Live Event Toby Greene fronts the tribunal - Suspension appeal

[Ant_]

“All I’m trying to achieve is to lock the ball in,” Greene said on the stand

As believeable as his defence of cutting up Dahlhaus mouth that he "was protecting himself in a marking contest"..... Shame it was a handball receive

 

[slashin_velvet]

#FreeToby

#EnterMaynard

Let the grub off... Unleash the Weapon

Give the job to #philinn

 

[Smoky]

In that case wouldn't they have to ensure none on the tribunal are even Collingwood fans? If that could be established.

the cameramans kid is a Pies supporter too... the footage is tainted.

#weapon

 

[SloppyJoe]

Everyone keeps saying that the footage conclusively shows that Greene's hand/fingers made contact with Neale's "eye region".

I can't agree with that because the footage is front-on. You need a side-on view to conclusively show contact.

When you add to this that Neale's evidence is that he only felt contact to his nose, I can see the appeal being upheld.

 

[Smoky]

Give the job to #philinn

is that funny?

or clever?

i like pineapple on pizza (thats relevant to this topic too!)

Tool

 

[Smoky]

Everyone keeps saying that the footage conclusively shows that Greene's hand/fingers made contact with Neale's "eye region".

I can't agree with that because the footage is front-on. You need a side-on view to conclusively show contact.

When you add to this that Neale's evidence is that he only felt contact to his nose, I can see the appeal being upheld.

Player always dob each other in at the Tribunal!

 

[Bay Giant]

Dragging on a touch.

 

[Smoky]

#Maynard

 

[Blueboys11]

Regions of the human body:

List of human anatomical regions - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

"The eyes are referred to as the orbital or ocular region."

There are seven bones that form the orbit:

Orbit (anatomy) - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

View attachment 748819

You better tell Wiki and the medical profession that they are rubbish!

So through that you are confirming the nose isn’t part of the eye region. It has its own region called the nasal region.

Cheers

 

[Bay Giant]

is that funny?

or clever?

i like pineapple on pizza (thats relevant to this topic too!)

Tool

Now I want smoky bacon pizza with pineapple.

 

[Bay Giant]

So through that you are confirming the nose isn’t part of the eye region. It has its own region called the nasal region.

Cheers

Why do your eyes water after a really big line?

 

[SloppyJoe]

Player always dob each other in at the Tribunal!

Well, then the Tribunal/Appeals Board would need to be satisfied that Neale's evidence is not credible.

And it sounds like the AFL's silk didn't do a good enough job in cross examination on that one.

 

[Elmer_Judd]

 

[Snarls Barkley]

Thought the GWS lawyer was just going to filibuster through until Saturday 5pm

 

[BlueBlood1999]

After nearly two hours, the Tribunal will now deliberate.

 

[Yidaki]

Well, then the Tribunal/Appeals Board would need to be satisfied that Neale's evidence is not credible.

And it sounds like the AFL's silk didn't do a good enough job in cross examination on that one.

They don't need to. Player evidence is always sketchy at best. This is well known. The real evidence is the video footage.

 

[Underarm]

Greene's lawyer just repeated what he said on Tuesday. This ban will stick.

 

[beerbandit]

Does anyone actually think he is not guilty?? Or is it the hate Collingwood factor that they want him to get off??

 

[Strange Cat]

I wonder if the giants will sook some more and get the injunction they have threaten if the appeal fails

 

[Elmer_Judd]

Greene's lawyer just repeated what he said on Tuesday. This ban will stick.

No Collingwood Mafia on the Appeals board though so hopefully not.

 

[Elmer_Judd]

Does anyone actually think he is not guilty?? Or is it the hate Collingwood factor that they want him to get off??

I think he is guilt of being reckless, but not guilty enough of missing the Preliminary Final (if that makes sense)

I certainly don't believe he eye gouged Neale.

 

[SSwans2011]

Does anyone actually think he is not guilty?? Or is it the hate Collingwood factor that they want him to get off??

Huh? Most the initial response was that he was rightfully gone. I'm personally unsure.

 

[Coach_Required]

Cant wait for the melts if Greene has the ban reversed lol

 

[FIGJAM]

I think he is guilt of being reckless, but not guilty enough of missing the Preliminary Final (if that makes sense)

I certainly don't believe he eye gouged Neale.

Should have used Judd's Steven Seagal defence.

 

[beerbandit]

I think he is guilt of being reckless, but not guilty enough of missing the Preliminary Final (if that makes sense)

I certainly don't believe he eye gouged Neale.

I think he rightfully should miss the preliminary final.... shouldn’t of been playing it anyway from the Bontempelli incident .. should of got a couple for that, he deserves the week for he’s actions and for being brain dead.