Competitions SC and DT for Swans - only place for dt/sc answers.

[Bonz]

Is Mitchell likely to be the sub here on in?

I wouldn't think so, but knowing out coaching staff and our depth in the midfield it could eventually happen.

 

[christoff91]

I wouldn't think so, but knowing out coaching staff and our depth in the midfield it could eventually happen.

Thanks for your reply. Im trying to figure out if he will make a good M8 or not?

 

[Bonz]

Thanks for your reply. Im trying to figure out if he will make a good M8 or not?

I plan on using him as one for the moment, But am wary so will make sure I have a playing emergency (i.e Kmart) and a non playing midfielder to sub him out to just in case.

 

[bestin]

Can someone tell me a little about Mitchell, haven't had the chance to watch him play yet.

 

[Stan_Darsh72]

I am contemplating trading in Josh Kennedy for Cotchin and i am wondering how has his form been this season and would Hanners or McVeigh be potentially better trades.

 

[bestin]

I am contemplating trading in Josh Kennedy for Cotchin and i am wondering how has his form been this season and would Hanners or McVeigh be potentially better trades.

Don't sideways premiums just yet, wait a few more weeks until the last few rounds. Trades are precious!

 

[SM]

Don't sideways premiums just yet, wait a few more weeks until the last few rounds. Trades are precious!

Not in DT if that's what he's playing?

 

[Ed_Gein]

Even then, Kennedy is not a DT type player i would have thought. But i don't play DT to be honest.

 

[SM]

Even then, Kennedy is not a DT type player i would have thought. But i don't play DT to be honest.

He does quite well in DT.

 

[MC Extra Dollop]

Thoughts on Jed Lamb as a downgrade option? What sort of role is he expected to play and how many more games could you see him getting?

Thanks in advance.

 

[Bonz]

Thoughts on Jed Lamb as a downgrade option? What sort of role is he expected to play and how many more games could you see him getting?

Thanks in advance.

If we were at full fitness I wouldn't expect him to get a heap of games, and his more likely to be sub at this current point in time than not sadly.

 

[Danair]

He does quite well in DT.

Been shocking the last three weeks, I'm only keeping him in because we got Melbourne and GWS the next two weeks.

 

[Werewolf]

What's the job security of Xavier Richards like? I need a DPP downgrade. Cheers

 

[swansfan51]

What's the job security of Xavier Richards like? I need a DPP downgrade. Cheers

Would be quite concerned if he got another game this year.

 

[Danair]

Pre Lockout decision, Malceski (leaning towards), Ibbotson or Hibberd for Birchall?!

 

[Commissioner Gordon]

Hey lads, what's the job security like for B Jack? Need a downgrade in my midfield.

 

[S120]

Hey lads, what's the job security like for B Jack? Need a downgrade in my midfield.

Pretty good for now although I can't see him averaging a big score as a small forward. He had been pretty much minding Lewis Jetta's spot in the 22 but after yesterday's performance, it will be hard to see him drop completely out of the rotation any time soon. In the short term, he probably overtook Jed Lamb yesterday so he will probably start for the next few weeks but he will be a good sub option when we have our injured players start to filter back into the side.

 

[Commissioner Gordon]

Pretty good for now although I can't see him averaging a big score as a small forward. He had been pretty much minding Lewis Jetta's spot in the 22 but after yesterday's performance, it will be hard to see him drop completely out of the rotation any time soon. In the short term, he probably overtook Jed Lamb yesterday so he will probably start for the next few weeks but he will be a good sub option when we have our injured players start to filter back into the side.

Thanks mate, have O'Meara sitting on the pine who i want to cash in so thinking a downgrade might be the go. My other bench spot is Crouch so i have that back up there in case Jack is in and out a bit.

 

[Slawk]

Who do you guys reckon is the more solid option for supercoach:
ROK or McVeigh?

 

[Bonz]

Who do you guys reckon is the more solid option for supercoach:
ROK or McVeigh?

ROK is a better supercoach scorer.

Whilst both players will constantly get scores between 90-110 ROK has the potential to get some massive scores, that and he has a lower break even this week so wil be going up in value.

 

[Slawk]

ROK is a better supercoach scorer.

Whilst both players will constantly get scores between 90-110 ROK has the potential to get some massive scores, that and he has a lower break even this week so wil be going up in value.

Cheers, it's the massive scores that I'm looking for!

 

[Bonz]

Cheers, it's the massive scores that I'm looking for!

If you really want to go someone from the Swans you would probably go Jack, might cost just a tad more but his scope is higher than both ROK and McVeigh.

 

[Ed_Gein]

RO'K seems a bit like Boyd in a way. Butcher the ball a bit can harm him, but can get the big scores through weight of numbers.

 

[Doggies7]

Hi guys, just wondering with Goodes I see he is still listed as 4 weeks away from returning. In my elite league we have 2 rounds left then finals so probably not worth keeping him. Have you heard anything in regards to him returning early or do you think it's likely he will be back playing AFL in 4 weeks from now? Thanks and please smash the Eagles this weekend

 

[swansfan51]

Hi guys, just wondering with Goodes I see he is still listed as 4 weeks away from returning. In my elite league we have 2 rounds left then finals so probably not worth keeping him. Have you heard anything in regards to him returning early or do you think it's likely he will be back playing AFL in 4 weeks from now? Thanks and please smash the Eagles this weekend

Goodes is literally the only player on our list where I would trust the medical reports. He has a fantastic record of not missing many games, and is hugely professional in the way he prepares. If anyone else on our list was "3-4 weeks" then I'd tell you to write them off for the year.