Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
What difference does it make if Langdon got up. He left the ground, it was late, he chose to bump instead of tackle and it was to the head. Should be minimum 2 weeks. The MRP have lost the plot
The MRP is incompetent. Hardly a surprise they stuffed this one up.Clearly.
Very lucky but then again Buddy has at least a couple of these every year so I can't whinge.
Why? Some players break easier than others. It's absolute lunacy to assess based on injury to the victim. It's the action that counts most. Someone could do the exact same thing and if the victim gets concussion the player will be suspended 2 games. The way the MRP works does not discourage actions and behaviours. It's just farcical.It makes a massive difference in the grading of the charge.
but nice melt.
Why? Some players break easier than others. It's absolute lunacy to assess based on injury to the victim. It's the action that counts most. Someone could do the exact same thing and if the victim gets concussion the player will be suspended 2 games. The way the MRP works does not discourage actions and behaviours. It's just farcical.
Redpath was silly. I expected 1 with 2 weeks because of his record. It sucks we're playin port this week because it dilutes my argument :-(Do you know what is farcical? That Redpath didn't get 3
I'm not sure what people are arguing was graded wrong.
They never grade them intentional if they are in the play like this, so careless is nailed on.
I guess there is an argument to be made for medium impact, but impact grading is trial by medical report and it always has been, so Langdon getting straight up with no ill effects made it pretty hard to grade medium there.
Lucky Wines wasn't playing against Carlton. Their medical team would of lied again and got him 2 weeks
So what part of the grading would you change?Take off your bias glasses
what ever they found for the mumford one...So what part of the grading would you change?
Hodge got weeks for bumping Wingard a couple years ago even though Chad was fine.
Ollie lucky they didn't add the potential to cause injury...
Yeah I guess Mummy's hit was a whole lot worse than Wines, Eh?
Rubbish.
So much for this wanting to protect the head BS!!!