Votes v Ess

[cairo tiger]

1. Newman
2. Cotch
3. Rance

unlucky vicks, lids, nahas, Jake

 

[Vitriol]

3 Cotchin
2 Rance
1 Browne

 

[Puntroad]

4. Cotchin
3. Rance
2. Vickery
1. Browne

 

[Crumden]

3. Cotch
2. Lids
1. Rance

Newman not far behind those three.

 

[captain blood 17]

3 - Rance. Was a rebounding general tonight
2 - Cotchin.
1 - Vickery. Took out Gadget man.
.5 - Browne.

 

[Rustof]

3. Rance
2. Cotch
1. Lids

 

[delediofan3]

3. Cotchin
2. Deledio
1. Rance

 

[Rubber Hips]

1 Chris Newman
2 Trent cotchin
3 Andrew browne
4 Alex rance
5 Brett deledio/Tyrone vickery

 

[TheProwler]

1. Cotch by a fair margin




Fairly even for the next group

Browne, great job in his 6th or so AFL game. Beat the opposing rucks and put himself in the right spots. Lets hope Gus was watching.

Rance, Effort was exceptional, disposal was perhaps the best I have seen from him. Well done Rance

Conca, great first 3 qtrs and drifted out a liitle in the last.


Honourable mentions for Newman, Grimes, Nahas and Vicks.

 

[Car Ramrod]

3 Cotchin
2 Rance
1 Newman

 

[Tigerland]

3 - Rance
2 - Cotchin
1 - Browne

 

[nut]

4. Cotchin
1. Deledio
1. Rance

 

[richoatthedisco]

5. Cotchin. Magnificent.
4. Deledio. Gun.
3. Rance. Best game yet.
2. Newman. So cool.
1. Vickery. Worms Tugga, worms.

 

[RichosGuns]

Rance was elite tonight

 

[Gentlemen]

5. Cotchin - Star, Elite, Brilliant, Gun
4. Rance - Best game of his career
3. Delidio - Star, Elite, Brilliant, Gun
2. Vickery - Very good
1. Browne - What a game from the young man


Mentions : Newman, Conca, Grimes, Riewoldt, King

 

[Lamp]

3. Trent Cotchin
2. Brett Deledio
1. Alex Rance

 

[happy_punter]

5. deledio
4. cotchin
3. rance
2.vickery
1. grimes (so so so good before the hammy, best game yet)

 

[harimal12]

3 Rance
2 Deledio
1 Cotchin

Special mention Browne and Newie

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

1...Defensive game plan...

2...Newman...

3...cotchin...

4...rance...

5...grimes...

6...delideo...

 

[El Tigre]

3 - Cotch
2 - Rance
1 - Big Browne Dog

1st game Big Browne Dog played was in front of 80K+ people, and we were pantsied big timem and now this. He is certainly experiencing the highs and the lows.

Unlucky...
King - played his now usual great game
Vickery - continues to do his part
Grimes - his defensive efforts are 1st class, and has far more scope for improvement than any of the other defenders
Newman - had a shocker last week

Room for improvement...
Grigg - we all know why
Post - didn't do any of the things that Miller did (crash packs) and really struggled to get any penetration on his kicks, which is his biggest worry.

 

[criticize]

3. cotch
2. delid
1. newman


unlucky king + rance.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

3. Cotchin
2. Newman
1. Browne

SPECIAL MENTION TO TYRONE! GO BIG T!

 

[Tiger67]

5/ Cotch
4/ Rance
3/ Lids
2/ Grimes
1/ Vickery

Nice to have a game where it is hard to decide based on too many good players
Conca Browne Newie King and Martin could all have been in the votes and the fact Jack kicked 4 goals and is not in any list of best players is evidence of our improvement.

 

[Woodstock]

I think we could squeeze Brent Stanton in for a vote, he was great for us tonight

 

[mcuzzy]

5- cotchin - so courageous, always looks like he wants to win more than any other player
4- deledio - classy and very calm with the ball
3- rance - probably our best defender tonight
2- Newman - probably his best game this season
1- Martin - just a very solid game

Special mentions to our forward line players especially jack who always knew when to free up a team mate or if he knew he needed to go for it. Beautiful crumbing too