- Jun 16, 2012
- 25,076
- 25,677
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Shaw
List Mgmt. Free agency/trade/draft discussion (READ OP FIRST)
- Thread starter strauchanie59
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
- Jan 17, 2013
- 7,599
- 8,294
- AFL Club
- GWS
Sam Reid will be 23 at start of next season
- Apr 22, 2013
- 4,163
- 5,058
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Neither Reid nor jetta performed. But nor did Cunningham, Parker, mcveigh, jack (whose decision making was catastrophic today) shaw, mal, rampe, mcglynn. All of our smalls were just totally outplayed. Totally outplayed.
Singling out Reid and jetta after this game seems odd. However on the balance of the season...
Reid has not performed much all season and is playing like someone who doesn't have a role.
Jetta has been vital to us all season.
Shaw and mal will go. Rohan who I love struggled with the game because unlike against north the hawks could hit targets, so trailing his man meant he couldn't close the space on the lead.
Singling out Reid and jetta after this game seems odd. However on the balance of the season...
Reid has not performed much all season and is playing like someone who doesn't have a role.
Jetta has been vital to us all season.
Shaw and mal will go. Rohan who I love struggled with the game because unlike against north the hawks could hit targets, so trailing his man meant he couldn't close the space on the lead.
Thanks for that update champ.
I mainly blame the inside midfielders. If they got first hands on the ball it would have made everything a lot easier for everyone else in the team. For most of the match Hawthorn's inside midfielders were not only getting clearances but they were getting easy clearances giving them lots of time and space to get the ball going forward.
Oh please yes. Have a quote somewhere?
Cadsky
❤️ Mila ❤️ Alyssa ❤️
players that should be on the table this year
Jetta - Not hard enough at it. 6 disposals... .WTF???
Reid - KPD or go. cannot play swingman to save his life.
Hannerbury - Gotta get rid of someone to shake the midfield up a bit and Hanners would be a big loss but would also get maximum return.
Players that should retire
Teddy - has been average this year and looks to be going backwards.
Shaw - Sorry mate. the game has gone past you
Free agency
Malceski
two players to think about
K.Jack - has had an extremely bad year. isnt a small forward. isnt an inside mid and isnt a fast paced outside mid.
McVeigh - similar to Jack. cant play mid anymore. needs to play half back next year.
extremely disappointing. these guys are supposed to be our two captains and stand up when its required. neither of them did.
Jetta - Not hard enough at it. 6 disposals... .WTF???
Reid - KPD or go. cannot play swingman to save his life.
Hannerbury - Gotta get rid of someone to shake the midfield up a bit and Hanners would be a big loss but would also get maximum return.
Players that should retire
Teddy - has been average this year and looks to be going backwards.
Shaw - Sorry mate. the game has gone past you
Free agency
Malceski
two players to think about
K.Jack - has had an extremely bad year. isnt a small forward. isnt an inside mid and isnt a fast paced outside mid.
McVeigh - similar to Jack. cant play mid anymore. needs to play half back next year.
extremely disappointing. these guys are supposed to be our two captains and stand up when its required. neither of them did.
swansfan51
Brownlow Medallist
- Jun 3, 2007
- 12,602
- 21,357
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- The Exers
Article about to go up on the Swans website about Goodes. Still not sure whether to go on next year
Unrelated - there's already a crap article up with McVeigh saying the same rubbish he spewed after the GWS loss (won't happen again, we're embarrassed, need to be harder etc etc etc)
Unrelated - there's already a crap article up with McVeigh saying the same rubbish he spewed after the GWS loss (won't happen again, we're embarrassed, need to be harder etc etc etc)
Yeah that is bullshit. This was not round 1 when we could be caught a bit unawares. This was the grand final and at no point did the team show any pride in their own performance or the team as a whole. McVeigh was so soft today so clearly he cannot practice what he preaches.
- Jun 25, 2013
- 2,113
- 3,225
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Hey guys sorry about the loss today hope you can recover well and hit back next year.
There are a few rumours going around that St Kilda are very interested in Hannerbury (this is before the Grand final match) and was wondering what you think would be a fair deal?
There are a few rumours going around that St Kilda are very interested in Hannerbury (this is before the Grand final match) and was wondering what you think would be a fair deal?
MarkP
That guy
Top 10 pick.
- Jun 25, 2013
- 2,113
- 3,225
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
We would be happy to give pick 1 up but would probably need a sweetener chucked in.
Cadsky
❤️ Mila ❤️ Alyssa ❤️
Must keep Jones. 1 for hanners and mambrey.
- Jun 25, 2013
- 2,113
- 3,225
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Hannebery and Jones would be a win win for both sides
Also talk of a three way trade between GWS us and you guys.
Going to be an interesting trade period!
- Aug 9, 2012
- 10,680
- 8,233
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Come on mate you should help the spooners.
Mitchell + Hannebery for pick 1 we'll even chuck in the star Trent Dennis-Lane.
But being serious, surely you blokes wouldn't trade Hannebery?
Come on mate you should help the spooners.
Mitchell + Hannebery for pick 1 we'll even chuck in the star Trent Dennis-Lane.
But being serious, surely you blokes wouldn't trade Hannebery?
If he wanted to go back to Melbourne which he has indicated in the past we would definitely consider it. Also you have to remember that the Swans have some room to maneuver here as we have Heeney, Mills and Dunkley all being drafted in the next 14 months. Sure we have a few older midfielders like McVeigh and to a certain extent Jack and McGlynn but generally speaking our midfield is not that old and with the 3 new guys coming in we will need to find space in the midfield.
If we got Heeney, Mills, Dunkley and Petracca in the next 14 months it would/could setup our midfield for the next decade.
Membling
Brownlow Medallist
Honestly Pick Maybe our second chucked in.
Been looking at previous drafts, including Hanners (he is the 1st-4th best in 08 draft IMO) and only about 6 number 1 draft picks can claim to be in this category (Murphy, Cooney, Riewoldt, Goddard, Hodge, Goddard).
Note: Firm believer in 'pickflation' and that a proven quality player that has been AA and rising star has more value to us currently
- Moderator
- #2,472
Too soon, too raw. Re opening on Monday.
We don't call him a squib because he's played 1 bad game. Since the 2012 GF he's played 2 seasons worth of bad games, with a smattering of good games here and there. He talked about leaving to go back to WA - I think he should do this, on his own recognizance.
Sydswans0512
Norm Smith Medallist
- Jun 25, 2013
- 6,260
- 1,805
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Banned
- #2,474
Stats say Pyke was good but we cant have two Ruckman that dont have footy smarts. Tippet needs to be a stay at home full forward because he is a horrible Ruckman.
Sydswans0512
Norm Smith Medallist
- Jun 25, 2013
- 6,260
- 1,805
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Banned
- #2,475
Jones Richards Smith
Mcveigh Grundy Rampe
Hannebery Kennedy Lloyd
Parker Franklin Membrey
Mcglynn Tippett (need a good goalkicker to take the focus off Franklin/ Tippett )
Ryder Mitchell Jack
Cunningham Brandon Jack Towers Heeney/Hewett
Emergency Pyke Laidler Reid Rohan
Trade For Ryder
Mal to take the coin somewhere else
Goodes, Shaw,Okeefe and LRT retire
Mcveigh Grundy Rampe
Hannebery Kennedy Lloyd
Parker Franklin Membrey
Mcglynn Tippett (need a good goalkicker to take the focus off Franklin/ Tippett )
Ryder Mitchell Jack
Cunningham Brandon Jack Towers Heeney/Hewett
Emergency Pyke Laidler Reid Rohan
Trade For Ryder
Mal to take the coin somewhere else
Goodes, Shaw,Okeefe and LRT retire
- Status
Similar threads
