List Mgmt. General Trade/Draft/Free Agency Discussion/Speculation

[Gongswan]

Not sure actually...


In all seriousness I can't see us signing him... the cap issues and outrage would possibly be too much this time round.

Would we trade Reg, which would at some point leave AJ and Reid as our KPD's?

 

[Membling]

Would we trade Reg, which would at some point leave AJ and Reid as our KPD's?

After this year that would be a red flag to the footy gods to destroy us with more injuries next year

 

[Gongswan]

After this year that would be a red flag to the footy gods to destroy us with more injuries next year

True enough.

 

[Tedeski]

If we get Shaw then I am expecting to lose Sam Reid or Smith!

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

Yeah no need for Shaw. Our back line is set for a few years with the possible addition of Reid down there.

 

[Sydswans0512]

Yeah no need for Shaw. Our back line is set for a few years with the possible addition of Reid down there.

Agree

 

[Punts]

Trade radio saying the Buddy deal will drag out and it is holding up all other trades

 

[Membling]

Trade radio saying the Buddy deal will drag out and it is holding up all other trades

unsurprising really

 

[Gongswan]

The longer it takes the AFL to find something wrong, hte less likely there is something wrong

 

[Punts]

Tigers gave up pick 28 for Hampson , so we should go for pick 27 for White

 

[bedford]

I would have thought smith would be one of the last guys to be considered to be traded.

U wouldn't be too upset if mglynn got traded. Lamb would step straight into his role .

And that's what should happen

 

[Superstar swan]

I think everyone has accepted buddy will be at sydney. No point the afl dragging this out. No doubt all 17 other clubs will be getting frustrated by the whole situation / stalemate

 

[RW]

And that's what should happen

If you mean Lamb filling McGlynn's role then yes I could see that but would be very upset if we traded one of the leaders of the club in Smith, fairly sure there's nothing to it though.

 

[Membling]

Hypothetical:

IF- This is a huge huge huge if- the rumours are true in regards to getting a top 5 pick a fairish deal may look like:

GWS: In-Mumford, swans first
Out- Mid first round compo (9, 10)
Melb: In- Parker, mid first round compo (9, 10)
Out- Pick 2
Swans: In- Pick 2
Out- Mumford, Parker, pick 15

Probably a realistic trade considering situation with Mumford and GWS

 

[Superstar swan]

Hypothetical:

IF- This is a huge huge huge if- the rumours are true in regards to getting a top 5 pick a fairish deal may look like:

GWS: In-Mumford, swans first
Out- Mid first round compo (9, 10)
Melb: In- Parker, mid first round compo (9, 10)
Out- Pick 2
Swans: In- Pick 2
Out- Mumford, Parker, pick 15

Probably a realistic trade considering situation with Mumford and GWS

Seems like a fair deal, but I wouldn't be trading parker for pick 2

 

[Membling]

Seems like a fair deal, but I wouldn't be trading parker for pick 2

Neither to be honest but if we were to get pick in the top five more than likely a required part of the trade. Seen some corkers though which include Hannebery, Jack and our first rounder

 

[Bonz]

If you mean Lamb filling McGlynn's role then yes I could see that but would be very upset if we traded one of the leaders of the club in Smith, fairly sure there's nothing to it though.

Isn't Smith out of contract?

 

[bedford]

Seems like a fair deal, but I wouldn't be trading parker for pick 2

Parker aint going anywhere ffs, this is bullshit

 

[Woodie99]

Isn't Smith out of contract?

Lamb is the only required player out of contract (not counting Mummy & White) & he wants to stay.

 

[Membling]

Parker aint going anywhere ffs, this is bullshit

We know, it is a hypothetical if we were after pick two. High draft picks are good but vastly overrated as clubs such as Geelong and our own have proven time and again

 

[bedford]

Well why even mention him

 

[Membling]

Well why even mention him

Mostly procrastination.

Asides nothing in trades will be done until yay or nay on Franklin situation. Need to kill time somehow

 

[Jack2Jack]

Mumford can go to GWS for free in the pre-season draft, everyone needs to accept we're getting sfa for him. GWS aren't going to give us a good pick or allow us to upgrade a 1st round pick out of the goodness in their hearts, we can either accept unders or lose him for nothing.

We have no bargaining hand what so ever in that deal, the only reason GWS might deal at all is to make it official sooner rather than wait for the Pre-season draft.

 

[Membling]

Mumford can go to GWS for free in the pre-season draft, everyone needs to accept we're getting sfa for him. GWS aren't going to give us a good pick or allow us to upgrade a 1st round pick out of the goodness in their hearts, we can either accept unders or lose him for nothing.

We have no bargaining hand what so ever in that deal, the only reason GWS might deal at all is to make it official sooner rather than wait for the Pre-season draft.

Of course not but that would be the only solution in which we may reach for a pick in the top 5.

Honestly prefer to trade into the pick 20-40's. Strike rate is phenomenal in that range

 

[TradeDraft]

Trade radio saying the Buddy deal will drag out and it is holding up all other trades

Bloody AFL Commision