Competitions All Time Draft - Vote For The Best Team

Who Has The Best Team


  • Total voters
    14
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

_RT_

2017 2019 2020
Sep 17, 2006
40,428
67,210
Southern Stand Punt Road End
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Furies Premiers 2010
I've seen this done on a couple of boards and was thinking it could be an interesting exercise to run on our board. To make this work ideally we'd have between 8-12 participants, so please if you join make sure that you are a regular poster so that this runs right through to the end. Maybe we can ask the mods for a badge to be awarded to the person whose team is voted as the best.

1. A player will only be judged on deeds done in the Yellow & Black.

2. No time limit for picks. With regards to work commitments, it's probably unreasonable to assume that everyone can be on the same schedule and be able to pull the trigger on their next selection as soon as the previous selection has been made (myself included). If anyone is really dragging their feet, we will just rely on good old fashioned peer pressure through tagging. With 198 players to pick though it would be nice to move through the rounds quite quickly, after you've posted your selection, tag the next poster as a courtesy.

3. Feel free to write a few sentences to justify your selection! It'll make it easier to push your case for voting for the best team at the end.

4. All players, past and present, are eligible.

5. The draft order will be randomised and will run in a snake order for example if we get 12 players then it runs: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 12, 11, 10, 9, 8, 7, 6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1
 
Draft Picks New

_RT_

2017 2019 2020
Sep 17, 2006
40,428
67,210
Southern Stand Punt Road End
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Furies Premiers 2010
Round 1
1. Wacky Tiger - Dustin Martin
2. richoatthedisco - Royce Hart
3. Tiger_Of_Old - Kevin Bartlett
4. Barunga Bullet - Matthew Richardson
5. richard parker - Trent Cotchin
6. peterbuch74 - Dale Weightman
7. _RT_ - Jack Dyer
8. Phar Ace - Jack Titus
9. tiger_tough - Jack Riewoldt

Round 2

10. tiger_tough - Alex Rance
11. Phar Ace - Maurice Rioli
12. _RT_ - Francis Bourke
13. peterbuch74 - Michael Roach
14. richard parker - Shane Edwards
15. Barunga Bullet - Ian Stewart
16. Tiger_Of_Old - Nathan Brown
17. richoatthedisco - Bill Barrot
18. Wacky Tiger - Dylan Grimes

Round 3
19. Wacky Tiger - Roy Wright
20. richoatthedisco - Vic Thorp
21. Tiger Of Old - Matthew Knights
22. Barunga Bullet - Dick Clay
23. Richard Parker - Wayne Campbell
24. Peter Buch 74 - Darren Gaspar
25. RT - Dick Harris
26. Phar Ace - Michael Green
27. Tiger Tough - Geoff Raines

Round 4
28. Tiger Tough - Kevin Sheedy
29. Phar Ace - Roger Dean
30. RT - Ron Branton
31. Peter Buch 74 - Nick Vlastuin
32. Richard Parker - Brett Deledio
33. Barunga Bullet - Jim Jess
34. Tiger Of Old - Mark Lee
35. richoatthedisco - Bryan Wood
36. Wacky Tiger - Neil Balme

Round 5
37. Wacky Tiger - Barry Richardson
38. richoatthedisco - Robert Wiley
39. Tiger Of Old - Noah Balta
40. Barunga Bullet - Joel Bowden
41. Richard Parker - Jeff Hogg
42. Peter Buch 74 - Chris Newman
43. RT - Mervyn Keane
44. Phar Ace - Fred Swift
45. Tiger Tough - David Cloke

Round 6
46. Tiger Tough - Barry Rowlings
47. Phar Ace - Tony Free
48. RT - Bill Morris
49. Peter Buch 74 - Brendon Gale
50. Richard Parker - Scott Turner
51. Barunga Bullet - Tom Lynch
52. Tiger Of Old - Paul Broderick
53. richoatthedisco - Bachar Houli
54. Wacky Tiger - Gordon Strang

Round 7
55. Wacky Tiger - Doug Strang
56. richoatthedisco - Dion Prestia
57. Tiger Of Old - Michael Perry
58. Barunga Bullet - Michael Malthouse
59. Richard Parker - Toby Nankervis
60. Peter Buch 74 - Ivan Maric
61. RT - Brad Ottens
62. Phar Ace - David Astbury
63. Tiger Tough - Shane Tuck

Round 8
64. Tiger Tough - Andrew Kellaway
65. Phar Ace - Paddy Guinane
66. RT - Brian Taylor
67. Peter Buch 74 - Kane Lambert
68. Richard Parker - Neville Crowe
69. Barunga Bullet - Nathan Foley
70. Tiger Of Old - Shai Bolton
71. richoatthedisco - Ray Poulter
72. Wacky Tiger - Kane Johnson

Round 9
73. Wacky Tiger - Craig Lambert
74. richoatthedisco - Perce Bentley
75. Tiger Of Old - Ben Cousins
76. Barunga Bullet - Ben Holland
77. Richard Parker - Basil McCormack
78. Peter Buch 74 - Michael Mitchell
79. RT - Mark Coughlan
80. Phar Ace - Des Rowe
81. Tiger Tough - Bruce Monteath

Round 10
82. Tiger Tough - Mike Patterson
83. Phar Ace - Stuey Maxfield
84. RT - Robbie 'Bones' McGhie
85. Peter Buch 74 - John Northey
86. Richard Parker - Michael Pickering
87. Barunga Bullet - Nick Daffy
88. Tiger Of Old - Greg Strachan
89. richoatthedisco - Stan Judkins
90. Wacky Tiger - Jayden Short

Round 11
91. Wacky Tiger - Rex Hunt
92. richoatthedisco - Mopsy Fraser Jr
93. Tiger Of Old - Max Oppy
94. Barunga Bullet - Kevin Morris
95. Richard Parker - Billy Brown
96. Peter Buch 74 - Leon Cameron
97. RT - Mark Chaffey
98. Phar Ace - Ricky McLean
99. Tiger Tough - Wayne Walsh

Round 12
100. Tiger Tough - Andrew Krakouer
101. Phar Ace - Leo Merrett
102. RT - Chris Naish
103. Peter Buch 74 - Michael Gale
104. Richard Parker - Sydney Stack
105. Barunga Bullet - Jack O'Rourke
106. Tiger Of Old - Brian Roberts
107. richoatthedisco - Paul Sproule
108. Wacky Tiger - Brandon Ellis

Round 13
109. Wacky Tiger - Jack Graham
110. richoatthedisco - Jack Baggott
111. Tiger Of Old - Kamdyn McIntosh
112. Barunga Bullet - Phil Egan
113. Richard Parker - Alan Geddes
114. Peter Buch 74 - Bill Wilson
115. RT - Arthur 'Joe' Murdoch
116. Phar Ace - Graham Burgin
117. Tiger Tough - Duncan Kellaway

Round 14
118. Tiger Tough - Daniel Jackson
119. Phar Ace - Dan Minogue
120. RT - Maurie Sheahan
121. Peter Buch 74 - Havel Rowe
122. Richard Parker - Nathan Broad
123. Barunga Bullet - Kevin O'Neill
124. Tiger Of Old - Chris Bond
125. richoatthedisco - Mark Merenda
126. Wacky Tiger - Shaun Grigg

Round 15
127. Wacky Tiger - Matty Rogers
128. richoatthedisco - Trevor Poole
129. Tiger Of Old - Terry Smith
130. Barunga Bullet - Greg Tivendale
131. Richard Parker - Martin Bolger
132. Peter Buch 74 - Graeme Bond
133. RT - Hughie James
134. Phar Ace - Eric Zschech
135. Tiger Tough - Donald Don

Round 16
136. Tiger Tough - Daniel Rioli
137. Phar Ace - John 'Ray' Martin
138. RT - Clarrie Hall
139. Peter Buch 74 - Emmett Dunne
140. Richard Parker - Liam Baker
141. Barunga Bullet - John Annear
142. Tiger Of Old - Laurie Fowler
143. richoatthedisco - George Smeaton
144. Wacky Tiger - Jamie Tape

Round 17
145. Wacky Tiger - Ted Langridge
146. richoatthedisco - Greg Stafford
147. Tiger Of Old - John Ronaldson
148. Barunga Bullet - Troy Chaplin
149. Richard Parker - Bill Cosgrove
150. Peter Buch 74 - Will Thursfield
151. RT - Alan 'BULL' Richardson
152. Phar Ace - Neville Roberts
153. Tiger Tough - Jake King

Round 18
154. Tiger Tough - Jason Torney
155. Phar Ace - Bob Bawden
156. RT - Andrew 'Max' Hislop
157. Peter Buch 74 - Daniel Butler
158. Richard Parker - Peter Welsh
159. Barunga Bullet - Josh Caddy
160. Tiger Of Old - Marlion Pickett
161. richoatthedisco - Robert Lamb
162. Wacky Tiger - Tom Hafey

Round 19
163. Wacky Tiger - Jason Castagna
164. richoatthedisco - Geoff Strang
165. Tiger Of Old - Tyrone Vickery
166. Barunga Bullet - Greg Dear
167. Richard Parker - Maurie Hunter
168. Peter Buch 74 - Barney Herbert
169. RT - Charles Backhouse
170. Phar Ace - George Bayliss
171. Tiger Tough - Frank 'Checker' Hughes

Round 20
172. Tiger Tough - Thomas O'Halloran
173. Phar Ace - Ron Durham
174. RT - Alec Edmond
175. Peter Buch 74 - Jimmy Smith
176. Richard Parker - Henry Colden Antill Harrison
177. Barunga Bullet - John 'Jack' Hutchinson
178. Tiger Of Old - Bruce Tempany
179. richoatthedisco - Fred Burge
180. Wacky Tiger - Bill Perkins

Round 21
181. Wacky Tiger - Geoff Spring
182. richoatthedisco - Frank Harley
183. Tiger Of Old - Craig McKellar
184. Barunga Bullet - Percy Maybury
185. Richard Parker - Dave Cuzens
186. Peter Buch 74 - Mel Morris
187. RT - Ray Stokes
188. Phar Ace - Frank Huggard
189. Tiger Tough - Danny Guinane

Round 22
190. Tiger Tough - Tom Simpson
191. Phar Ace - Maurice Rioli Jr
192. RT - James Parker
193. Peter Buch 74
194. Richard Parker
195. Barunga Bullet
196. Tiger Of Old
197. richoatthedisco -
198. Wacky Tiger
 
Last edited:

_RT_

2017 2019 2020
Sep 17, 2006
40,428
67,210
Southern Stand Punt Road End
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Furies Premiers 2010
Wackys Best 22

FB:
Tom Hafey - Barry Richardson - Dylan Grimes
HB:
Jayden Short - Gordon Strang - Jamie Tape
C:
Shaun Grigg - Jack Graham - Brandon Ellis
HF:
Matthew Rogers - Rex Hunt - Dustin Martin
FF:
Ted Langridge - Doug Strang - Neil Balme
Foll:
Roy Wright - Kane Johnson - Craig Lambert
Int:
Jason Castagna - Bill Perkins - Geoff Spring - Justin Charles

RATD 22
B: Smeaton Thorp Poole
HB: Houli Fraser Strang
C: Wood Barrot Judkins
HF: Baggott Hart Merenda
F: Wiley Poulter Lamb
R: Bentley Sproule Prestia
INT: Stafford Harley Burge B.Edwards

Tiger Of Old 22
B:Bond,Balta,Strachan
HB:Terry Smith,Perry,Fowler
C:McIntosh,Knights,Pickett
HF:Brown,Ronaldson,Oppy
F:Bartlett,Roberts,Bolton
Foll:Lee,Broderick,Cousins
I/C:Tempany,Vickery/McKellar/Palm


Barunga Bulletts 22
B: Malthouse Chaplin O'Neill
HB: Bowden Jess Morris
C: Clay Stewart Tivendale
HF: Daffy Richo Egan
F: Hutchinson Lynch O'Rourke
R: Dear Foley Annear
INT: Caddy Holland Maybury Landy

Richard Parkers 22
B: Martin Bolger - Scott Turner - Nathan Broad
HB: Basil McCormack - Dave Cuzens - Liam Baker
C: Henry Colden Harrison - Trent Cotchin - Allan Geddes
HF: Brett Deledio - Michael Pickering - Sydney Stack
F: Billy Brown - Jeff Hogg - Maurie Hunter
Fol: Toby Nankervis - Wayne Campbell - Shane Edwards
IC: N.Crowe - Peter "Whoosa" Welsh - Bill Cosgrove - Sel Murray

PB74
B: Cameron Gaspar Vlastuin
HB: Newman Thursfield M.Gale
C: G.Bond M.Mitchell Havel Rowe
HF: Northey B.Gale K.Lambert
F: Dunne Roach Butler
R: Maric Wilson Weightman
INT: Herbert Smith M.Morris Pettifer

RT 22
B: Branton Sheahan Murdoch
HB: Keane M.Hislop McGhie
C: Bourke(VC) Coughlan Stokes
HF: A.Richardson Ottens Backhouse
F: Harris Taylor C.Naish
R: Morris Dyer(C) Hall
INT: James Chaffey Edmond Parker


Phar Ace 22
B: D Astbury F.Swift R.Dean
HB: D.Rowe D.Minogue(c) G.Burgin
C: S.Maxfield M Rioli Snr L.Merrett
HF: N.Roberts P.Guinane E.Zschech
F: R.Bawden R.McLean J.Titus
FOL: M.Green T.Free R.Martin
INT: G.Bayliss R.Durham F.Huggard M.Rioli Jnr

Tiger Tough 22
B: D.Kellaway......A.Kellaway........K.Sheedy
HB: D.Rioli...........A.Rance............D.Guinane
C: D.Jackson........G.Raines.........W.Walsh
HF: B.Monteath.....D.Cloke..........D.Don
FF: A.Krakoeur....J.Riewoldt.........T.O'Halloran
R: M.Patterson......F.Hughes.........B.Rowlings
I/C: S.Tuck....J.King....J.Torney....T.Simpson
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

_RT_

2017 2019 2020
Sep 17, 2006
40,428
67,210
Southern Stand Punt Road End
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Furies Premiers 2010
There has to be a time line for players as nobody would know a player from 1917
There are 1176 players who have worn the Richmond jumper in the VFL/AFL. If we have 12 people participating it's 264 selections that will be made. No need to limit the eras that players can be selected from. There are some from that far back that are worthy of being selected in all time line ups and it would be unfair to exclude them.
 

Rioli2Rioli

Club Legend
Nov 23, 2015
2,281
7,054
#17
AFL Club
Richmond
There are 1176 players who have worn the Richmond jumper in the VFL/AFL. If we have 12 people participating it's 264 selections that will be made. No need to limit the eras that players can be selected from. There are some from that far back that are worthy of being selected in all time line ups and it would be unfair to exclude them.
Just thinking for judging it would be impossible to judge as nobody that is alive would remember any player after 1950
 

_RT_

2017 2019 2020
Sep 17, 2006
40,428
67,210
Southern Stand Punt Road End
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Furies Premiers 2010
Just thinking for judging it would be impossible to judge as nobody that is alive would remember any player after 1950
It's not like we're going to be picking 100 players from 100 years ago, but there are a number of all time greats who should be included in the pool.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Wrenny

Premiership Player
Dec 8, 2003
4,434
4,259
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Liverpool FC
q6pzXhTTmk7Is.gif
 

Tiger_Of_Old

๐Ÿ†๐Ÿ†๐Ÿ†๐Ÿ†๐Ÿ†๐Ÿ†๐Ÿ†๐Ÿ†๐Ÿ†๐Ÿ†๐Ÿ†๐Ÿ†
Nov 23, 2000
49,732
104,425
Country Victoria
AFL Club
Richmond
There are 1176 players who have worn the Richmond jumper in the VFL/AFL. If we have 12 people participating it's 264 selections that will be made. No need to limit the eras that players can be selected from. There are some from that far back that are worthy of being selected in all time line ups and it would be unfair to exclude them.
1175 are stiff not to go #1.