Draft Review 2016 - Revisiting the 2016 AFL Draft

KissKiss · Aug 1, 2022

Wild Bill said:
Until Bolton finds some consistancy he won't pass McCluggage.

Bolton has polled coaches votes in 2 of his last 12 games V the Suns and Hawks. McCluggage is 11th in the AFL for votes.

Bolton (and maybe McCluggage) will probably pick up votes of this game.

Marcel Proust · Aug 2, 2022

Wild Bill said:
Until Bolton finds some consistancy he won't pass McCluggage.

Bolton has polled coaches votes in 2 of his last 12 games V the Suns and Hawks. McCluggage is 11th in the AFL for votes.

My brother in Christ. If bolton "finds some consistancy" he will be the best player in the game.

Elmer_Judd · Aug 2, 2022

Marcel Proust said:
My brother in Christ. If bolton "finds some consistancy" he will be the best player in the game.

That's never likely going to happen, so it's a moot point.

Marcel Proust · Aug 2, 2022

blaisee said:
Champion Data rates Bolton as the most impactful player in the AFL with 45 per cent of his disposals part of a scoring chain, streets ahead of Marcus Bontempelli.

Champion Data rates Bolton as the most impactful player in the AFL with 45 per cent of his disposals part of a scoring chain.
He is the No. 1 ranked mid-forward for goals and score involvements.

(Thehun website)

adammania9 · Aug 2, 2022

There's a lot of depth in this draft

Team 1:
B: Tom Stewart (Pick 40), Brennan Cox (Pick 41), Luke Ryan (Pick 66)
HB: Jordan Ridley (Pick 22), Jack Henry (Rookie Pick 16), Andrew McGrath (Pick 1)
C: Hugh McCluggage (Pick 3), Jy Simpkin (Pick 12), Josh Daicos (Pick 57)
HF: Shai Bolton (Pick 29), Mitch Lewis (Pick 76), Tyson Stengle (RD Pick 6)
F: Tim English (Pick 19), Nick Larkey (Pick 73), Cameron Zurhaar (Rookie Pick 11)
R: Sean Darcy (Pick 38), Tim Taranto (Pick 2), Will Brodie (Pick 9)
I: Rowan Marshall (Rookie Pick 10), Todd Marshall (Pick 16), Brandan Parfitt (Pick 26), Oliver Florent (Pick 11)

Team 2:
B: Robbie Fox (RD Pick 34), Griffin Logue (Pick 8), Jack Scrimshaw (Pick 7)
HB: Harry Perryman (Pick 14), Josh Battle (Pick 39), Jack Bowes (Pick 10)
C: Sam Petrevski-Seton (Pick 6), Willem Drew (Pick 33), Jack Graham (Pick 53)
HF: Sam Powell-Pepper (Pick 18), Peter Ladhams (RD Pick 9), Ben Ainsworth (Pick 4)
F: Willie Rioli (Pick 52), Darcy Cameron (Pick 48), Will Hayward (Pick 21)
R: Oscar McInerney (RD Pick 37), Jarrod Berry (Pick 17), Patrick Lipinski (Pick 28)
I: Zac Fisher (Pick 27), Harry Morrison (Pick 74), Lewis Young (Pick 49), Alex Witherden (Pick 23)

Marcel Proust · Aug 2, 2022

Elmer_Judd said:
That's never likely going to happen, so it's a moot point.

The afl media seem to think otherwise.

Saying he is there abouts now.

Jeremias · Aug 2, 2022

Marcel Proust said:
The afl media seem to think otherwise.

Saying he is there abouts now.

Got an example of that?

RedmanWasHere · Aug 2, 2022

adammania9 said:
There's a lot of depth in this draft

Team 1:
B: Tom Stewart (Pick 40), Brennan Cox (Pick 41), Luke Ryan (Pick 66)
HB: Jordan Ridley (Pick 22), Jack Henry (Rookie Pick 16), Andrew McGrath (Pick 1)
C: Hugh McCluggage (Pick 3), Jy Simpkin (Pick 12), Josh Daicos (Pick 57)
HF: Shai Bolton (Pick 29), Mitch Lewis (Pick 76), Tyson Stengle (RD Pick 6)
F: Tim English (Pick 19), Nick Larkey (Pick 73), Cameron Zurhaar (Rookie Pick 11)
R: Sean Darcy (Pick 38), Tim Taranto (Pick 2), Will Brodie (Pick 9)
I: Rowan Marshall (Rookie Pick 10), Todd Marshall (Pick 16), Brandan Parfitt (Pick 26), Oliver Florent (Pick 11)

Team 2:
B: Robbie Fox (RD Pick 34), Griffin Logue (Pick 8), Jack Scrimshaw (Pick 7)
HB: Harry Perryman (Pick 14), Josh Battle (Pick 39), Jack Bowes (Pick 10)
C: Sam Petrevski-Seton (Pick 6), Willem Drew (Pick 33), Jack Graham (Pick 53)
HF: Sam Powell-Pepper (Pick 18), Peter Ladhams (RD Pick 9), Ben Ainsworth (Pick 4)
F: Willie Rioli (Pick 52), Darcy Cameron (Pick 48), Will Hayward (Pick 21)
R: Oscar McInerney (RD Pick 37), Jarrod Berry (Pick 17), Patrick Lipinski (Pick 28)
I: Zac Fisher (Pick 27), Harry Morrison (Pick 74), Lewis Young (Pick 49), Alex Witherden (Pick 23)

Who've you got as the medi-sub for both teams?

Also, which 2 of the 2016 retirees would you put in as coaches?

RedmanWasHere · Aug 2, 2022

adammania9 said:
There's a lot of depth in this draft

Team 1:
B: Tom Stewart (Pick 40), Brennan Cox (Pick 41), Luke Ryan (Pick 66)
HB: Jordan Ridley (Pick 22), Jack Henry (Rookie Pick 16), Andrew McGrath (Pick 1)
C: Hugh McCluggage (Pick 3), Jy Simpkin (Pick 12), Josh Daicos (Pick 57)
HF: Shai Bolton (Pick 29), Mitch Lewis (Pick 76), Tyson Stengle (RD Pick 6)
F: Tim English (Pick 19), Nick Larkey (Pick 73), Cameron Zurhaar (Rookie Pick 11)
R: Sean Darcy (Pick 38), Tim Taranto (Pick 2), Will Brodie (Pick 9)
I: Rowan Marshall (Rookie Pick 10), Todd Marshall (Pick 16), Brandan Parfitt (Pick 26), Oliver Florent (Pick 11)

Team 2:
B: Robbie Fox (RD Pick 34), Griffin Logue (Pick 8), Jack Scrimshaw (Pick 7)
HB: Harry Perryman (Pick 14), Josh Battle (Pick 39), Jack Bowes (Pick 10)
C: Sam Petrevski-Seton (Pick 6), Willem Drew (Pick 33), Jack Graham (Pick 53)
HF: Sam Powell-Pepper (Pick 18), Peter Ladhams (RD Pick 9), Ben Ainsworth (Pick 4)
F: Willie Rioli (Pick 52), Darcy Cameron (Pick 48), Will Hayward (Pick 21)
R: Oscar McInerney (RD Pick 37), Jarrod Berry (Pick 17), Patrick Lipinski (Pick 28)
I: Zac Fisher (Pick 27), Harry Morrison (Pick 74), Lewis Young (Pick 49), Alex Witherden (Pick 23)

Further, my picks for captain in bold.

Footy Smarts · Aug 2, 2022

adammania9 said:
There's a lot of depth in this draft

Team 1:
B: Tom Stewart (Pick 40), Brennan Cox (Pick 41), Luke Ryan (Pick 66)
HB: Jordan Ridley (Pick 22), Jack Henry (Rookie Pick 16), Andrew McGrath (Pick 1)
C: Hugh McCluggage (Pick 3), Jy Simpkin (Pick 12), Josh Daicos (Pick 57)
HF: Shai Bolton (Pick 29), Mitch Lewis (Pick 76), Tyson Stengle (RD Pick 6)
F: Tim English (Pick 19), Nick Larkey (Pick 73), Cameron Zurhaar (Rookie Pick 11)
R: Sean Darcy (Pick 38), Tim Taranto (Pick 2), Will Brodie (Pick 9)
I: Rowan Marshall (Rookie Pick 10), Todd Marshall (Pick 16), Brandan Parfitt (Pick 26), Oliver Florent (Pick 11)

Team 2:
B: Robbie Fox (RD Pick 34), Griffin Logue (Pick 8), Jack Scrimshaw (Pick 7)
HB: Harry Perryman (Pick 14), Josh Battle (Pick 39), Jack Bowes (Pick 10)
C: Sam Petrevski-Seton (Pick 6), Willem Drew (Pick 33), Jack Graham (Pick 53)
HF: Sam Powell-Pepper (Pick 18), Peter Ladhams (RD Pick 9), Ben Ainsworth (Pick 4)
F: Willie Rioli (Pick 52), Darcy Cameron (Pick 48), Will Hayward (Pick 21)
R: Oscar McInerney (RD Pick 37), Jarrod Berry (Pick 17), Patrick Lipinski (Pick 28)
I: Zac Fisher (Pick 27), Harry Morrison (Pick 74), Lewis Young (Pick 49), Alex Witherden (Pick 23)

Sam Draper, Mark O'Connor, Zach Guthrie, Connor Nash, Jarrod Lienert and Jamaine Jones all played this week and can't even get a spot in the second team!

Marcel Proust · Aug 2, 2022

Jeremias said:
Got an example of that?

The footy show

Wild Bill · Aug 2, 2022

Marcel Proust said:
The afl media seem to think otherwise.

Saying he is there abouts now.

Come he has half the votes of Oliver, Miller and Petracca. They don’t have games where they don’t impact. Talent wise he is amazing but he can light it up for a half and hardly touch it.

scott_the_man · Aug 3, 2022

adammania9 said:
There's a lot of depth in this draft

Team 1:
B: Tom Stewart (Pick 40), Brennan Cox (Pick 41), Luke Ryan (Pick 66)
HB: Jordan Ridley (Pick 22), Jack Henry (Rookie Pick 16), Andrew McGrath (Pick 1)
C: Hugh McCluggage (Pick 3), Jy Simpkin (Pick 12), Josh Daicos (Pick 57)
HF: Shai Bolton (Pick 29), Mitch Lewis (Pick 76), Tyson Stengle (RD Pick 6)
F: Tim English (Pick 19), Nick Larkey (Pick 73), Cameron Zurhaar (Rookie Pick 11)
R: Sean Darcy (Pick 38), Tim Taranto (Pick 2), Will Brodie (Pick 9)
I: Rowan Marshall (Rookie Pick 10), Todd Marshall (Pick 16), Brandan Parfitt (Pick 26), Oliver Florent (Pick 11)

Team 2:
B: Robbie Fox (RD Pick 34), Griffin Logue (Pick 8), Jack Scrimshaw (Pick 7)
HB: Harry Perryman (Pick 14), Josh Battle (Pick 39), Jack Bowes (Pick 10)
C: Sam Petrevski-Seton (Pick 6), Willem Drew (Pick 33), Jack Graham (Pick 53)
HF: Sam Powell-Pepper (Pick 18), Peter Ladhams (RD Pick 9), Ben Ainsworth (Pick 4)
F: Willie Rioli (Pick 52), Darcy Cameron (Pick 48), Will Hayward (Pick 21)
R: Oscar McInerney (RD Pick 37), Jarrod Berry (Pick 17), Patrick Lipinski (Pick 28)
I: Zac Fisher (Pick 27), Harry Morrison (Pick 74), Lewis Young (Pick 49), Alex Witherden (Pick 23)

Jeez there's a lot of talent even in the 2nds team. Bloody deep draft indeed.

Wild Bill · Aug 3, 2022

adammania9 said:
There's a lot of depth in this draft

Team 1:
B: Tom Stewart (Pick 40), Brennan Cox (Pick 41), Luke Ryan (Pick 66)
HB: Jordan Ridley (Pick 22), Jack Henry (Rookie Pick 16), Andrew McGrath (Pick 1)
C: Hugh McCluggage (Pick 3), Jy Simpkin (Pick 12), Josh Daicos (Pick 57)
HF: Shai Bolton (Pick 29), Mitch Lewis (Pick 76), Tyson Stengle (RD Pick 6)
F: Tim English (Pick 19), Nick Larkey (Pick 73), Cameron Zurhaar (Rookie Pick 11)
R: Sean Darcy (Pick 38), Tim Taranto (Pick 2), Will Brodie (Pick 9)
I: Rowan Marshall (Rookie Pick 10), Todd Marshall (Pick 16), Brandan Parfitt (Pick 26), Oliver Florent (Pick 11)

Team 2:
B: Robbie Fox (RD Pick 34), Griffin Logue (Pick 8), Jack Scrimshaw (Pick 7)
HB: Harry Perryman (Pick 14), Josh Battle (Pick 39), Jack Bowes (Pick 10)
C: Sam Petrevski-Seton (Pick 6), Willem Drew (Pick 33), Jack Graham (Pick 53)
HF: Sam Powell-Pepper (Pick 18), Peter Ladhams (RD Pick 9), Ben Ainsworth (Pick 4)
F: Willie Rioli (Pick 52), Darcy Cameron (Pick 48), Will Hayward (Pick 21)
R: Oscar McInerney (RD Pick 37), Jarrod Berry (Pick 17), Patrick Lipinski (Pick 28)
I: Zac Fisher (Pick 27), Harry Morrison (Pick 74), Lewis Young (Pick 49), Alex Witherden (Pick 23)

Not sure any other draft could beat team 1.

eth-dog · Aug 3, 2022

adammania9 said:
There's a lot of depth in this draft

Team 1:
B: Tom Stewart (Pick 40), Brennan Cox (Pick 41), Luke Ryan (Pick 66)
HB: Jordan Ridley (Pick 22), Jack Henry (Rookie Pick 16), Andrew McGrath (Pick 1)
C: Hugh McCluggage (Pick 3), Jy Simpkin (Pick 12), Josh Daicos (Pick 57)
HF: Shai Bolton (Pick 29), Mitch Lewis (Pick 76), Tyson Stengle (RD Pick 6)
F: Tim English (Pick 19), Nick Larkey (Pick 73), Cameron Zurhaar (Rookie Pick 11)
R: Sean Darcy (Pick 38), Tim Taranto (Pick 2), Will Brodie (Pick 9)
I: Rowan Marshall (Rookie Pick 10), Todd Marshall (Pick 16), Brandan Parfitt (Pick 26), Oliver Florent (Pick 11)

Team 2:
B: Robbie Fox (RD Pick 34), Griffin Logue (Pick 8), Jack Scrimshaw (Pick 7)
HB: Harry Perryman (Pick 14), Josh Battle (Pick 39), Jack Bowes (Pick 10)
C: Sam Petrevski-Seton (Pick 6), Willem Drew (Pick 33), Jack Graham (Pick 53)
HF: Sam Powell-Pepper (Pick 18), Peter Ladhams (RD Pick 9), Ben Ainsworth (Pick 4)
F: Willie Rioli (Pick 52), Darcy Cameron (Pick 48), Will Hayward (Pick 21)
R: Oscar McInerney (RD Pick 37), Jarrod Berry (Pick 17), Patrick Lipinski (Pick 28)
I: Zac Fisher (Pick 27), Harry Morrison (Pick 74), Lewis Young (Pick 49), Alex Witherden (Pick 23).

I'm obviously biased but Draper has to be in the second side for me, I think he's closing in on Darcy and Marshall as the third best ruck of this crop. Would also have Berry ahead of Florent in the ones and probably Logue as a second key defender somewhere in there.

Wild Bill · Aug 3, 2022

eth-dog said:
I'm obviously biased but Draper has to be in the second side for me, I think he's closing in on Darcy and Marshall as the third best ruck of this crop. Would also have Berry ahead of Florent in the ones and probably Logue as a second key defender somewhere in there.

Yep - Draper is in front of the Big O. Also he adds value with his goal celebrations.

adammania9 · Aug 3, 2022

Footy Smarts said:
Sam Draper, Mark O'Connor, Zach Guthrie, Connor Nash, Jarrod Lienert and Jamaine Jones all played this week and can't even get a spot in the second team!

And Isaac Cumming. Most would get in but I forgot them. A testament to the depth

RedmanWasHere · Aug 3, 2022

adammania9 said:
And Isaac Cumming. Most would get in but I forgot them. A testament to the depth

Isaac Cumming becomes player No. 51 in the names mentioned since your teams post.

Crazy depth indeed.

BrutThough · Aug 3, 2022

RedmanWasHere said:
Isaac Cumming becomes player No. 51 in the names mentioned since your teams post.

Crazy depth indeed.

Ben Long as well. Another solid player to add to this drafts depth.

RedmanWasHere · Aug 3, 2022

Is the draft's cut-off point for depth Zach Sproule?

RedmanWasHere · Aug 3, 2022

On this, who would you guys take first if these 2 were available?

Zach Sproule or Taylin Duman?

eth-dog · Aug 3, 2022

RedmanWasHere said:
On this, who would you guys take first if these 2 were available?

Zach Sproule or Taylin Duman?

Sproule

freo_leo29 · Aug 3, 2022

RedmanWasHere said:
On this, who would you guys take first if these 2 were available?

Zach Sproule or Taylin Duman?

Duman was another victim of Freo drafting a s**t tonne of defenders, him and Tobe Watson (diff draft) were cut too early but because Freo were s**t noone else gave them a go, even though our defense was really good.

tonygeeks · Aug 3, 2022

How has Duman been going in the VFL ?

Always liked that guy

On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

s_wd6 · Aug 3, 2022

tonygeeks said:
How has Duman been going in the VFL ?

Always liked that guy

On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Had a 42 disposal (36 kicks) 15 mark game a few weeks back.

Rd 7 Sunday + Club boards

Rd 7 Reviews + Club boards »

EPL Matchdays 34, 35, & 36 ⚽ Tip Now

Draft Review 2016 - Revisiting the 2016 AFL Draft

Norm Smith Medallist

"Oohh WADA ooga booga" {Jul 11 2013}

Everyone's favourite grouch

"Oohh WADA ooga booga" {Jul 11 2013}

Brownlow Medallist

"Oohh WADA ooga booga" {Jul 11 2013}

Moderator

Rarely in kitchens at parties.

Rarely in kitchens at parties.

Brownlow Medallist

"Oohh WADA ooga booga" {Jul 11 2013}

Brownlow Medallist

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

Tier 1 WW Player

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Rarely in kitchens at parties.

Brownlow Medallist

Rarely in kitchens at parties.

Rarely in kitchens at parties.

Tier 1 WW Player

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Similar threads