he was reasonable without being outstanding.

Took a few strong marks and had a few good spoils.

Seemed to get to good positions but was disputed by his teammates. Time in the system will fix that.

Some moments of inexperience giving quality talls too much space.

Learning that the 50/50s in VFL that are usually overlooked are almost always paid to the forward at AFL level. I think 3 or 4 free kicks given away for a slight hand over the shoulder or on the arm while spoiling. Then again, that may just be a Bulldogs thing because Lewis doesn't get those often.

 

[Alite]

Thought he was reasonable without being outstanding.

Took a few strong marks and had a few good spoils.

Seemed to get to good positions but was disputed by his teammates. Time in the system will fix that.

Some moments of inexperience giving quality talls too much space.

Learning that the 50/50s in VFL that are usually overlooked are almost always paid to the forward at AFL level. I think 3 or 4 free kicks given away for a slight hand over the shoulder or on the arm while spoiling. Then again, that may just be a Bulldogs thing because Lewis doesn't get those often.

VandoHawk is on the money. I thought the same thing. In AFL you can barely touch the fwd but in VFL you can compete.

Ethan has to stop putting hands on shoulders and go for the mark / fist… which we know he can do.

In all measures Phillips was beaten. Not badly, he halved a few, was good in his disposal, but still beaten. Not surprising given amount of ball coming into our backline.

Some people shrink from a loss, others grow. I’m betting Ethan will learn a lot from that game.

 

[The Jet From Poowong]

Not sure when he is likely to get a chance.

However, I read he isn’t playing this week because of injury. What happened to him over the VFL break or training this week?

 

[Brant]

Not sure when he is likely to get a chance.

However, I read he isn’t playing this week because of injury. What happened to him over the VFL break or training this week?

Training block leading into Finals?

 

[Newmo89]

Not sure when he is likely to get a chance.

However, I read he isn’t playing this week because of injury. What happened to him over the VFL break or training this week?

Has a knee problem he is managing. He’s had his program deloaded and has been running in joggers the past fortnight.

 

[The Jet From Poowong]

Has a knee problem he is managing. He’s had his program deloaded and has been running in joggers the past fortnight.

Another knee problem.

Waverley surface must be worse than Marvel.

How serious is it as I thought I read it was a knock

 

[Brant]

Another knee problem.

Waverley surface must be worse than Marvel.

How serious is it as I thought I read it was a knock

Be thankful it's not a rolled ankle

 

[Newmo89]

Another knee problem.

Waverley surface must be worse than Marvel.

How serious is it as I thought I read it was a knock

Problem occurred in the match agains the Cats VFL team at GMHBA.
In terms of severity, it’s enough that he’ll miss this week and has had his training program interrupted

 

[HedgeFund]

Be thankful it's not a rolled ankle

HFC rolled ankle protocol

 

[TylerDurden]

17 marks today.

 

[SSSSSS]

Was like the Rock of Gibraltar down back.

 

[hawker79]

17 marks..... wow. I hope he plays in the seniors very very soon. I think he should have been given a chance already seeing how much we have needed reinforcement and replacements down back.

 

[Goatie]

He has an incredible ability to read the ball in flight and take intercept marks. I believe the reason he wasn’t drafted and hasn’t played for us is he looks slow and will be found out on bigger AFL grounds with leading forwards.

He moves a bit like Jackson Callow.

We might as well give him a go and see if he can make it at the level.

 

[hawkmang]

Surely we can’t do much worse than give this guy a run in the 1s… 17 marks!!! What more do the coaches want from him? 3 goals?!

 

[onthemoney]

Surely we can’t do much worse than give this guy a run in the 1s… 17 marks!!! What more do the coaches want from him? 3 goals?!

Well if you're offering

 

[Ka Norkers]

he's an interesting player, got lots of tools, but he's very slow. Lightning quick mentally, but physically he'll find the next level up very difficult.

 

[smish]

He moves a bit like Jackson Callow.

That’s not what I want to hear

 

[TBoyleSuperstar]

17 marks is huge, but I wonder who's spot he takes.

Is he a Key position and takes Frost's position?

Does he push out Sicily and Scrimshaw as our interceptors (one is the captain, the other is the arguably top 2 in the crimmins medal right now)

 

[extractasam]

17 marks is huge, but I wonder who's spot he takes.

Is he a Key position and takes Frost's position?

Does he push out Sicily and Scrimshaw as our interceptors (one is the captain, the other is the arguably top 2 in the crimmins medal right now)

Dogs in 2 weeks could be a good game to throw him in the mix considering they sometimes play 4 talls.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

I sniff a debut not too far away.

Ethan Phillips (16 disposals, 10 marks)​

“It was another really solid outing for Ethan. He played on some key players and key forwards. They (Sydney) rotated a few through the front end so he had a variety of match-ups for the day. What we really liked with Ethan’s game this week was his balance of when to mark and when to spoil. I thought he got that decision right for the majority of the time this week which was good.”

 

[Billyc]

Prototype sub in our current setup.

 

[TylerDurden]

Was in rehab again today yeah?

 

[Newmo89]

Was in rehab again today yeah?

He has been having lighter sessions on the track midweek as he comes back from his knee issue. Very promising review of his game on the weekend.

 

[HoldingThe Ball]

If he's fit, then I have no idea why he isn't playing Sunday.

We are missing Chol Serong and Ramsden for various reasons and the only tall added is Dear.

If Weddle is 2nd ruck as suggested, then we are uber small down back against Darcy English Naughton and JUH.


I have no idea why he isn't playing.