Autopsy Roast/Toast R1 vs Carlton & Changes for R2 vs Port

[biaseddustyfan]

unfortunately carltoon are garbage so that BRAVE loss isn't as exciting as I want it to be

but also I think we could've easily won by 50 with a couple less corrupt umps and a couple less * ups from kmac/Bolton/Pickett and no injuries

 

[Ctl]

Brave and valiant effort in the end. We look a lot better when we play small, Grimes is better when he is set a task and has to play tall, doesn’t have the speed for the other forwards anymore.

Next week we play port who aren’t blessed with talls. Ollie lord is injured, Georgiades is out of the side. Grimes can take Marshall and Balta can take Dixon If he is sent back or we can bring in Miller for one game. Mcauliffe, Clarke and Briwn all had very impressive VFL games, I’d bring in Clarke over Mcauliffe as we already have Dow, Hopper, Taranto, in the side and I’d like to see more Bolton, Baker, Martin on ball time but Mcauliffe could easily come into the side instead. We can actually hold up pretty well despite the injuries.

In: Brown, Clarke, Miller/Lefau (depending on Balta)
Out: Prestia, Young, Gibcus
Sub: Mansell

 

[Triggering Tiger]

Anyone who was at the ground could see the agenda from the maggots. If you can’t see that you’re a fool.

Sonz, Clarke, mcauliffe and one of the talls in (Kosi or miller)

Pickett needs to * off

Yep i'm sure they could!

 

[Karp3_dm]

Balta is *en amazing
He's got potential to be best player in comp..

Carey like but with morals

 

[59Stanley]

Macca was decent tonight and Pickett was good in the ruck.
Dion is finished and Hopper disappears after half time.
Umpires screwed up big time and Martin needed to kick the goal

 

[Karp3_dm]

What’s best case for Gibcus?

 

[LTT]

the result was ultimately determined by the bog-ordinary 50 against Baker

You call that 50. The free was paid at the back of the square and baker ended up standing 30 m from goal

 

[Bojangles17]

Oh , yea was hopper shot at half time , he was huge first half with 20p , 5 in sec half , wtf

 

[Noidnadroj]

With the consistent crap from the umpires i sadly have to agree with your votes.
Curnows 3 1/2 minutes unmanned in the backline will get him over the line for the the three votes.
Any richmond supporter remember lynch ever playing in the back line to try save the game??

2020 PF v Port… Lynch took match saving mark in D50 with 5 seconds left.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Bojangles17]

What’s best case for Gibcus?

Jarred knee

 

[Antzzz]

Not saying we weren’t shafted after quarter time. When the heat was on in the big moments throughout the game, several of our players cost us badly with poor skill errors that lead to goals for them.

I agree

 

[sawyer]

Oh , yea was hopper shot at half time , he was huge first half with 20p , 5 in sec half , wtf

Did the same s**t last year

 

[lllscroatlll]

What’s best case for Gibcus?

badly jarred with bruising and torn meniscus but dont know what im talking about just ay eye-ing what i have read or heard tonight

 

[fargothegreat]

What’s best case for Gibcus?

Round 1 2025

 

[Truetiger]

What’s best case for Gibcus?

Doctor Google would have the answer. Poor kid, hopefully not as bad as it looked.

 

[sawyer]

Brave and valiant effort in the end. We look a lot better when we play small, Grimes is better when he is set a task and has to play tall, doesn’t have the speed for the other forwards anymore.

Next week we play port who aren’t blessed with talls. Ollie lord is injured, Georgiades is out of the side. Grimes can take Marshall and Balta can take Dixon If he is sent back or we can bring in Miller for one game. Mcauliffe, Clarke and Briwn all had very impressive VFL games, I’d bring in Clarke over Mcauliffe as we already have Dow, Hopper, Taranto, in the side and I’d like to see more Bolton, Baker, Martin on ball time but Mcauliffe could easily come into the side instead. We can actually hold up pretty well despite the injuries.

In: Brown, Clarke, Miller/Lefau (depending on Balta)
Out: Prestia, Young, Gibcus
Sub: Mansell

View attachment 1928100

Yeah I agree I think Clarke should come in for shais spot in the fwd line and shai takes prestias spot as mid/half fwd

 

[Lord of the Wings]

What’s best case for Gibcus?

Round 1 2025.

 

[lllscroatlll]

umps have done one good thing

ive gotten so munted on copium im gone man g

 

[Daka]

What’s best case for Gibcus?

probably a medial but they would have tested him it's pretty much confirmed ACL, the knee rocking test is accurate as.

 

[Ancient Tiger]

Changes:

Out:
Gibcus
Young
Prestia
MJR

In:
Miller (just need height down back)
Brown
Clarke
McAulliffe or Sonsie

 

[Black Saab]

Still heading home from the game. Much, much better effort.

What the hell happened to Carlton?? Are they already at their peak?? Where was the monster demolition job? Huge handout from the umps to boot and they barely win. Lucky they didn't face the Sun's this week instead of us eh??

 

[Groupie_]

we will belt them in RD16 when Lynch and Dusty are in full flight

im officialy in protest mode not watching until it stops

 

[Hoos]

Glad we took the points but all things considered you guys deserved the win

I hate that expression. No, we didn't deserve to win, because we didn't win. Too many dumb mistakes. We had our chances and blew it. We got what we deserved.

 

[Coach_Required]

Think I'm done with AFL this year, might just watch our VFL games.
No one cares, Richmond won't even ask the AFL questions on why we give away frees but never get those same calls back or why we always have a negative differential every damn week.
Commentators tell us every free kick we give is there and the ones we do somehow get are soft.
It's an utter joke, so from now on I won't spend time watching any games, might even deliberately watch NRL games to piss the AFL off.

 

[Bojangles17]

Worth mentioning I dddged a bullet end of game after walking down 4 flights of stores , right at the bottom some kid fell down a few stairs and cannoned into my knee , lucky my mountain goat legs braced the contact , so easily could have crumbled and done my ACL, ohh kid was alright too