List Mgmt. List management for 2016

[Lagooner]

See ya Justin.

I'd rather Jackson play forward. Jacko and Ryder swap.

He looks like a baby giraffe kicking for goal but at least Jacko doesn't shit the bed every time he has a shot from 25m out directly in front.

 

[FishingRick04]

Disappointed in you last night Rick for all the talk of getting ruthless I heard garbage about signing Boomer Harvey for a year.. perplexed

Boomer Harvey is the opposite of Westhoff.

Boomer is a professional football who executes under pressure and has delivered for 21 seasons. We are void a small forward and we need some spine and leadership in this side that is mentally weak. If Boomer would come to us for a season and then take a coaching role it would only benefit our players.

Just may be professional with his physical preparation but he's the opposite. He's mentally fragile under pressure and he is way to inconsistent with his impact on games and output.

I hope that clears up your perplexion

 

[FishingRick04]

Can someone please sing the praises to me of why we should keep Justin outside he's a nice guy and has an awesome beard!

 

[Far Kern]

Can someone please sing the praises to me of why we should keep Justin outside he's a nice guy and has an awesome beard!

Because he's a match winner. Problem is that's about three quarters a year.

 

[JimmyBeerCans]

Boomer Harvey is the opposite of Westhoff.

Boomer is a professional football who executes under pressure and has delivered for 21 seasons. We are void a small forward and we need some spine and leadership in this side that is mentally weak. If Boomer would come to us for a season and then take a coaching role it would only benefit our players.

Just may be professional with his physical preparation but he's the opposite. He's mentally fragile under pressure and he is way to inconsistent with his impact on games and output.

I hope that clears up your perplexion

I wasn't relating it to Westhoff just the whole idea of being "ruthless" does not contain signing 40 year olds for a year it's diabolical thinking.

 

[PAFC66]

When is monfries and Ryder allowed to train?

 

[Loyal2Port]

Ultimately, we need winners, players who give a damn about who is in front at the final siren.

 

[Alfred_]

Would Westhoff even go somewhere else? He strikes me as pretty happy with his lot and more likely to retire than go elsewhere (unless it was to West Lakes, that is).

I was thinking this myself the other day, couldn't see him going interstate.

 

[FallingLiefs]

Can someone please sing the praises to me of why we should keep Justin outside he's a nice guy and has an awesome beard!

It's simple.
He's 30 his value isn't exactly worth trading out for.
He's currently easily in our 22
He's currently our second of 3 key forward's not on our long term injury list. With Butcher (the third) likely gone
He's not being payed a lot
He can play a variety of positions.
He's a better footballer than Kersten, Towers, Mayne, Schoenmakers, Darling, Waite, SReid. Who are all currently third tall in a top 4 team or have played in grand final side as a third tall.
He's got 3 years left in him.
We couldn't possibly pick up a kid to replace him with the pick 30-40 odd we get back.

 

[FishingRick04]

It's simple.
He's 30 his value isn't exactly worth trading out for.
He's currently easily in our 22
He's currently our second of 3 key forward's not on our long term injury list. With Butcher (the third) likely gone
He's not being payed a lot
He can play a variety of positions.
He's a better footballer than Kersten, Towers, Mayne, Schoenmakers, Darling, Waite, SReid. Who are all currently third tall in a top 4 team or have played in grand final side as a third tall.
He's got 3 years left in him.
We couldn't possibly pick up a kid to replace him with the pick 30-40 odd we get back.

Have you considered he's been part of our group since 2007. A period where we haven't really done much. Potentially he's part of the problem?

 

[FishingRick04]

I wasn't relating it to Westhoff just the whole idea of being "ruthless" does not contain signing 40 year olds for a year it's diabolical thinking.

Recruiting Boomer, why isn't that ruthless? Who cares what the age is as long as the strategy is right?

Mature recruits have filled a spot in other teams, I'd prefer to look at all options and if non fits his type so be it. He would add more value than Neade would! He would add more leadership than most of lads playing out there. We need a consistent small forward and a natural leader, he looks to fit that bill.

 

[Alfred_]

Recruiting Boomer, why isn't that ruthless? Who cares what the age is as long as the strategy is right?

Mature recruits have filled a spot in other teams, I'd prefer to look at all options and if non fits his type so be it. He would add more value than Neade would! He would add more leadership than most of lads playing out there. We need a consistent small forward and a natural leader, he looks to fit that bill.

The time that Logan Austin sold candy to him twice in one play I realised Boomer was finished.

 

[Malibu#27]

Recruiting Boomer, why isn't that ruthless? Who cares what the age is as long as the strategy is right?

Recruiting him at 38 would be single handedly the worst recruiting decision the club has made in 20 years.

 

[Malibu#27]

The time that Logan Austin sold candy to him twice in one play I realised Boomer was finished.

Absolutely. He's a one way player these days. Happy to run to get on the end of it, does jack shit the other way.

 

[Alfred_]

Absolutely. He's a one way player these days. Happy to run to get on the end of it, does jack shit the other way.

A North poster told me he is illergic to tackling.

 

[Magus]

I'm hoping that Dougal becomes a more consistent Westhoff styled player.

 

[Far Kern]

When is monfries and Ryder allowed to train?

In a couple of weeks I believe - early September.

 

[Lagooner]

The time that Logan Austin sold candy to him twice in one play I realised Boomer was finished.

I could watch it all damn day.

 

[JimmyBeerCans]

View attachment 281094

I could watch it all damn day.

Boomer turning slower than Tex after a few pots there

 

[FallingLiefs]

Have you considered he's been part of our group since 2007. A period where we haven't really done much. Potentially he's part of the problem?

so has Jay Schulz and Alipate Carlile, but they haven't been pushed out the door on this board for the same reasons have they?

 

[edgie]

so has Jay Schulz and Alipate Carlile, but they haven't been pushed out the door on this board for the same reasons have they?

Somewhat inconsistent but never mentally weak. Also have battled far more with injury than Hoff ever will.





Sent from my Lumia 800 using Tapatalk

 

[mightypowerrrr]

Can we upgrade a rookie for Howard next year? If we can, keep both snelling and krack on the rookie list and upgrade the one most determined for the single list spot.

Lobbe is a depth ruck. He doesn't want to leave (i think) and we should only encourage him to go if we are offered a good player or a first rounder. We would most likely get a pick 35 or so for him and would then have to acquire a another depth ruck. What is the point?

Carlile is contracted for next year unfortunately. Will be Depth

Schulz has been delisted and Butcher will be to. This leaves us with Howard, Westhoff and Dixon. Howard will go nowhere near it next season, so WE must keep Westhoff (unless we receive a godfather offer) as we have no depth. Hopefully Hoff can play more as a forward with Bonner developing and Hombsch returning, instead of playing as a loose. This means we MUST acquire another key forward, best circumstance to be in our best 22, but mostly for depth, especially if Hoff or Dixon get injured. Someone like Schoenmakers or Vickery (we may have to unfortunately pay overs) would suit us.

Our depth for talls and rucks isn't great and if we are to be contending next year, this must be improved. Depth has constantly let us down through 2015/16.

 

[Malibu#27]

Somewhat inconsistent but never mentally weak. Also have battled far more with injury than Hoff ever will.

How do you define mentally weak ?
* Missing goals ?
* Appears laconic on the field ?

I'm just trying to ascertain what makes Justin more or less mentally weak than any other player on our list.

 

[Hong-Kong Phooey]

we currently have 5 sub 180cm players on the list. I think this is too many.
neade - trade
snelling - keep - upgrade
mitchell - delist
Sam C - delist
Sam Gray - keep

 

[GcSunsfan]

Hey guys i come in peace. What's Brendan Ah Chee contract status ?