Which player(s) from your club are you ashamed of


Club Legend
Oct 2, 2016
AFL Club
John Nicholls is a dick. Should never have been voted our #1 player ever.
Coming from a Blue, that’s a hell of a statement.
It was Nicholl’s on field play and generalship that got Carlton flags in 70 & 72. Both were quite bizzare, flukey, crazy wins.
But they were wins!
Never heard a Carlton fan talk about him like this before....

(Log in to remove this ad.)


Oct 22, 2017
AFL Club
Liberatore was a dirty and ugly player, you dont want guys like him representing your club, and has never been held to account. completely brushed over his squirrels. Whitten was a cystic old bastard as well. even if he wasnt so hateful, he was a footballer but he's talked about like he invented spray-on skin for burn victims.
Whitten was not a nice family man and should not just be remembered as a good footballer who treated his mates/players better.

Boston tiger

Norm Smith Medallist
May 10, 2010
AFL Club
  • Didn’t live up to expectations after a 3 Brownlow vote game in his first season, plus being overhyped as ‘best 16 year old Michael Voss has ever seen’;
  • Played when WC needed some of their many early draft picks to become A graders;
  • Lost confidence in his kicking and started shanking them (mind you so did the rest of the midfield back then - Ebert, Selwood x2, Waters, Priddis, Masten, Rosa, Houlihan);
  • Odd appearance and gait;
  • Most footy supporters are dumb campaigners...
    = Easy whipping boy
West Coast had a drop kick skills coach ... had all the young blokes kicking tennis balls to change their kicking styles. Suddenly good young footballers were second guessing themselves.
Last edited:


All Australian
Apr 13, 2008
AFL Club
Other Teams
Chelsea, Glasgow Celtic
I agree (particularly re Ablett), having said that, I haven’t seen many Carlton fans (including your posts) listing the man their best and fairest is named after, “Gentleman” John Nicholls. Convicted of embezzlement and larceny in the 60’s and then 7 counts of fraud in the 80’s.

Ah Big Nick, I remembering opening a bank account for him in the 90's, first thing he asked was when could he get a cheque book? I told him him we'd have to see good conduct on the account over a period of a few months.

My manager came speeding after he left saying "you didn't give a cheque book did you?", told the boss I knew exactly who he was and that he'd have to wait 3-6 months :D


Senior List
Aug 13, 2018
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
New York Mets
Terrible player or terrible bloke or both?

How Justin Murphy ever darkened our doors got me. There's Ablett but that's post career. Eagles fans must still feel rankled that someone like a Tom Swift ever pulled on their colours.

This will probably turn in to a shit fest of accusations and rumours but here's hoping.
No not really, at least he called it quits.
Ben Cousins for me , Brilliant footballer, Brownlow Medalist, Club Captain, Pin up boy of the AFL......... burned his career and tarnished the club with a glass bbq.

The 747

Brownlow Medallist
Jan 19, 2008
AFL Club
Why Jacko? He was funny af. Need more characters like him, not that it will ever happen.
Not sure ashamed is the right word but Jacko was an absolute arse clown. Made every game a circus and constantly did things that went against the team goals. He was very talented but so selfish he makes Gary Ablett Senior look like the ultimate team player. There is a reason why he played for four clubs and was booted out of all of them.


Club Legend
Dec 17, 2006
AFL Club
Other Teams
South Fremantle, Sturt
What exactly did Swift do to attract ire?
I've never understood why supporters disliked Tom Swift so much, and it wasn't only at AFL level it was in the WAFL too.

Swift played for the Claremont Tigers in the 2011 and 2012 Grand Finals, with the Tigers defeating the Subiaco Lions and the East Fremantle Sharks respectively. At the post match presentations where Claremont players were presented with their premiership medallions, when Swift's name was called out he was booed and jeered not only by Lions and Sharks supporters and neutral spectators, but some Tiger fans too.

mc snooza

All Australian
Dec 29, 2014
AFL Club
Other Teams
Manangatang Thirds. NewYork Knicks.
As a Richmond fan has to be Jarred Oakley Nickols, he was a top 10 pick & was absolutely useless, had a score in supercoach of -8 one week.
Clinton King/Kent Kingsley weren't the best pick ups either.

On Redmi Note 7 using BigFooty.com mobile app

(Log in to remove this ad.)


Brownlow Medallist
Sep 4, 2010
AFL Club
Other Teams
Manchester United
People forget when it comes to their team that good player doesn't always mean good bloke
One thing I remember growing up at 13/14 is how the Eagles were considered cool despite the obvious drug abuse/shit blokes because they were winning and we're seen as the lady type

Top Bottom