Player X v Y v Z

[Mitchell54]

Pendles. Erryday.

Think Pendles is picking up HBFASUMSCF. It’s a fever going around atm. It’s short for Half-Back Flank And Stuff Up My SuperCoach Fever.

 

[SC fish]

Greene

Thank me later

I don't have many "never again" players on my list but Greene is one of them after what he did last year.

 

[big_bazza]

Ive never had the Greene machine so hes ripe for the picking this year, i dont buy into the whole punchable face thing, i reckon hes just your average good Aussie bloke earning a crust kicking a ball around

 

[toxic]

Think Pendles is picking up HBFASUMSCF. It’s a fever going around atm. It’s short for Half-Back Flank And Stuff Up My SuperCoach Fever.

Jack Crisp is going back to HB.


Scott will play midfield

 

[Keg on legs]

Ive never had the Greene machine so hes ripe for the picking this year, i dont buy into the whole punchable face thing, i reckon hes just your average good Aussie bloke earning a crust kicking a ball around

Yeah, he is all that...... and with a punchable head to match.

 

[Hai_Newman]

I don't have many "never again" players on my list but Greene is one of them after what he did last year.

+1

 

[JuddgementDay]

Mids: Beams vs Treloar vs Gibbs
Def: Hanley vs McDonald vs Shaw

 

[King_Steele]

Mids: Beams vs Treloar vs Gibbs
Def: Hanley vs McDonald vs Shaw

Beams
Heater

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Mids: Beams vs Treloar vs Gibbs
Def: Hanley vs McDonald vs Shaw

ATM gone Gibbs out of those 3 .....and i'd go Hanley

 

[King_Steele]

Gibbs is a soft seagull.

Spewwwww

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Gibbs is a soft seagull.

Spewwwww

IIRC Ave 102 in a bottom side ......surely he'll have less pressure & more opportunities at the Crows ?

 

[King_Steele]

IIRC Ave 102 in a bottom side ......surely he'll have less pressure & more opportunities at the Crows ?

Is 102 a super premo though? Acceptable as M8.

Surely Crouch bros/Laird etc take most of the points?

 

[Keg on legs]

Mids: Beams vs Treloar vs Gibbs
Def: Hanley vs McDonald vs Shaw

Beams
McDonald

 

[JuddgementDay]

Thanks guys
Lol - 3 replies and one for each of the
3 defenders; back to square one :-(
atm 1. Hanley mid minutes 2. McDonald time to shine 3. Shaw so cheap

Mids
I like beams, but i don't really trust his body
Gibbs, you think he'll have to play out of his skin now - after the trouble with a 2 year trade period
Treloar - burnt me last year, but I'm tempted again

 

[Me Myself and I]

Thanks guys
Lol - 3 replies and one for each of the
3 defenders; back to square one :-(
atm 1. Hanley mid minutes 2. McDonald time to shine 3. Shaw so cheap

Mids
I like beams, but i don't really trust his body
Gibbs, you think he'll have to play out of his skin now - after the trouble with a 2 year trade period
Treloar - burnt me last year, but I'm tempted again

Tie breaker.
Beams & McDonald.

 

[Yoda_]

Nat Fyfe priced ($597,900)

OR

Dayne Zorko ($608,900)

Zorko is proven to be a worthy, reliable scorer, Fyfe's best is one of the best in SC.

 

[InFiction]

IIRC Ave 102 in a bottom side ......surely he'll have less pressure & more opportunities at the Crows ?

The opposite I reckon. 102 average in a rebuilding side full of opportunities? Surely he could have got his hands on more points than that? This includes his huge 208 score from last year as well.

If anything, the amount of gun SC players at the Crows will limit his ability to average more, and most likely force that 102 backwards.

I think he's an awesome pick up for the Crows, but find he'd be a huge risk in SC.

 

[ScrewInStuds]

I'm finding it really hard to split these options:

M. Crouch and Hanley

vs

Dunstan and Hurley

 

[Yoda_]

I'm finding it really hard to split these options:

M. Crouch and Hanley

vs

Dunstan and Hurley

Hardly a best 22 player imho

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

I'm finding it really hard to split these options:

M. Crouch and Hanley

vs

Dunstan and Hurley

option 1 all the way

 

[ScrewInStuds]

Hardly a best 22 player imho

I feel like it clicked for Dunstan at the end of last year and there's some significant upside there, but Saint's depth does worry me if he starts to slack off.

Option 2 also has a bit of risk due to Hanley's bye when I've already got Barlow up front. I appreciate the thoughts gents.

 

[ScrewInStuds]

Nat Fyfe priced ($597,900)

OR

Dayne Zorko ($608,900)

Zorko is proven to be a worthy, reliable scorer, Fyfe's best is one of the best in SC.

Fyfe, Zorko seems like he'll be the number one tag target at Brisbane - I feel like he's already priced at his maximum (is an under-rated gun though).

 

[Yoda_]

Fyfe, Zorko seems like he'll be the number one tag target at Brisbane - I feel like he's already priced at his maximum (is an under-rated gun though).

Zorko has been the #1 target for ages already though?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

The opposite I reckon. 102 average in a rebuilding side full of opportunities? Surely he could have got his hands on more points than that? This includes his huge 208 score from last year as well.

If anything, the amount of gun SC players at the Crows will limit his ability to average more, and most likely force that 102 backwards.

I think he's an awesome pick up for the Crows, but find he'd be a huge risk in SC.

Cheers for your thoughts .....there's no emotion in picking my SC side

 

[Keg on legs]

option 1 all the way

+1