NFL What is the Ultimate NFL Dream Team?

[ausbacker]

I feel a new thread in the works GG.

Name the best player at every position on the field. All Pro format seems fair enough.

 

[Exe Gesis]

I feel a new thread in the works GG.

Name the best player at every position on the field. All Pro format seems fair enough.

You can certainly start that thread and while you're at it Geno Atkins best dt

 

[ausbacker]

QB: Tom Brady - New England Patriots
RB: Jamaal Charles - Kansas City Chiefs (ability in the passing game gives him the nod over AP)
WR: Calvin Johnson - Detroit Lions
WR: A.J. Green - Cincinnati Bengals
TE: Jimmy Graham - New Orleans Saints (only because Gronk is injured all the time otherwise the actual TE would be here)
LT: Joe Thomas - Cleveland Browns
LG: Jahri Evans - New Orleans Saints
CE: Alex Mack - Cleveland Browns
RG: Louis Vasquez - Denver Broncos
RT: Sebastian Vollmer - New England Patriots (not a huge believer in swinging the LT here otherwise I would)

DE: Robert Quinn - St. Louis Rams
DT: Geno Atkins - Cincinatti Bengals
NT: Haloti Ngata - Baltimore Ravens
DE: J.J. Watt - Houston Texans
Sam: Von Miller - Denver Broncos
Mike: Luke Kuechly - Carolina Panthers
Will: Lavonte David - Tampa Bay Buccaneers
CB: Darrelle Revis - New England Patriots
CB: Richard Sherman - Seattle Seahawks
SS: Eric Berry - Kansas City Chiefs
FS: Earl Thomas - Seattle Seahawks

K: Stephen Gostkowski - New England Patriots
P: Andy Lee - San Francisco 49ers

 

[bgt2110]

QB: Tom Brady - New England Patriots
RB: Jamaal Charles - Kansas City Chiefs (ability in the passing game gives him the nod over AP)
WR: Calvin Johnson - Detroit Lions
WR: A.J. Green - Cincinnati Bengals
TE: Jimmy Graham - New Orleans Saints (only because Gronk is injured all the time otherwise the actual TE would be here)
LT: Joe Thomas - Cleveland Browns
LG: Jahri Evans - New Orleans Saints
CE: Alex Mack - Cleveland Browns
RG: Evan Mathis - Philadelphia Eagles
RT: Sebastian Vollmer - New England Patriots (not a huge believer in swinging the LT here otherwise I would)

DE: Robert Quinn - St. Louis Rams
DT: Geno Atkins - Cincinatti Bengals
NT: Haloti Ngata - Baltimore Ravens
DE: J.J. Watt - Houston Texans
Sam: Von Miller - Denver Broncos
Mike: Luke Kuechly - Carolina Panthers
Will: Lavonte David - Tampa Bay Buccaneers
CB: Darrelle Revis - New England Patriots
CB: Richard Sherman - Seattle Seahawks
SS: Eric Berry - Kansas City Chiefs
FS: Earl Thomas - Seattle Seahawks

K: Stephen Gostkowski - New England Patriots
P: Andy Lee - San Francisco 49ers

Thought you could only pick 1 player per team ?

 

[Blacky]

Biggest Homer ever

 

[GreyWind]

Bears, Vikings, Colts, Packers no mention from a quick glance. 3 Pats, 2 Bengals, 2 Chiefs, 2 Seahawks.

 

[sblack]

And Mathis is a LG, not a RG

 

[Blacky]

Somehow Brady is that much better than Rodgers he warrants 4 Pats

 

[Blacky]

If teams don't matter then Vasquez is the best RG

 

[ausbacker]

Thought you could only pick 1 player per team ?

Who keeps adding these stupid clauses? You pick the best player in the NFL at every position.

 

[ausbacker]

And Mathis is a LG, not a RG

You're right, that was an oversight on my behalf.

 

[sblack]

Who keeps adding these stupid clauses? You pick the best player in the NFL at every position.

That was the point of the exercise though...

 

[ausbacker]

Somehow Brady is that much better than Rodgers he warrants 4 Pats

Rodgers is overrated. He's had 2, perhaps 3 good seasons in a league now designed for passing. Great player just not the greatest (right now).

Give me Brees and Brady over Rodgers any day.

 

[sblack]

Actually a funner challenge we used to do was select a full team...offense defense PK pn kr....where you can only select one player per team

But make it 32 slots. So a third CB, third WR, hc etc.

See who has the best team

 

[ausbacker]

That was the point of the exercise though...

My idea, my rules.

That other idea is a separate thread.

 

[Dagless]

Somehow Brady is that much better than Rodgers he warrants 4 Pats

ausbacker gon ausback

 

[ausbacker]

Bears, Vikings, Colts, Packers no mention from a quick glance. 3 Pats, 2 Bengals, 2 Chiefs, 2 Seahawks.

None of them are the best in their positions and it's best in the position, not this stupid 1 player from each team crap.

 

[Blacky]

Rodgers is overrated. He's had 2, perhaps 3 good seasons in a league now designed for passing. Great player just not the greatest (right now).

Give me Brees and Brady over Rodgers any day.

When he hasn't been injured he has lit it up, from day 1

 

[ausbacker]

When he hasn't been injured he has lit it up, from day 1

There's no doubting his talent and I acknowledge he can make all the throws but my personal preference is toward Brady and Brees. Whichever way it is spun, Brady, Brees, Manning and Rodgers are significantly better than the other Quarterbacks in the league. There's a reason why their teams are yearly contenders.

 

[Dagless]

If you're going to pick someone other than Rodgers (And I don't think lack of playing time in comparison is an adequate excuse), I'm not sure how, at the moment, you can justify Brady over Brees. And I love Brady more than the general community I'm guessing...