Changes v West Coast

[Phoenixguard09]

If boak is fit then Ken should resign in shame

If boak isn't fit then Ken should resign in shame for repeatedly lying


If Ken had the courage he would drop Ebert and Boak

But we know the only courage Ken has, is the type that let's a player be courageous.

Whatever that means. I think we saw Ken courageous in the last 10 minutes.

When did Ken's courageous last win us a game?

Who of our assistants would you prefer coaching over Hinkley?

Voss? Nicks? Basset? **** me sideways.

 

[Powerade 08]

We get nothing out of bringing Carlile back in. Clurey or Austin should be given an extended run if we want another tall defender.

 

[Coobk001]

IN: Carlile, R Gray, Colquhoun
OUT: O'Shea, Impey, AhChee


WCE by 49 points.

 

[Chokito]

farkn

robbie in for the demolition of us at the hands of the eagles.

since we've given GWS a record, we may as well restore the country's faith in WCE by giving them a comprehensive win away from home.

we dont deserve to be in the 8 with the footy we're playng

 

[x_les_x]

I actually wouldnt mind austin to debut this week, has been in good form and deserves it. Eagles have the 3 tall forward line and jonas needs to play on lecca

In: austin colquhoun toumpas r Gray carlile
Out: oshea amon ah chee impey stewart(even though he was ok today)

 

[Coobk001]

we dont deserve to be in the 8 with the footy we're playng

Yep and we wont be. We just aren't that good.

We'll get a good draft pick this year, we need to make it count.

 

[Us against the rest]

It won't make any difference who we bring in or drop, it's the attitude and skills not 1 or 2 players, it's the whole team.

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

OUT: Neade, Stewart, O'Shea (None of the would get a game anywhere else in the league), Krak

IN: Colquhoon, R.Gray, Austin, Toumpas

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

People saying Carlile in clearly didn't watch the magpies game... Slow, poor defence etc... Game has gone past him

 

[John the Butcher]

OUT: O'Shea, Amon, PStew
IN: RGray, Austin, Butch for #crashingpacks or Dimitri

 

[port always]

OUT: O'Shea, Amon, PStew
IN: RGray, Austin, Butch for #crashingpacks or Dimitri

Why would you bother posting such dribble..
You may as well go for a walk and improve your health

 

[Power Raid]

Out: Neade, Ah Chee
In: Gray and ?

 

[John the Butcher]

Why would you bother posting such dribble..
You may as well go for a walk and improve your health

LukeDarcySayThatAgain.jpg

 

[Seanybruz]

Why would you bother posting such dribble..
You may as well go for a walk and improve your health

Stop being so overly defensive of Stewart, he marked well & is playing serviceable footy down back but the bloke is so bad when it comes to making decisions & delivering the ball he's actually making Jonas look AFL standard in comparison.

I will agree that he wouldn't be in my outs (Ah Chee is a certain out after his game) but honestly there's no need for personal insults just because someone included your best mate in their outs this week.

 

[port always]

LukeDarcySayThatAgain.jpg

Rehab works

 

[port always]

Stop being so overly defensive of Stewart, he marked well & is playing serviceable footy down back but the bloke is so bad when it comes to making decisions & delivering the ball he's actually making Jonas look AFL standard in comparison.

I will agree that he wouldn't be in my outs (Ah Chee is a certain out after his game) but honestly there's no need for personal insults just because someone included your best mate in their outs this week.

How touchy is your post...wasnt talking about Stewy it was about the Butcher messiah that constantly gets put up and does zero to deserve it..not worried about Stewy he us going well

 

[Seanybruz]

How touchy is your post...wasnt talking about Stewy it was about the Butcher messiah that constantly gets put up and does zero to deserve it..not worried about Stewy he us going well

You took issue with his post because he had Stewart dropped for Butcher or you would've singled out a number of others who have named Butch as an in.

Just don't think you should bite everyone's head of every time they say a bad word about Stewart, he's 29 in 2 months & part of the 22 that's letting this club down he's not immune from criticism.

 

[woffy]

There's reasons to drop most from this game. Need to look toward the future, whilst still try to win.

We need more height in defence without sacrificing speed - Austin for Jonas.
Clurey for Stewart - Stewy not the worst, but they're similar & Clurey will be around for the long haul.
Another KPF to help Dixon - Dougal for Neade.
Robbie for Ebert - make a statement Ken!
Palmer for Ah Chee.

 

[Alyx]

What I would like to happen:

Out: Ah Chee, Amon, Krakoeur, Neade, O'Shea.
In: R. Gray, Toumpas, Colquhoun, Palmer, Austin.

What will actually happen:

In: Carlile, R. Gray, S. Gray.
Out: Three completely undeserving players, baffling and frustrating everyone.

 

[StrappingTape]

It is time we played clurey and developed him in the afl otherwise he is another where theres no point having him on the list fo so long

 

[Sewer de Lance]

If the same set of rules and scrutiny applied to everyone then...

Boak & Ebert should be the first ones dropped back to the SANFL. Both are now purely earning a spot each week based on reputation alone and not upon merit.

 

[Eric Blair]

Great call - Butcher would have given us a target to kick to. How man times did we go down the line only for carltons big men take the mark.
We have seriously messed up this year.
Why have Butcher on the list if you aint going to use him.

This. So much this, but what is the point arguing as we know minimal changes will be made, and we'll have to get used to this shit one tall fwd structure until Schulz recovers.

This is what shits me more than anything, our predictability, the fact that we lose games on selection night, our lack of balance, and the fact that supporters can see this but coaching staff seemingly can't. What the **** gives? Rant over/

 

[PAFC66]

Agreed, this loss has really gotten to me, i feel gutted, almost betrayed.

I feel like we've all been sold a dud got so excited at first we've lost the receipt so have to keep it till it finally doesn't work.

 

[PAFC66]

This. So much this, but what is the point arguing as we know minimal changes will be made, and we'll have to get used to this shit one tall fwd structure until Schulz recovers.

This is what shits me more than anything, our predictability, the fact that we lose games on selection night, our lack of balance, and the fact that supporters can see this but coaching staff seemingly can't. What the **** gives? Rant over/

What used to happen was when Jay was out butch was his replacement. We normally actually win with Butcher in the side.. Poor kicking aside he takes a tall defenders attacking mind out of it and has to be accountable.. Rather then kick to short people we couldn't do any worse. Play him

 

[Quinz]

You guys shouldn't drop Neade, small/medium forwards always kill us. Either he, Wingard or Gray will kick 4+, I guarantee it.