List Mgmt. 2019 Trade Thread

[#gosaintas]

Yeah 3 dim sims and a chiko roll.

He was never being traded

Jack Steven was getting excited until u typed the second line.

 

[Keg on legs]

I'm starting to think that saints should target the suns in a trade for a top 2 pick. I'd look at saints 2019 + 2020 1st round picks for pick 1 or 2 + Fiorini. In a more realistic scenario might be able to get Brodie instead of Fiorini.

I'd have a good look at that for sure. I'm keen to be bold and chase elite talent like Rowell or Anderson

Then work out what's better, Brodie / Fiorini vs their future 2nd.

 

[CaptainRisky]

But I thought we were trading him

Only ---------- thought about trading him thank god they had no say

 

[Coconut_twirl]

Goldstein will be a back up run. If Marshall gets injured, the cupboard is very bare from choosing a replacement. It's for insurance and I highly doubt both would play in the same team. Goldstein might not move because of this factor and he might just stay at North.

 

[Keg on legs]

I actually imagined you more like this...

View attachment 690019

This is how I imagine Pluggs to be...

 

[The_Snake26]

Can put the RoMa traded story to bed:

View attachment 690354

There was no story. Just a bunch of posters who jumped to conclusions cause a journo threw up we were having a look at Goldy!

Love Roma. He’s trending upwards and that is ‘significantly pleasing’

 

[hangdog]

I'd have a good look at that for sure. I'm keen to be bold and chase elite talent like Rowell or Anderson

Then work out what's better, Brodie / Fiorini vs their future 2nd.

As much as I rate Brodie, isn't he an inside mid?

 

[RWB4life]

I'd have a good look at that for sure. I'm keen to be bold and chase elite talent like Rowell or Anderson

Then work out what's better, Brodie / Fiorini vs their future 2nd.

They wont let fiorini go.

I'd be happy with Brodie but we may need some picks.

 

[cooperrules]

Would you trade ross and newnes for caldwell and bonar...

 

[Mikka84]

Would you trade ross and newnes for caldwell and bonar...

I'd trade both just for Caldwell in a heartbeat.

But Newnes is free to play where he wants.. Ross + our first for Caldwell and their first.

 

[triggering bro]

I'd trade both just for Caldwell in a heartbeat.

But Newnes is free to play where he wants.. Ross + our first for Caldwell and their first.

Surely Ross has more value than Caldwell?

 

[bergholt]

I'm starting to think that saints should target the suns in a trade for a top 2 pick. I'd look at saints 2019 + 2020 1st round picks for pick 1 or 2 + Fiorini. In a more realistic scenario might be able to get Brodie instead of Fiorini.

Why would they do that though? Trade a top pick where they know who they’ll get for a couple of worse picks which could be anyone - and throw in a decent player? Unless they need draft points for some reason I can’t see that being a thing.

 

[MOLTEN GANGLANDS]

I'd trade both just for Caldwell in a heartbeat.

But Newnes is free to play where he wants.. Ross + our first for Caldwell and their first.

what about his soft tissue injuries though? He looks seriously good I agree, but gotta get him on the park

 

[MOLTEN GANGLANDS]

Surely Ross has more value than Caldwell?

lucky for us if so

 

[Mikka84]

Surely Ross has more value than Caldwell?

I would gladly let him go for Caldwell.

 

[Mikka84]

what about his soft tissue injuries though? He looks seriously good I agree, but gotta get him on the park

That's the risk vs due diligence we do on him I guess..

If there was a chance to get him as part of a deal ( and it's strongly rumored he wants to come home ) then i wouldn't hesitate. A couple of guys from GWS coaching ranks rate him so highly it makes me giddy.

 

[Keg on legs]

As much as I rate Brodie, isn't he an inside mid?

Tbh i don't know that I've ever seen him play. I'm more keen on the pick 2 elememt

 

[plugger66]

This is how I imagine Pluggs to be...

View attachment 690447

Is this still going. Doug Hogan kindly posted my actual picture after winning the Ormond golf day if you really want to see me. I tell you one thing. It aint worth it.

 

[plugger66]

what about his soft tissue injuries though? He looks seriously good I agree, but gotta get him on the park

We manage soft tissue injuries well in young guys.

 

[MOLTEN GANGLANDS]

That's the risk vs due diligence we do on him I guess..

If there was a chance to get him as part of a deal ( and it's strongly rumored he wants to come home ) then i wouldn't hesitate. A couple of guys from GWS coaching ranks rate him so highly it makes me giddy.

yeah, he moves very well, it's just frustrating knowing that in reality it would be between hawthorn, collingwood, richmond and essendon. Unless he's after a paycheck but the good ones never are, they want the big stage and success

 

[SaintsSeptember]

As much as I rate Brodie, isn't he an inside mid?

We need better insiders.
We need better outsiders.

On insiders.
Steele doesn't seem to be able to play his own game.
Dunstan is very limited.
Ross is not a very inside insider.

Do we have any others?

 

[Mikka84]

yeah, he moves very well, it's just frustrating knowing that in reality it would be between hawthorn, collingwood, richmond and essendon. Unless he's after a paycheck but the good ones never are, they want the big stage and success

I think the younger the better chance we are to be honest.. the player agent would be saying take the money now, establish yourself in the seniors and then let the future take care of itself. Older players need the success and big stage for sponsor rights, tv coverage ect ect.

 

[bird_man]

We need better insiders.
We need better outsiders.

On insiders.
Steele doesn't seem to be able to play his own game.
Dunstan is very limited.
Ross is not a very inside insider.

Do we have any others?

Long term we have Clark and Bytel coming through.

 

[Mowman]

We need better insiders.
We need better outsiders.

On insiders.
Steele doesn't seem to be able to play his own game.
Dunstan is very limited.
Ross is not a very inside insider.

Do we have any others?

Yep
We need better everything

 

[Keg on legs]

Is this still going. Doug Hogan kindly posted my actual picture after winning the Ormond golf day if you really want to see me. I tell you one thing. It aint worth it.

Like anything mate, the illusion is always better than the reality. I'm happy to continue to live the illusion thanks very much