List Mgmt. 2019 Draft and Trade Hypotheticals Thread - Part II

[Membling]

Good to see everyones crystal ball is working well and receiving fantastic reception.

Next year will be a down year, blind freddy could see that. Blood youth, 2021 and 2022 hit up rfa/trade table.

 

[SSwans2011]

Oddly played in two GFs in that period....
while the teams that "won" trade week ...have barely won a final

Every team to win a GF has brought in players over that period. Most have brought in guns.

 

[lollol]

Lose jack,grundy,hanners,rohan,smith,macca, jones

In: lewis taylor

Great f@$$@ work sydney

A lot of players out contract next year....
A lot of RFA.....

We have a lot of cash.

Not worried, JD was going to make no difference to our flag hopes in the next 2 years.

 

[The King!]

sorry but now id kind of like to see daniher struggle to get on the park in a way

 

[Kapanis]

If you see a punter with a swans scarf on at a thai restaurant in Lygon st, come up and say gday Kapanis. Great to have paps at the club another year.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Realistically we are bottom 5 next year.

Might get a live pick before our academy kid not an awful thing anyway.

 

[Wolfgang West]

Monumental mistake to not accept 9 for papley...will get less next year

Papley should be held to his contract. **** him. This is a cut throat business and the only way he was going anywhere was if he could be used to get something big in. You have to give to get in this game. He plays in Sydney next year end of story. Oh ! btw **** Carlton and his Mates there.

 

[WillHayward]

Monumental mistake to not accept 9 for papley...will get less next year

Tend to agree. They wanted 25 back but sheesh going to the draft with 5 and 9 would have been bloody mouth watering.

 

[Superstar swan]

Our list is stagnant again

Disagree...its moving backwards

 

[DST]

The Zac Jones trade with the future picks included works out as pick 22. Actually a fair trade

Yep and ammo for the Academy guys next year.

We moved the dial our way on that deal in the end.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[MarkP]

Meh - Jones for Taylor is ok for me. Jones was quick so is Taylor.

Taylor might have a better brain.

Disappointed but not surprised. Just hope Joe screws them next year and Dodo is looking like the tool he is. Even if we miss out.

This cub has bigger issues than this trade period anyway. See what happens.

 

[The King!]

A lot of players out contract next year....
A lot of RFA.....

We have a lot of cash.

Not worried, JD was going to make no difference to our flag hopes in the next 2 years.

every year people say we have cash to spend, cant seem to land anyone unfortunately

 

[Cadsky]

So does Papley get dropped from the leadership group now?

 

[caesar88]

who knows

club will put a positive spin on it of course

stkilda went out really positive and traded

will be interesting to compare the approaches

Difference is that Saints had **** all talent to begin with, so they needed to go hard.

We, IMO, already have that talent. Just gotta wait for it to grow then plug holes when we're in contention. (I know you disagree about us having that talent.)

 

[TheMase]

Disgruntled Papley

He was on his way already moved out of Sydney apparently

For a contracted player, that’s a bit ridiculous by him to be honest.

 

[The King!]

alright caesar88 who will get at 5
Get some excitement goinf

 

[SSwans2011]

How is 9+25 a bad offer? A top 10 pick and an early second for a bloke that hasn’t played much lately....that’s more than fair.

Happy with Taylor it’s an astute acquisition.

It's **** all for a player of Daniher's calibre.

 

[The King!]

Our list is stagnant again

if it doesnt work over the next year or 2

then tom can **** off and take kinnear with him

 

[RW]

time will tell, i just think we have in the past traded well to win 2 flags

seems reluctant to do it anymore

It's harder to do now IMO after what we did in 2009, the other clubs won't give us a free kick like that again.

Disappointing that we couldn't improve our list though, 2020 looks like another tough year.

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

and will it lead to trade requests or failure to attract

im sick of the points for academy stuff a bit to be honest

Oh yer forgot about that next season our whole draft will be gone on academy selections.

 

[RobbieK]

About 6 Teams get ahead while we don’t is ******* frustrating af

It is about now that I would like to remind you of what happened at Port Adelaide in 2017, everyone labelled them the trade winners when they brought in Rockliff, Motlop and Watts.

Who won the trade period in 2018? Lot's were saying North Melbourne after bringing in Polec, Tyson, Pittard and Hall.

Winning the trade period... doesn't always mean winning games.

 

[Superstar swan]

Need a review of footy department...from harley to horse and co

 

[Dubsforsam1]

Monumental mistake to not accept 9 for papley...will get less next year

Did you not listen to what Carlton said - pick 9 was only part of the deal

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

 

[6yearsold]

Geelong and Hawthorn got golden crops, West Coast and Richmond traded for established players as well to form their premiership-winning core
Carlton, Melbourne, St Kilda, Brisbane, Gold Coast, even Richmond prior to 17 had many busted drafts that had led them nowhere

Not saying that premiership teams can't be built through accumulating high picks in the draft but it requires that the kids actually develop into stars and the club doesn't face retention problems. It's a lottery and not really any more a reliable method of building a successful list than trading for established talent imo.

Bit of both was my point

 

[Opts]

interesting year for joe daniher ahead

essendons big contract extension will come

And if he has any balls he'll tell dildo to GAGF for knocking back a very reasonable trade. The fact is that offering two first round picks, one being a top 10, is extremely reasonable for a player that; has one year on his contract, kicks 1.8 goals a game and has a very questionable body.