List Mgmt. 2024 Trade & List Management Thread

[sheridan]

I would take both for the right draft capital shiel is a insane trainer I would look at Jed bews from cats same insane trainer only 30

shiel can run a Pt business then. stay the heck away from our list…

 

[DuckYeah]

I would take both for the right draft capital shiel is a insane trainer I would look at Jed bews from cats same insane trainer only 30

What I wouldn’t like to see are spud players coming to collect one last pay day. **** that

 

[Harris 10]

Not very happy about this. Just heard Shiel will be on our list next year

The Shiel thing started a few days ago from one of those stupid FB or X pages

 

[amaz199]

Shiel wouldn't cost a lot but at this stage anything is going to improve us. We're seriously that bad in terms of lacking senior experience.

It's incredible how badly our list management has been. We went from the Rolls Royces in Wells, Boomer, Higgo etc. etc. to considering Shiel lol.

Disaster. Just get Parker.

 

[cmhaj_]

yeh, same bloke that told me boomer was going to step away. I think the club is looking at everyone. I also heard Marchbank too. Whether they have enquired or are set on it is the grey area

I HATE seeing this type of player come to North and clog our list. STOP.

 

[DuckYeah]

The Shiel thing started a few days ago from one of those stupid FB or X pages

View attachment 1997967

It didn’t come from there. It come from a very close mate to a legend of our club.

 

[R00StaR]

Finally somebody outside of the smaller clubs sees how the deck is stacked against the smaller Vic clubs.

 

[giantroo]

 

[Twangler]

Which of norths current midfielders would Shiel replace output?

Phillips? Lazzaro? Shiels? Greenwood?
Certainly wouldn’t be ahead of Powell, Wardlaw and LDU and above names are pretty debatable as well.

 

[King Corey]

Do Hawthorn get a compensation pick if they poach Hardwick?

 

[hilly]

Do Hawthorn get a compensation pick if they poach Hardwick?

You mean if they lose him? It's based on net position...I imagine if they lost him and gained one of Perryman/Battle they'd get nothing.

 

[Harris 10]

Which of norths current midfielders would Shiel replace output?

Phillips? Lazzaro? Shiels? Greenwood?
Certainly wouldn’t be ahead of Powell, Wardlaw and LDU and above names are pretty debatable as well.

2 of them will be retired, one will probably request a trade and who knows what happens to fumbles Lazzaro.

In saying that I’m sure we could find better options than Dylan Shiel.

 

[giantroo]

 

[ToxicMegaPunts]

Which of norths current midfielders would Shiel replace output?

Phillips? Lazzaro? Shiels? Greenwood?
Certainly wouldn’t be ahead of Powell, Wardlaw and LDU and above names are pretty debatable as well.

Shiel ain't gonna solve any of our most pertinent midfield issues, namely defensive accountability, ball use by foot, and hardness at the contest. He is a soft downhill skier who torches the footy. Adding him would only further exacerbate our current midfield woes.

 

[Shermanator]

The Shiel thing started a few days ago from one of those stupid FB or X pages

View attachment 1997967

What a load of shit.

With half the list currently made up of one-way running soft serves that’s got us in this hole, the LAST person in the AFL we would chase would be the biggest soft serve of them all.

This is troll and it wouldn’t surprise me if it was from a *scum supporter.

 

[Shinboner Supremacy]

Another squib that cant kick? Bet ya heckin dollar on it I really hope its just an enquiry thats got out, I really do

Same. He is absolutely putrid!

 

[DunderHead]

Need to replace our bottom four blokes with guys who can play and compete at AFL level.

It ain’t going to be pretty. No A graders are coming our way.

 

[ChairmanZia]

Why are we always thinking of experience players to lead, why are we not getting the right experience players to hold the line so the top end youngsters attack ala alexander the great and general parmenion?

 

[ChairmanZia]

Need to replace our bottom four blokes with guys who can play and compete at AFL level.

It ain’t going to be pretty. No A graders are coming our way.

Yes, and these need to be replaced with the experienced blokes

 

[New_Roo]

Why are we always thinking of experience players to lead, why are we not getting the right experience players to hold the line so the top end youngsters attack ala alexander the great and general parmenion?

Does this make sense? Instead of getting experienced players to lead we should get the right experienced players?


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[leighlee13]

The Shiel thing started a few days ago from one of those stupid FB or X pages

View attachment 1997967

Just sayin, everyone looks better in our colours.

 

[Hearts to hearts]

Just sayin, everyone looks better in our colours.

This one still doesn’t look good though.

 

[Ashley B]

This one still doesn’t look good though.

It looks odd maybe the jet black hair and colours don’t match or perhaps it’s his uniquely shaped head

 

[roos_fanatic08]

If we get Shiel, that would just about do me. Unless it was a salary dump and Essendon’s first rounder came with it.

We are the worst turnover side in the comp, and Shiel is one of the worst turnover players in the game. He is also one soft tissue injury away from being completely cooked.

 

[Epictetus]

If we get Shiel, that would just about do me. Unless it was a salary dump and Essendon’s first rounder came with it.

We are the worst turnover side in the comp, and Shiel is one of the worst turnover players in the game. He is also one soft tissue injury away from being completely cooked.

Agree, but more importantly, he doesn't provide the type of experience we need. He's never seen success, he's selfish, he doesn't strike me as a player who values team and others and as you say, he's a limited player.

We wouldn't do it. I have enough faith - just enough - that we are better run than this.