Player X v Y v Z

[Judd_Magic]

Assuming he is fit - Jelly. He plays a great game for SC.

J.Kelly or Neale?

 

[King_Steele]

J.Kelly or Neale?

Kelly

 

[Hai_Newman]

Seems like a simple answer but I am flip flopping on my trades this week.

Rocky & Yeo with Sicily forward Vs. Wines & Gunston with Sicily back.

Any trade that involves my man Yeo, he's in very impressive form and a shoe in for top 3 defender.
Wines also looking like he's breaking out, can you get both?

 

[Judd_Magic]

Kelly

What makes you pick Kelly mate?

 

[Judd_Magic]

Ok I have a new one.

Which combo is the best out of the 2?

Nank, McDonald, Neale/J.Kelly

Or

Grundy, Rocky, Fritsch


Option A pretty obvious right?

I'd like all 3 of Grundy, McDonald and Neale/Kelly but think I am going to have to sacrifice one for now.

 

[Goats]

Any trade that involves my man Yeo, he's in very impressive form and a shoe in for top 3 defender.
Wines also looking like he's breaking out, can you get both?

Nope.

Going with Yeo is definitely the safer pick, there wouldn't be many in the top 1000 without him.

Head says Yeo & Rocky - gut says Wines & Gunston. I'm just going to get drunk Thursday afternoon (taking Friday off) and roll with it.

 

[Goats]

J.Kelly or Neale?

I'd go with Neale. Jelly's groins a worry.

 

[Hai_Newman]

Ok I have a new one.

Which combo is the best out of the 2?

Nank, McDonald, Neale/J.Kelly

Or

Grundy, Rocky, Fritsch


Option A pretty obvious right?

I'd like all 3 of Grundy, McDonald and Neale/Kelly but think I am going to have to sacrifice one for now.

I'd be looking hard at Grundys draw, I reckon that's the key to the decision.
Collingwood leave Victoria only 3 times in their last 10 games, 6 at the G...hmmm...

 

[Judd_Magic]

I'd be looking hard at Grundys draw, I reckon that's the key to the decision.

I don't think his draw gets any easier from here.

He has already beaten up on all the average rucks.

 

[Moustachio]

J.Kelly or Neale?

I'd take Jelly too... Both similar runs on the board and injury history, when in doubt pick the better talent imo.

 

[Moustachio]

Dusty or Crouch?

Want to turf one of these spuds - who would you keep and why?

 

[Hawkboy62]

Ok I have a new one.

Which combo is the best out of the 2?

Nank, McDonald, Neale/J.Kelly

Or

Grundy, Rocky, Fritsch


Option A pretty obvious right?

I'd like all 3 of Grundy, McDonald and Neale/Kelly but think I am going to have to sacrifice one for now.

Don't like Nank and I think he will tire as season goes on. Have you considered Ryder? I swapped Nank to him last week when he was cheaper than Nank. Still only 494k. I think he and The Hoff complement each other. Of course it's an extra trade but a superior team IMO.

Grundy has been huge but sometimes it is hard to maintain the level. Only takes a knock and his scores drop dramatically.

 

[zoomba23]

Dusty or Crouch?

Want to turf one of these spuds - who would you keep and why?

Imo keep Mrouch.

Scores better with Sloane in the team and hopefully will stop looking for cheap handballs.

 

[DT_35]

Which 3 player combo is the best.

OUT: Doedee + Henry + Coff
IN:
- Wines, Chad, Ahern
- Wines, Rockliff, Ahern
- Gray, Chad, Ahern
- Gray, Rockliff, Ahern

OUT: Nankervis + Doedee + Henry/Coff
IN:
- Grundy, Chad, Ahern
- Grundy, Rockliff, Ahern
- Nic Nat, Oliver, Ahern

Thoughts?

 

[Judd_Magic]

Don't like Nank and I think he will tire as season goes on. Have you considered Ryder? I swapped Nank to him last week when he was cheaper than Nank. Still only 494k. I think he and The Hoff complement each other. Of course it's an extra trade but a superior team IMO.

Grundy has been huge but sometimes it is hard to maintain the level. Only takes a knock and his scores drop dramatically.

Might hold onto Nank till closer to finals time.

For me I think McDonald and J.Kelly/Neale is more of a priority for me now as those 2 finish off my forwards and mids.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Might hold onto Nank till closer to finals time.

For me I think McDonald and J.Kelly/Neale is more of a priority for me now as those 2 finish off my forwards and mids.

FFS .......this board has just spent an hour telling me i can't have them

You are not helping my frame of mind

 

[Judd_Magic]

FFS .......this board has just spent an hour telling me i can't have them

You are not helping my frame of mind

Sorry man but when JM is on the up he has to bring in the cream of the crop and put the afterburners on Top Gun style.

 

[Hai_Newman]

Sorry man but when JM is on the up he has to bring in the cream of the crop and put the afterburners on Top Gun style.

 

[Axly]

Sidebottom v Wines v Bont

 

[Judd_Magic]

Sidebottom v Wines v Bont

Wines.

 

[Moustachio]

Sidebottom v Wines v Bont

Bont. Dont think Wines has the tank yet to keep up his recent scoring (check his TOG).

Bont vs JKelly?
Both I think can av 115+...
For Bont maybe the Macrae injury and Mclean hurt means he drops his fwd rotations.
For Kelly there is no role question but we have to hope he is over the groin.
Both similar ownership but JKelly currently 8 times more traded in for the round, so leaning towards Bont.

 

[Moustachio]

How about Kelly vs Wines vs Neale?

I am actually thinking I might go Neale now.

Love how he plays and a great POD.

Less risk than Kelly too imo as he is fully fit and no groin issues.

Do we know what was going on with Neale at start of year? Must have some niggle to explain scoring...

 

[Moustachio]

Crisp Vs Andrews vs Hurly ?

Crisp.

Building all season, no issues with role or injury, great pod, should play finals so not gonna choke for you in the last few rounds.

 

[Danger_zone]

Crisp.

Building all season, no issues with role or injury, great pod, should play finals so not gonna choke for you in the last few rounds.

Yeah. That's who ended up choosing. Thanks for validating my decision! =D

 

[JDavey]

Do I bounce Dusty, Crouch or Parker for Piggy Oliver?