- Apr 16, 2008
- 9,690
- 26,523
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Safe bet with average disposal Clearly worth 2 1sts... No thanks!None of his potential shown is relevant to the discussion though.
I mean Cripps best has been clearly better then Walsh’s but everyone would take Walsh ahead of Cripps
I’d probably take Curnow going forward as well given his age and pre injury form but that wasn’t what was argued. If you confine it down who’s going to be better in 2022 I’d probably take the safe bet in Shiel.
But again, you're entitled to your opinion.
I don't rate Shiel in the top 50 midfielders in the comp so I just can't agree he is a safe bet out of the 2.