- Oct 29, 2017
- 18,945
- 36,570
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Vote up.
If you had the final say on 3 more mandatory list cuts, who would you cut/trade?
- Thread starter beema limapep
- Start date
- Tagged users None
sregit
Club Legend
In Order
1. Aarts : just not good enough.
2. RCD : has not improved at an acceptable rate.
3. Martyn : has not shown enough
4. Stack : languished. Poor dedication. Never turns up to preseason in acceptable condition.
1. Aarts : just not good enough.
2. RCD : has not improved at an acceptable rate.
3. Martyn : has not shown enough
4. Stack : languished. Poor dedication. Never turns up to preseason in acceptable condition.
Aarts and Martyn are a given. For the third I'd be looking at trading out a fringe player that has some currency so we can still have a couple of decent picks this year and/or next year for the draft. One of Ralphsmith, Soldo, Graham and Ross could be the steak knives required so we can keep a decent pick or two, rather than trading them all out.
- Nov 26, 2013
- 12,602
- 22,409
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Man U, Chicago Bulls, Anaheim Ducks
It’s so easy
Delist:
Aarts: Not good enough for AFL
Martyn: As above
Trade
RCD: Not required if hopper and Taranto come in
Castagna: Lost his spot In the team, not skilled enough
Upgrade:
Stack: Class, X-Factor,Game Changer etc.
Delist:
Aarts: Not good enough for AFL
Martyn: As above
Trade
RCD: Not required if hopper and Taranto come in
Castagna: Lost his spot In the team, not skilled enough
Upgrade:
Stack: Class, X-Factor,Game Changer etc.
Frustrated Tiger
Norm Smith Medallist
*Aarts, good VFL player and that's it. Nothing wrong with that.
*Castagna, enough said.
*Martyn although he did okay off the HBF in the VFL when moved there.
*RCD happy to keep but if the GWS lads come in I just can't see who he replaces.
*Biggy, VFL games I've seen I've not been impressed. Good traffic director, loves pointing.
All imo only....
*Castagna, enough said.
*Martyn although he did okay off the HBF in the VFL when moved there.
*RCD happy to keep but if the GWS lads come in I just can't see who he replaces.
*Biggy, VFL games I've seen I've not been impressed. Good traffic director, loves pointing.
All imo only....
Last edited:
Noidnadroj
Norm Smith Medallist
- Dec 8, 2020
- 6,010
- 20,681
- AFL Club
- Richmond
If we can somehow get Castagna, Aarts, RCD and Martyn off our list, I believe we’d have a list where I could not name one single player where I can say with certainty “not AFL standard and never will be”.
This would change through 2023 as a couple of
spuds emerge, but in my mind we wouldn’t have a single ‘write off’ on our list to start 2023 which is quite extraordinary.
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
This would change through 2023 as a couple of
spuds emerge, but in my mind we wouldn’t have a single ‘write off’ on our list to start 2023 which is quite extraordinary.
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
- Apr 13, 2011
- 1,260
- 8,164
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Don't be stupid
It's obvious.
Aarts
Castagna
Daicos
Aarts
Castagna
Daicos
Soldo.
I think the days of an immobile ruck are over.
Love Soldo but would prefer a dud tap with a bit of run and carry.
Hit outs are over rated.
I think the days of an immobile ruck are over.
Love Soldo but would prefer a dud tap with a bit of run and carry.
Hit outs are over rated.
Groupie_
time to return the traditional Richmond yellow
daniel rioli and short
- May 15, 2017
- 22,747
- 87,239
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Dusty
how the * did you manage to get your original groupie account back
Groupie_
time to return the traditional Richmond yellow
royal commission
Aarts and Martyn.
Trade Castagna / RCD.
Trade Castagna / RCD.
I reckon RCD is around the 8th player to bring into the 22 to cover injuries (obviously dependent on which line those injuries are) Castagna, Martyn and Aarts would be around the 18-20th players to bring in, so those 3 for mine.
Aarts and RC/DC and Lynch.
Similar threads
